Notes and To Do : Unable to save to IMAP …
apple Verified ·
Imported from the Apple Support Forums via the Wayback Machine 🔗
For some reason, Apple Mail can't create the folders necessary on the IMAP server ("Notes" and "Apple Mail To Do").... even if I create these folders manually, the notes/todo's still can't be saved ....
Is anyone getting these issues on their own IMAP servers?
I would really prefer that second folder not called "Apple Mail To Do" ... it should just be "To Do" ...
OR
Apple should give an option to specify which folder to use for To Do's and Notes (like they give you for inbox/sent/drafts/trash/junk)
Anyone else having issues? 😟
15 replies
Sign in or join Beachball Help to reply.
- 0
flyingout ·
Imported from the Apple Support Forums via the Wayback Machine 🔗
I'm seeing this problem with my Fastmail account (Cyrus, I believe). The Notes folder was created successfully, however, on both my .Mac account and on my local IMAP server (UW-IMAP).
My working theory is that it has something to do with the Fastmail server being one of those that store folders within INBOX whereas UW-IMAP and .Mac create folders at the same level as INBOX. I don't have enough examples to generalize though. Maybe some specifics from those of you who are either seeing the problem or not will help.
Hopefully this will be fixed or a workaround can be found. I would like to store notes on the server.
- 0
badtz ·
Imported from the Apple Support Forums via the Wayback Machine 🔗
You're right, the server that worked for me stored the two folders at root level.
On the server that doesn't work, it seems like I put it at root level (according to webmail) but I have a feeling it's putting it as a child of the Inbox (on webmail it shows as root, but on my iPhone, it shows it as a child of the inbox) .... I wonder if this can be fixed server side ...
- 0
RocketAlchemist ·
Imported from the Apple Support Forums via the Wayback Machine 🔗
I am having this problem it appears. Mail continually tries to save a To Do, fails to create the folder, gives a dialog box to say it failed, and trys again.
And again.
And after about 10 tries .. crashes.
Making Mail unusable.
- 0
badtz ·
Imported from the Apple Support Forums via the Wayback Machine 🔗
Has anyone been able to figure this out? I still don't use the notes/to do feature in Mail because it simply doesn't work 😟
Would be much nicer if we could specify the folder for notes and todos like we can with the inbox/sent/drafts/junk/trash ....
- 0
Tony Burch ·
Imported from the Apple Support Forums via the Wayback Machine 🔗
Now in 10.5.2 the problem seems to have turned around somewhat...
I too had a problem with not being able to create ToDo folders on fastmail.fm IMAP servers. I had no problem with .Mac or another IMAP server.
So I directed Mail.app in Prefs, to create ToDos 'On my Mac'.
Come 10.5.2, despite the exact same settings, Mail has created IMAP folders for ToDos on the two servers that can do this, but then continuously attempts to 'contact the server' without apparent success. Neither can I delete these errant mailboxes! Dunno what to do. Mail hasn't crashed yet, but revolving cogwheels against the server icons makes me scared. - 0
kelly_hirano ·
Imported from the Apple Support Forums via the Wayback Machine 🔗
i seem to be having a similar problem, but actually don't want the solution that apple is pushing on me. about every hour, i get the following dialog box:
Mail needs to change the IMAP path prefix for account “Work” to create the “Apple Mail To Do” mailbox. Do you want Mail to change the prefix now?
The mail server reported your IMAP path prefix as “INBOX”, but that prefix is not used in the account’s Advanced preferences. Mail can change it for you.
(Change) (Don't Change)it sounds like this dialog is intended to solve the problem that the folks on this thread are complaining about. however, i don't want to add the prefix; i want things as they are. does anyone know how to turn this off?
Message was edited by: kelly_hirano
- 0
JustTed ·
Imported from the Apple Support Forums via the Wayback Machine 🔗
I am having the same problem too, since 10.5.2. I ask Mail not to change it. I don't want to mess with my IMAP folders if I don't have to. Any advice is appreciated.
- 0
JeredF ·
Imported from the Apple Support Forums via the Wayback Machine 🔗
I'm having a very similar problem with Cyrus IMAP. Each iteration of Mail seems to be making things a bit worse...
BACKGROUND:
I use Cyrus as an IMAP server, which keeps mailbox names by default of:
user.
user1
user.
user1+.+subfolder
user.
user2
etc.For the logged in user, "user.
logged-in-user" is automatically aliased to INBOX, so my folders (as Mail sees them) are:
INBOX
INBOX.social
INBOX.work
etc.Additionally, I have some shared list archives that have names like:
lists.
list1
lists.
list2
etc.This is, I believe, a rather standard set-up for Cyrus, which is pretty widely deployed.
Note that my IMAP path prefix in Mail is empty, which is the only setting giving remotely appropriate results, see below.
MAIL BEHAVIOR (pre-10.5):
Before Leopard, Mail worked mostly OK. My top-level INBOX shows as "Inbox" under the Mailboxes section, and the subfolders appear as subfolders. The shared folders appear under a separate sidebar section with the name of the account. The only problem is that I am unable to manage subscriptions to the shared folders, so I get them all, even the ones I don't want to read.
MAIL BEHAVIOR (10.5.0, 10.5.1):
Mail complains occasionally about not being able to create its Todo folder.
MAIL BEHAVIOR (10.5.2):
Mail prompts constantly to change the IMAP path prefix to "INBOX". This is very bad. when the IMAP path prefix is set to "INBOX", the behavior is as follows:
1) Only the top-level INBOX appears as Inbox under Mailboxes.
