Benches macOS

1

.webarchive renders in Safari without ima…

apple Verified

Imported from the Apple Support Forums via the Wayback Machine 🔗

In Safari v3.2.1 without any plugins installed, I click FILE -> SAVE AS.. -> Format: Web Archive, and save a web page on my desktop.

I then double click the saved .webarchive while connected to the Internet, a Safari window opens and the page displays correctly. The page however does not render instantly, indicating that content (i.e. images) is still downloaded off the internet (the blue progress indicator in the URL/address bar moves in steps slowly). After Safari is done rendering, I hit Cmd+w and close the window.

I now unplug my network cable, and my Mac is not connected to the Internet. I double click the .webarchive again, a new Safari window pops up and renders the saved page. This time the images do not render; instead, a small blue question mark appears where the images should be.

What's going on? Why doesn't the webarchive contain all script, css, and image files so that the page can be rendered in Safari while offline?

I tried with a different site, and the problem did not appear. The .webarchive renders properly both when online and offline. One difference between the two sites is that the former requires a login before the saved content can be accessed. I run another test to identify how the login status affects the situation:

With the Mac connected to the Internet, I open my first .webarchive in Safari. Like before, the page renders correctly with the images. I do not disconnect the network cable like before, but instead I logout from the site (via a different Safari window pointing to the corresponding live website). I now try opening the .webarchive again, and the images are not rendering!!

What the..? I hope the answer is not that Web Archives work only with sites that do not require user login... Any help greatly appreciated.

Many thanks

1 reply

Sign in or join Beachball Help to reply.

  1. 0

    welljim

    Imported from the Apple Support Forums via the Wayback Machine 🔗

    Nobody? It can't be that rare, somebody else must have seen that..!?