Benches macOS

15

Spaces issue

apple Verified

Imported from the Apple Support Forums via the Wayback Machine 🔗

Okay so I love Spaces, definitely helps me avoid window clutter .. but there is one very bothersome and seemingly buggy aspect to it: when i quit an application or hide an application, it will often automatically switch to a an undesired space. The culprit is usually the finder as I always have finder windows open in all my spaces, and it seems to switch to these at random. Is there any way (through terminal possibly? which i unfortunately have no experience with) to only have it switch spaces when I manually tell it to do so?

15 replies

Sign in or join Beachball Help to reply.

  1. 0

    mbh069

    Imported from the Apple Support Forums via the Wayback Machine 🔗

    There is a way to do that through the operating system if i'm understanding you correctly. If you go into your system preferences there should be a spot there in which you can choose certain spaces for certain applications. Make sure that is blank. That is no applications selected for certain spaces. This should allow you to move windows around freely only when you choose and not when the computer wants to. However if you have a safari window open in space one and you're in space 3 > then you click on the safari icon in the dock, it won't load another window of safari but will rather switch you to the space with the already open safari window. Unfortunately there is no way of changing that through the OS. Hope this helps

  2. 0

    Ferd II

    Imported from the Apple Support Forums via the Wayback Machine 🔗

    Adam,

    Choose Expose & Spaces>Spaces>{+} Other>Macintosh HD>System>Library>Core Services>Finder>Add

    Then make sure that you choose "Every Space" for Finder.

    ;~)

    User uploaded file

  3. 0

    Adam Weinberg

    Imported from the Apple Support Forums via the Wayback Machine 🔗

    For me that area is already blank. Maybe I wasn't clear with the issue. Let's say I have 2 spaces, and have Finder windows open in both. How does the OS know which Space is associated with the Finder? The problem almost always happens when I intentionally or unintentionally switch from one app to the Finder and it will switch to an undesireable space. It's frustrating.

  4. 0

    Adam Weinberg

    Imported from the Apple Support Forums via the Wayback Machine 🔗

    Now that you mention it .. is there any way of setting the Finder to a particular space? That way I would know which Space it was always going to switch to and at least it would be predictable. There doesn't appear to be a way of doing this though.

  5. 0

    dobes918

    Imported from the Apple Support Forums via the Wayback Machine 🔗

    Well, yes, there is a way to assign it to one space. Open the space assignment panel in System Pref>Spaces, then navigate to System>Library>Core Services>Finder.app, select it, and choose which Space you want to assign it to.

  6. 0

    Adam Weinberg

    Imported from the Apple Support Forums via the Wayback Machine 🔗

    Great, thanks for the help everyone!

  7. 0

    Adam Weinberg

    Imported from the Apple Support Forums via the Wayback Machine 🔗

    hmmm .. though i that did seem like the logical solution, that didn't exactly do what i was hoping. first, if you set the finder to every space, then your open finder windows actually stay present in any space you switch to. and if you chose a specific space for the finder, it will still switch automatically to that space (for example) every time i click on the desktop. i would like to find a way of spaces never switching automatically, just when i tell it to do so.

  8. 0

    mbh069

    Imported from the Apple Support Forums via the Wayback Machine 🔗

    Unfortunately that is normal behavior. This issue won't only occur with finder but with all applications such as safari. If you open a safari window in space 1 and then navigate to space 3 then click on the safari icon in the dock it will bounce to space 1 where safari is open. In order to get it in multiple windows you will have to open up a new finder window and move it to multiple spaces in order to have finder in multiple windows. Hope this helps

  9. 0

    Adam Weinberg

    Imported from the Apple Support Forums via the Wayback Machine 🔗

    yea i understand it's normal behavior .. i was hoping that through terminal or some other way i could disable the automatic switching. it's frustrating.

  10. 0

    dobes918

    Imported from the Apple Support Forums via the Wayback Machine 🔗

    Although it doesn't bother me as much, I agree that it would be helpful to be able to turn off the automatic switching. Sometimes, when I close an application in one Space it's because I want to open another one there, and the automatic switch to one that is open in another Space already is a little annoying. Though, as I said, it really doesn't bother me much -- I just switch back, and it takes less than a second to do it.

