You cannot use this version of the applic…
apple Verified ·
Imported from the Apple Support Forums via the Wayback Machine 🔗
I just installed 10.5.8 (9L30) via Software Update and now my Mail doesn't work. Instead, I get a dialog box that says "You cannot use this version of the application Mail with this version of Mac OS X." When I run it out of Terminal from /Applications/Mail.app/Contents/MacOS/Mail it runs fine, even though it is Version 3.5 (which is what shows up when I do Get Info on the Mail application in the Applications folder). This is really poor, Apple. This is basic stuff -when you upgrade the OS you have to make sure all the Apps work. How are you going to fix this?
9 replies
Sign in or join Beachball Help to reply.
- 0
thomas_r. ·
Imported from the Apple Support Forums via the Wayback Machine 🔗
Are you asking Apple? They're not listening here. This is also not something for Apple to fix. It is something for you to fix. Do you really think all the folks at Apple are so stupid as to release a system update that breaks Mail?
Something certainly went wrong with your update. Did you verify your hard drive and repair permissions before installing? If not, you should have. Even if nothing is wrong with those, there's still a chance you had a corrupt file somewhere. I would advise trying to reinstall the update using the [10.5.8 combo updater|http://www.apple.com/downloads/macosx/apple/macosx_updates/macosx1058up date.html], which often helps with these sorts of problems.
- 0
amborodin ·
Imported from the Apple Support Forums via the Wayback Machine 🔗
Apple obviously are stupid enough to release an update that broke mail.. I am not the only one who has posted with this problem. No, it is not something for me to fix - updated OS's should work with previous versions of apps.
No i didn't verify anything before installing because Software Updater is automatic and does not ask you whether you want to verify HD or repair permissions. This was an automatic download. Nowhere does it say you should do this.
Thanks for the link, I will try this. But nonetheless, why should I download a software update twice? Windows does not have such issues with updates - they never break apps.
- 0
thomas_r. ·
Imported from the Apple Support Forums via the Wayback Machine 🔗
Apple obviously are stupid enough to release an update that broke mail..
Then how do you explain all the people saying they've had no problems with the update? (Oh, and "Apple are"???)
No i didn't verify anything before installing because Software Updater is automatic and does not ask you whether you want to verify HD or repair permissions.
I see. So, do you not brush your teeth in the morning because your computer doesn't tell you to?
No matter whether you use a Mac or Windows machine, you need to do some basic maintenance from time to time to keep things working smoothly. Macs, overall, tend to need less, but you still need to check the hard drive from time to time, and you
definitely never want to install an OS update if there's a chance you've got hard drive problems.Windows does not have such issues with updates - they never break apps.
LOL!
- 0
amborodin ·
Imported from the Apple Support Forums via the Wayback Machine 🔗
Thomas A Reed wrote:
Apple obviously are stupid enough to release an update that broke mail..
Then how do you explain all the people saying they've had no problems with the update? (Oh, and "Apple are"???)
Not everyone had the problem. Good for them. More than one person had the problem - and perhaps even more will experience it. That means there is a hole in the update process - i.e. something does not work properly in all situations. Apple is not God - they stuff up sometimes, innit? Stop defending them.
No matter whether you use a Mac or Windows machine, you need to do some basic maintenance from time to time to keep things working smoothly. Macs, overall, tend to need less, but you still need to check the hard drive from time to time, and you
definitely never want to install an OS update if there's a chance you've got hard drive problems.So if that's the case, why design an "automatic" Software Update utility that does not do a check of HD integrity if it is so vital to do such a check before installing an OS upgrade? Does that make any sense? Where do Apple recommend such a check prior to installing an OS upgrade? It's not immediately obvious do the average user. Apple have gone out of their way to make claims like "you never have to defrag a Mac". They don't mention anything about HD checks. If it's so fundamental, why not? Is it unreasonable to think that a company that prides itself on good design would think of this?
Thank you for the link for the consolidated update. That fixed it - except that it should have worked first go from the auto updater.
- 0
thomas_r. ·
Imported from the Apple Support Forums via the Wayback Machine 🔗
Not everyone had the problem. Good for them. More than one person had the problem - and perhaps even more will experience it. That means there is a hole in the update process
That's like equating a runny nose with the swine flu. That's only one possible cause for a runny nose... others include another variety of flu, an ordinary cold and allergies. You're confusing a symptom with a cause. Many people can easily have the same problem without having the same cause. This sort of thing happens with *every single update*, no matter how stable the update is. People see patterns where none actually exist, because only the subset of people having problems are posting... and people whine and blame Apple on these forums every single time.
You can choose to continue to do this, in which case you'll have to simply accept the problem (since "Apple did it to you") or can choose to address the issue and find and solve the root cause for yourself.
- 0
Ernie Stamper ·
Imported from the Apple Support Forums via the Wayback Machine 🔗
Some limited search of recent topics talks about similar reports -- see:
http://discussions.apple.com/thread.jspa?threadID=2107139&tstart=0
and
http://discussions.apple.com/thread.jspa?threadID=2107017&tstart=0
Ernie
- 0
David Fairbanks ·
Imported from the Apple Support Forums via the Wayback Machine 🔗
Had the same problem...
It appears as if the old mail program gets moved to a previous system folder and and a new mail program is placed into the applications folder. The dock link to the old mail program does not get relinked to the new program so you have to do it manually. - 0
amborodin ·
Imported from the Apple Support Forums via the Wayback Machine 🔗
Thomas, you did not address the fact that there is no information whatsoever that comes with any of the Apple update processes (either manual or automatic) that recommends a disk verification. If you say this is such an essential step in performing upgrades, then why isn't it at least mentioned by Apple? Don't you think it would be reasonable for them to mention it if it is such an important thing? Or at least, build it into the automatic update process? No?
- 0
radiorobot ·
Imported from the Apple Support Forums via the Wayback Machine 🔗
I cannot believe the dumb-ness of the above threads. Thank you for a solution. I got around to the current update and had the same problem. Fixing the dock link worked.