Benches macOS

9

AC3 Audio and Quicktime 7.6 Problem

apple Verified

Imported from the Apple Support Forums via the Wayback Machine 🔗

I was wondering if anyone else is having a problem with opening an audio file with the .ac3 extension in the updated Quicktime 7.6?

What I have been doing, for a couple of years now, is that I capture a TV program from my DVR using the firewire port. Once the file is loaded on my Mac, I then open MPEG Streamclip, trim out the commercials, Export to Quicktime using H264 and 2 channel AAC audio, after the export is done, I would then do a Demux to AC3 to get a separate audio only file containing the 5.1 surround sound.

I would open the .ac3 audio only file, open the .mov video file (both in Quicktime). I would then copy the 5.1 audio track from the .ac3 file, Go to the .mov file, perform Edit/Add to Movie. This way I would have 2 audio tracks, AAC a 2 channel track and AC3 a 6 channel track.

But now with Quicktime 7.6, I cannot open the .ac3 file at all, I get "The file is not a movie file." error message with no error code.

Any suggestions?

Thanks,

Bill

9 replies

Sign in or join Beachball Help to reply.

  1. 0

    PCor

    Imported from the Apple Support Forums via the Wayback Machine 🔗

    Hey there, YES... on my G5 PPC Tiger 10.4.11, I get the same error. However on my Mac Book Pro [Intel] 10.5.6 ac3 files open - but they load - before there just used to be a delay [spinning ball] and it would open. I'm playing around with some ideas - I'll let you know if I figure anything out - cause it's causing me a real headache. If you anyone hits on a solution - Please post Thanks.

    -----It's odd Streamclip can still deal with ac3 - demuxing, opening, converting on both machines.

  2. 0

    belloq

    Imported from the Apple Support Forums via the Wayback Machine 🔗

    There's a generally major issue with QT 7.6 and AC3, whether by itself or embedded in other file types like m4v or mkv.

    Apple has totally borked being able to use AC3 with this last update. Implore your friends to refrain from updating.

  3. 0

    Jon Walker

    Imported from the Apple Support Forums via the Wayback Machine 🔗

    I was wondering if anyone else is having a problem with opening an audio file with the .ac3 extension in the updated Quicktime 7.6?

    Very strange. I have an external drive set up with just the system software and one or two added codecs like MPEG-2 Playback and Perian for testing purposes. H.264/AC3 file plays fine on this system as startup but the same file won't play on my main system if booted. I assume there is either a conflict in the QT components or one of the startup applications on the main startup drive. Both drives have the same current OS (10.5.6) and QT (7.6) versions.

    User uploaded file

  4. 0

    Boliver

    Imported from the Apple Support Forums via the Wayback Machine 🔗

    POSSIBLE SOLUTION

    I think I have discovered a way to workaround the AC3 5.1 sound problem.

    I found an old 20GB drive and installed Tiger 10.4 onto the drive. I then downloaded the "MacOSXUpdCombo10.4.11PPC.dmg" file and updated the system to Tiger 10.4.11. I performed all of the updates (System Security updates and the Java updates) through Software Update except for iTunes and QuickTime.

    I then downloaded the "QuickTime755_Tiger.dmg" file from Apple and updated to QuickTime 7.5.5

    DO NOT UPGRADE TO 7.6

    I then opened the TV show in QuickTime 7.5.5, I extracted the audio file from the program and saved as a separate audio file (it saves as a .mov file).

    I opened this audio file in QuickTime 7.5.5 and then exported the audio

    selecting Export Movie to QuickTime movie,

    clicked on the options button,

    the sound box should already be checked,

    clicked on the settings button,

    under the Format drop down I clicked on AAC,

    Channels: I clicked on 5.1,

    then Rate:48.000,

    checked on Show Advanced Settings,

    Quality: Normal,

    Encoding Strategy: Constant Bit Rate,

    Target Bit Rate: 384

    (used MediaInfo Mac to gate this information),

    clicked OK,

    Clicked OK,

    then named the file, saved it and then waited for audio to be converted from AC3 5.1 to ACC 5.1.

