What's a good data organizer?
apple Verified ·
Imported from the Apple Support Forums via the Wayback Machine 🔗
I'm looking for a data organizer and am overwhelmed by all the different ones....like SOHO, DevonThink, Yojimbo, and many more. Do any of you use one of these things and why do you like it over the others? I'm leaning toward Yojimbo....but.......
7 replies
Sign in or join Beachball Help to reply.
- 0
amember ·
Imported from the Apple Support Forums via the Wayback Machine 🔗
Now I'm leaning toward DevonThink.... I just love talking to myself. Maybe I should have posted this in the Software department?
- 0
amember ·
Imported from the Apple Support Forums via the Wayback Machine 🔗
No, DevonThink doesn't have an adequate Notes section. Just everything else. Shucks.
- 0
Yer_Man ·
Imported from the Apple Support Forums via the Wayback Machine 🔗
iTunes is an excellent data organiser - if your data is music. iPhoto is good if your data is photographic... or to put it another way, your question is too vague. What kind of data are you organising? Does it come in different formats? Text? Pdf? What?
Some general considerations for any data organiser:
How easy is it to get material in?
What kinds of material does it support
How good is the search?
How easy is it to get data out again?The last is a particularly important consideration. Migrating can be a bear with some of these apps.
I've tested and experimented with many of these apps. FWIW
Avoid SOHO. Every time they update or upgrade the app there are significant problems.
DevonThink is just the job if you're doing a Doctorate. If you're trying to snip quick fixes from these forums to remember later, then it's overkill.
Circus Ponies NoteBook is extremely good. Has excellent searching, and even has an automatic index of everything in the NoteBook. But for my Money it's tortured by the NoteBook metaphor. Might be right for you though.
Together is a fine app, does very well.
Yojimbo scores highly in some ways but the organising is too limited for me.
Journler is also very good, based around a Journal metaphor. MacJournal is similarIn the end, the one that had the best mix of features and flexibility for me was EagleFiler.
You can search for all of these apps on
MacUpdateRegards
TD
- 0
amember ·
Imported from the Apple Support Forums via the Wayback Machine 🔗
Terence, thank you for your comprehensive answer. I'm interested in organizing basically everything that's most meaningful to me on my computer into one program, but now resides in many places there. I tried most of those you mentioned but will go now to look at EagleFiler!
- 0
Roger Barre ·
Imported from the Apple Support Forums via the Wayback Machine 🔗
I've tried them just about all of them and have a somewhat similar take on all this as Terence.
I've been using DevonThink Pro for some time and find it rock-solid, but strangely unsatisfying. The feature set is quite rich, but the emphasis seems to be on AI and creating links and other things that may be overkill for the average user. The interface is boring, almost DOS-like. It's good, reliable, but a little finicky sometimes, and I've had problems getting Spotlight to consistently find things that I wanted in it.
Circus Ponies Notebook and AquaMinds Notetaker are both excellent, but I too find the "notebook metaphor" often limiting. They're very good at what they do, but I prefer a 3-pane organizer so I can see everything at once, not have to hit tabs to change sections and pages.
Yojimbo seems good, but the inability to nest folders within folders is a tremendous limitation for me. If that's not an issue for you, it seems like a lovely program.
I have lately moved everything over to MacJournal and am very happy with it for a lot of reasons: a three-pane organizer works the way I want to work ... Spotlight works very well with it ... the interface is easy, intuitive and pleasing ... you can put any kind of document in (text, graphics, audio-visual, .htm, etc.) ... you can re-size graphics ... you can nest folders within folders (or Journals within Journals as they would say) ... and a host of other reasons. I've actually moved into it all my DevonThink docs, and all my Notebook and NoteTaker projects. I had been using all three programs because each did certain things better than others ... but it's nice having them now all under one roof.
You can download a trial version at http://www.marinersoftware.com.
And finally ... I'm using OmniOutliner for all my note-taking and outlining, and love it to pieces.
Hope this helps.
rb
- 0
Ashka ·
Imported from the Apple Support Forums via the Wayback Machine 🔗
I've been using MacJournal for several years going back to the free ware version. It has never let me down.
- 0
amember ·
Imported from the Apple Support Forums via the Wayback Machine 🔗
Thanks for the good responses and opinions. I sort of think DevonThink is to 'strict', if that means anything, like what was said...almost DOS-like, too much for me.
I'm going to look at MacJournal again. I really like Journler, but it's a little limited. I'm giving Curio a good try because it's more of an all-in-one Fun thing.