Benches macOS

8

Apple Mail.app and Gmail frustrations whe…

apple Verified

Imported from the Apple Support Forums via the Wayback Machine 🔗

Gmail and Mail.app are driving me mad. AOL, Yahoo, .Mac, my own personal servers, no problems with them and imap behavior.

I was curious if anyone has figured out how to get gmail working with Mail.app in a way that addresses this issue:

Gmail, by design has an archive feature called All Mail. It just appears as a folder in Mail.app, but in the web interface it's a special folder. The idea behind it is that you can archive things out of your inbox and have them stored in the All Mail folder and always have those messages available for future searches and reference without cluttering up your inbox.

This seems to cause problems if you try to delete an email with Mail.app, whether deleting it in the Inbox or the All Mail folder. In the web interface for Gmail, deleting a message in either folder will delete the message in both places, but in Apple Mail.app, if you delete it in either one, the message is not deleted in the other location. This becomes very annoying because you essentially have to delete every mail twice if you're using Mail.app.

I'm not sure if this a google or an apple problem, and if it can be worked around by tweaking settings in Mail.app.

My current settings in Mail.app are inline with Google's recommended settings for Apple Mail applications as found on their website.

IMAP Path Prefix is blank, but I've tried setting it to All Mail, which does not work properly because then you lose access to the other folders (gmail labels).

I've also tried setting the inbox to All Mail in mail.app.

I actually don't think it's a Gmail issue, because I have an iPhone with Gmail setup as imap, and it works just the way it is supposed to, delete a message from the inbox and all copies of the message are deleted from the account.

Any ideas?

8 replies

Sign in or join Beachball Help to reply.

  1. 0

    DamonBrandt

    Imported from the Apple Support Forums via the Wayback Machine 🔗

    When using Apple Mail with IMAP gmail the delete button is equal to gmail archive button. If you want mail to be deleted move the message to the gmail imap trash folder.

    You should not use the all mail folder as your inbox in Apple mail. By design the only mail in all mail is mail not in the spam, trash, or sent mail folders. All mail is the same as your itunes music library and other folders are like play lists.

    Does that help?

  2. 0

    DamonBrandt

    Imported from the Apple Support Forums via the Wayback Machine 🔗

    When using Apple Mail with IMAP gmail the delete button is equal to gmail archive button. If you want mail to be deleted move the message to the gmail imap trash folder.

    You should not use the all mail folder as your inbox in Apple mail. By design the only mail in all mail is mail not in the spam, trash, or sent mail folders. All mail is the same as your itunes music library and other folders are like play lists.

    Does that help?

  3. 0

    RodneyW

    Imported from the Apple Support Forums via the Wayback Machine 🔗

    It should work if you click on the "Gmail/Trash" folder, then

    Mailbox menu -> Use this mailbox for -> Trash.

    Now, anything you delete will go into the Gmail Trash folder, and it will also be deleted from All Mail (and any other location that you may have labelled it with).

  4. 0

    DamonBrandt

    Imported from the Apple Support Forums via the Wayback Machine 🔗

    I haven't tried that. We kinda like the auto archive feature of the default delete button action. I'll check that out and see if we like it. We have set the gmail drafts folder to be used as drafts, which is really nice. You can start a email in one place, web or aMail, an finsh it in the other place.

    D

  5. 0

    RodneyW

    Imported from the Apple Support Forums via the Wayback Machine 🔗

    We kinda like the auto archive feature of the default delete button action. I'll check that out and see if we like it.

    I like the consistency of using the Gmail trash folder as the Mail trash. Delete then means .... Delete.

    If I move a message from my Inbox to a sub folder, it is automatically archived and labelled in Gmail. If I don't want to label a message, but I do want to archive it - I simply move it to All Mail - and Gmail is smart enough to not create a duplicate!

    The only remaining problem I have is that every labelled message is stored twice on my hard drive and results in two spotlight search results. I avoid wasting hard disk space by setting preferences to not download attachments.

  6. 0

    DSA1

    Imported from the Apple Support Forums via the Wayback Machine 🔗

    Thank you very much. That explains the reason it's working the way it does, at least, even though when I push the DELETE button, I expect the message to be DELETED, ie, go to the trash can. LOL.

    A star for helpful for the answer, but the solved goes to Rodney whose tip produces the desired results.

    Take care.

    😉

  7. 0

    DSA1

    Imported from the Apple Support Forums via the Wayback Machine 🔗

    {quote:title=RodneyW wrote:}

    I like the consistency of using the Gmail trash folder as the Mail trash. Delete then means .... Delete.

    If I move a message from my Inbox to a sub folder, it is automatically archived and labelled in Gmail. If I don't want to label a message, but I do want to archive it - I simply move it to All Mail - and Gmail is smart enough to not create a duplicate!

    Read my 7:28 PM response above which I was drafting at the same time you wrote this. EXACTLY what I want, DELETE to mean DELETED, sent to trash, gone from my life, never to be seen again, etc, etc. LOL.

    Thanks very much for your tip. I thought I had done that, but obviously not. I had done the set inbox to inbox, drafts to drafts, etc, but missed trash to trash.

    At any rate problem SOLVED.

    Thanks again.

  8. 0

    George Pan

    Imported from the Apple Support Forums via the Wayback Machine 🔗

    RodneyW wrote:

    The only remaining problem I have is that every labelled message is stored twice on my hard drive and results in two spotlight search results.

    You can solve the spotlight problem by adding the /Library/Mail/[email protected]/Gmail/All Mail.imapbox folder into the Spotlight Privacy list in System Preferences. You can also avoid storing all messages in the All Mail box on your hard drive by following my suggestion in the following converstation, but some people have reported problems: <http://discussions.apple.com/message.jspa?messageID=7406454#7406454&gt;

    George