    If you now open up this file in QuickTime 7.5.5 it is an ACC format with 5.1 and plays fine.

    I then restarted to my regular drive with QuickTime 7.6 loaded and it plays the audio file without any problems.

    I'm sure that there must be a way to repackage the AC3 audio file in an AAC container that will work better and faster, but for now this seems to work, so I am going to try some other shows that I have.

    Let me know if this works for others.

    Bill

    Message was edited by: Boliver

    Message was edited by: Boliver

  5. 0

    Boliver

    Imported from the Apple Support Forums via the Wayback Machine 🔗

    POSSIBLE SOLUTION

    I think I have discovered a way to workaround the AC3 5.1 sound problem.

    I found an old 20GB drive and installed Tiger 10.4 onto the drive. I then downloaded the "MacOSXUpdCombo10.4.11PPC.dmg" file and updated the system to Tiger 10.4.11. I performed all of the updates (System Security updates and the Java updates) through Software Update except for iTunes and QuickTime.

    I then downloaded the "QuickTime755_Tiger.dmg" file from Apple and updated to QuickTime 7.5.5

    DO NOT UPGRADE TO 7.6

    I then opened the TV show in QuickTime 7.5.5, I extracted the audio file from the program and saved as a separate audio file (it saves as a .mov file).

    I opened this audio file in QuickTime 7.5.5 and then exported the audio

    selecting Export Movie to QuickTime movie,

    clicked on the options button,

    the sound box should already be checked,

    clicked on the settings button,

    under the Format drop down I clicked on AAC,

    Channels: I clicked on 5.1,

    then Rate:48.000,

    checked on Show Advanced Settings,

    Quality: Normal,

    Encoding Strategy: Constant Bit Rate,

    Target Bit Rate: 384

    (used MediaInfo Mac to gate this information),

    clicked OK,

    Clicked OK,

    then named the file, saved it and then waited for audio to be converted from AC3 5.1 to ACC 5.1.

    If you now open up this file in QuickTime 7.5.5 it is an ACC format with 5.1 and plays fine.

    I then restarted to my regular drive with QuickTime 7.6 loaded and it plays the audio file without any problems.

    I'm sure that there must be a way to repackage the AC3 audio file in an AAC container that will work better and faster, but for now this seems to work, so I am going to try some other shows that I have.

    Let me know if this works for others.

    Bill

  6. 0

    belloq

    Imported from the Apple Support Forums via the Wayback Machine 🔗

    I think I followed what you did, and am therefore pretty sure that you do not have Dolby AC-3 5.1 digital surround, but you do have Dolby Prologic II. Or, have you tested it with a receiver that, when you plug in the digital optical cable, the amp specifically says it's receiving a Dolby Digital signal? From what you've written, I would be quite surprised.

  7. 0

    Boliver

    Imported from the Apple Support Forums via the Wayback Machine 🔗

    Presently I have no way of testing the files to verify that they are indeed AC-3 5.1 surround sound.

    I got the idea of converting these files after viewing the "Quantum of Solace", "Terminator Salvation" and "Watchmen" trailers downloaded from the iTunes movie trailers site. The properties showed that the audio file was AAC with 5.1 channels.

    Sorry for misleading you.

    Bill

  8. 0

    Boliver

    Imported from the Apple Support Forums via the Wayback Machine 🔗

    *I forgot to add to my previous reply:*

    Since I was not getting any audio (other than noise), I had to convert the file anyway. The only way, for me, was to convert it using a previous version of QuickTime (7.5.5) starting up on another drive.

    At least now I can hear audio using the newest versions of iTunes and QuickTime and the original Front Row. So maybe this might help someone else at least get their audio back.

    Bill

  9. 0

    Matteo Cacciari

    Imported from the Apple Support Forums via the Wayback Machine 🔗

    Solved... maybe

    I add the AC3 codec developed by sourceforge projects

    http://sourceforge.net/projects/qtac3codec/

    now quicktime 7.6(472) is able to open .ac3 files