  11. 0

    dobes918

    Imported from the Apple Support Forums via the Wayback Machine 🔗

    If you write this:

    defaults write com.apple.Dock workspaces-auto-swoosh -bool NO

    into Terminal, your Spaces should stop switching automatically. BUT they also won't switch when you click on the icon on the dock. If you use it, you will have to switch Spaces manually through F8 or arrow keys every time. I don't use it because I want Spaces to switch through the dock icons. Good luck!

  12. 0

    Adam Weinberg

    Imported from the Apple Support Forums via the Wayback Machine 🔗

    thanks a lot. can i just literally copy and paste that one line into terminal and that's it? i never mess with it. also, if i make this change and then want to revert it, can i do the same thing except change the NO to YES? appreciate the help

  13. 0

    dobes918

    Imported from the Apple Support Forums via the Wayback Machine 🔗

    Yes -- and it is reversible. Again, I haven't tried it because I want Spaces to switch when I hit the application on the dock.

  14. 0

    Bruce Etnyre

    Imported from the Apple Support Forums via the Wayback Machine 🔗

    I agree that, I too, really like Spaces, but it took some getting used to. I had to change the way I had grown accustomed to working. Spaces isn’t going to change any time soon that we know, so that meant I needed to change to adapt to Spaces (difficult for an old dog like me).

    I have used Quickeys for many years and to change applications I assigned an F-key to my most commonly used applications. This was convenient so I didn’t need to move my hand from the keyboard to my trackball, move the cursor to the dock and roll around looking for the application I wanted to bring it to the front of all the clutter of applications I needed open. Also, I was developing repetitive stress pain from ‘mousing around’ so much.

    Learning to use Spaces was like learning to walk again. It took some stumbling, but now I can sprint. I liked your idea of having the Finder open in all Spaces. That way I could click on the desktop or double click my hard drive icon in any Space and I wouldn’t be switched to another Space.

    I also found that I learned very quickly which Space was related to which application and instead of using the Command-tab and scrolling through the applications I now almost automatically use the key combination of Control-number on the numeric keypad to get to the workspace I wanted.

    Space 1 has e-mail and a calendar, 2 is iChat and Safari (I often want to look up stuff while chatting), 3 is Excel (I do a lot of spreadsheet work), 4 is Firefox with streaming music, and 5 is Word. If I’m in Excel and I get an e-mail notification, Control-1 will take me there. I don’t use the F-key functions assigned by Quickeys much anymore. As you pointed out, there is a minor annoyance (I guess the level of annoyance is in the eye of the beholder) of Spaces sometimes automatically switching to an undesired Space. But a quick Control-number zaps me right back to where I was. Also, I’ve learned than when Spaces slides off to the right, from Space 3 to Space 2, I almost unconsciously hit Control-right-arrow to go back to Space 3.

    This is just my system and may not be optimal for you, but if you understand how Spaces is going to work and you think about how you can change to take advantage of it in the most efficient way, you will probably quickly learn to optimize the interface, just like how you automatically scroll to the dock or quickly press Command-tab to change applications. I think Spaces is a much better method than either of those, but it takes some practice, just like it did to learn those other maneuvers.

  15. 0

    Adam Weinberg

    Imported from the Apple Support Forums via the Wayback Machine 🔗

    i appreciate the advice / personal experience .. sometimes it's just hard when you have a workflow really engrained in you to switch things up. i'll give it a shot though!

    i want spaces to do something very simple for me, and it's just frustrating that it's so close to being exactly what i want, it would take so little for it to be perfect for my workflow. i'm a video editor and am constantly media managing, and i have an obscene amount of harddrives.. i like to have all the finder windows for each respective HD open simultaneous so i can keep track of drive contents / capacity. these finder windows for my 8 or so HDs take up the entire desktop, so it's great to be able to dedicate a Space just for this entire window layout. the problem is that it's
    always switching to that space when i don't want it to - only 10% of the time i'm on my computer do i spend in that space. hopefully i'll be able to adapt to it eventually though! :P