Benches macOS

4

Why is Firewall disabled by default?

apple Verified

Imported from the Apple Support Forums via the Wayback Machine 🔗

I cannot understand why Apple would do such a thing. If your computer is hooked directly up to a cable modem. You have absolutely no security. This is a terrible thing to do. What's even worse is that if you had Firewall on in Leopard. Even if you do a upgrade to Snow Leopard it turns the Firewall off??!!!!

4 replies

Sign in or join Beachball Help to reply.

  1. 0

    K T

    Imported from the Apple Support Forums via the Wayback Machine 🔗

    Quoting from elsewhere on the 'net...

    -=-=-=-

    Short story:

    If you do a clean install to a blank or erased disk,
    Snow Leopard will set the firewall to OFF by default, just as Leopard did.

    In the Security pane of System Preferences, click the Advanced button in the Snow Leopard Firewall tab to get to the rest of the options found in the Leopard Firewall tab.

    Long story:

    When Leopard arrived, Apple changed the interface to the Mac OS X firewall and caught a fair amount of flak as a result for the confusing way the options were offered. (It also made things worse by deciding to turn the firewall off by default.) In Snow Leopard, it has retained the application-based part of firewall services but has tried to simplify the presentation. The tab now opens with a note of whether the firewall is on or off, a Start/Stop button, and at the bottom, an Advanced button

    The Advanced button opens a sheet that present basically the same options as those found in Leopard. But Snow Leopard replaces Leopard's three confusing radio button options (Allow all incoming connections, Allow only essential services, and Set access for specific services and applications) with a single straightforward checkbox "Block all incoming connections." Below that is a scrolling list, carried over from Leopard, that shows which services have been made available (through the Sharing pane) and which specific applications have been either allowed or denied incoming access. As in Leopard, "essential services" (Bonjour, DHCP, and IPsec) are always allowed to accept incoming connections regardless of user settings, but you can now block access to File Sharing and other services.

    Note: If you install Snow Leopard over an existing Leopard system, it will pick up your basic firewall settings (along with many other settings). However, if you do a clean install to a blank or erased disk, Snow Leopard will set the firewall to OFF by default, just as Leopard did

    In all, the Snow Leopard firewall is not a big change from Leopard, but it's a step forward for clarity. If you're looking for something beefier and more flexible, you do have some third-party firewalls to choose from, such as Open Door Networks' DoorStop X Security Suite. (Open Door's notes on the Snow Leopard firewall are a brief but interesting read, as well.)

  2. 0

    John Scott1

    Imported from the Apple Support Forums via the Wayback Machine 🔗

    OK well it sounds as though Apple thinks many of its user cannot figure out the Firewall settings so it just turns them off? Not much better then the Wireless Router manufactures I guess who leave security off too for WIFI. I guess for the same reasons. I think it would be nice to at least have a setup window that pops up informing the user that the Firewall is turned off and the options the user has to enable it.

  3. 0

    varjak paw

    Imported from the Apple Support Forums via the Wayback Machine 🔗

    You can make suggestions to Apple regarding Mac OS X by submitting feedback here:

    http://www.apple.com/feedback/macosx.html

    You have absolutely no security.

    This is not true. Unless you turn on the various sharing and remote connection settings/options in Mac OS X, it would be very difficult for anyone to access your system even with the firewall turned off. I've never had the firewall set up on any of the many systems that I've managed over the years and have never had an exploit or even any evidence of an attack, and my home systems are connected to cable (and have been for several years). So I think having the firewall turned off by default is the best option as it's least likely to cause problems for a user. Those who feel the need for additional precautions can turn it on.

    Message was edited by: Dave Sawyer

  4. 0

    donv_the_ghost

    Imported from the Apple Support Forums via the Wayback Machine 🔗

    There is no great reason for the firewall to be disabled. On the other hand, given that we live in MacLand, there currently is no great reason for the firewall to be enabled. As mentioned above, Apple had a reason for disabling it that overwhelmed the pretty much nonexistent need for immediate protection of users.