2) Sub-folders of INBOX are shown in the separate sidebar section, not as under Inbox.
3) Shared folders are not at all accessible.I reset my IMAP path prefix back to "", which makes Mail usable again, but it incessantly prompts to change it. This is really a pain.
IPHONE BEHAVIOR:
The iPhone MobileMail inconsistent in behavior with Mail. With an empty IMAP path prefix, only the top-level INBOX is shown. With an IMAP path prefix of "INBOX" all subfolders are available, however unread counts are never automatically updated. Shared folders are not accessible.
SUMMARY:
Up until 10.5 there had been steady improvement here, but now things have slipped back a bit. I like Apple Mail a lot more than Thunderbird, though, so I really hope this can get sorted out in a not-to-distant update!
- 0
JosephDP ·
Imported from the Apple Support Forums via the Wayback Machine 🔗
I would just like to add a bit to this discussion, as I'm having similar problems.
*Background on the Mac side*: upgraded from 10.4.11 to 10.5.2 in the normal steps, with all updates. I had a lot of problems with iSync problems among dot-Mac, iPhone, and MissingSync for PalmOS, and multiple crashes per day with 10.5.0 & 10.5.1. With 10.5.2, I've begun getting the "Mail needs to change the IMAP path prefix for account…" for creating the "Apple Mail To Do" folder. In Mail.app, I have a dot-Mac account, six IMAP accounts, and one POP3 account set up. The dot-Mac, the POP3 and three of the IMAP accounts sync with the iPhone, all account information sync through dot-Mac among my laptop and two iMacs, and I also read these accounts in VersaMail on the Palm, and through webmail.
I only get the error in reference to "Apple Mail To Do" and haven't received anything about "Notes" though no "Notes" folder has been created.
*Background on the Server Side*: Five of the IMAP accounts are under our control, residing on a Red Hat Enterprise Linux server using Plesk 8.2 and Courier-IMAP 3.0.8-rhel4.build82070706.15 and QMAIL 1.03-rhel4.build82070807.17 with SpamAssassin and Dr. Web AV. The directory structure on the server is
/var/qmail/mailnames/domain.tld/username/Maildir/
with the Inbox being in ./cur/ and ./new/ and all other subfolders being in ./.specificSubFolderName/ under the ../Maildir/
The first time that I received the message, I allowed Mail.app to change the Advanced Preferences for that account to have the prefix "INBOX" - all subfolders disappeared, and in looking at the info for that account, no folders showed for subscription. I changed the Advanced Preferences so that the prefix was blank, and all mail in the Inbox disappeared, even though the count of unread mail was unchanged. Closing and restarting Mail.app with the prefix field in Advanced Preferences left blank, returned the subfolders, including a new "Apple Mail To Do" folder. However, Mail.app goes back to giving the message asking to change the prefix to "INBOX" so that it can create the "Apple Mail To Do" folder.
Message was edited by: JosephDP
- 0
Justin D'Onofrio ·
Imported from the Apple Support Forums via the Wayback Machine 🔗
Having the issue as well with 10.5.2 asking
constantly about changing the IMAP path prefix to store ToDos, even though I have... well, Notes... as NOT to save to the server.Not sure what is up with Leopard. Mail.app's IMAP worked
forever until 10.5. Under 10.5 and 10.5.1, it was the "Can't add a new mailbox without changing the path prefix." Why? What on earth changed between 10.4 and 10.5 to make it need the path prefix? It works fine without it!Now on 10.5.2, I still can't make new folders without changing, then changing back, the path prefix, AND it constantly nags me about ToDos.
- 0
Joshua Kaufman ·
Imported from the Apple Support Forums via the Wayback Machine 🔗
Same thing here. Annoying as all get out. It's worked fine up until now without changing the IMAP path prefix. Why does it have to do it now so badly?
Apple, please make it stop!
- 0
bo.erichsen ·
Imported from the Apple Support Forums via the Wayback Machine 🔗
I've got exactly the same problem as the people above. Just wan't Apple to listen.
/bo
- 0
kidhack ·
Imported from the Apple Support Forums via the Wayback Machine 🔗
while i'm composing a note I often see two duplicate notes in my inbox. when i delete one, it deletes that one and all the content from the note i'm working in and there is no way to retrieve the data. it *****.
- 0
Skeuomorph ·
Imported from the Apple Support Forums via the Wayback Machine 🔗
Now in 10.5.2 the problem seems to have turned around somewhat...
Also turned around: I'm unable to NOT save to the IMAP server. In Mail's preferences, under Composing, I have "Create Notes & To Do's in: On My Mac", and it only creates To Do in the IMAP accounts. Notes are created "On My Mac".
Anyone fooling with the issues here happen to have encountered/solved this?
- 0
Tony Burch ·
Imported from the Apple Support Forums via the Wayback Machine 🔗
Skeuomorph wrote:
Also turned around: I'm unable to NOT save to the IMAP server. In Mail's preferences, under Composing, I have "Create Notes & To Do's in: On My Mac", and it only creates To Do in the IMAP accounts. Notes are created "On My Mac".Anyone fooling with the issues here happen to have encountered/solved this?
MacFixit suggests: Quit Mail.app (or in my case force-quit!) then create a ToDo in iCal, then relaunch Mail. So far, so good!
Otherwise you have to get the sledgehammer out, quit Mail and delete the offending IMAP mailbox from ~/Library/Mail. It will force Mail to recreate the mailbox.