Snow Leopard Requires Password After Disp…
apple Verified ·
Imported from the Apple Support Forums via the Wayback Machine 🔗
After upgrading to 10.6 today, I noticed that every time my computer sleeps the display (my Energy Saver preferences are set to do this after 1 minute), that Snow Leopard wants my password to wake it. Under 10.5.8, it only asked for my password to wake from full sleep.
Here is the problem - I either push the display sleep wait timer to a longer interval and sacrifice battery time or I disable the Security preference that I want to enter my password when waking from sleep. I do not like either of these options, as I should be able to enjoy long battery life and the security of a password-locked laptop, without the hassle of entering my password after a mere display sleep.
Are there any alternatives to these options or way to work around this problem?
15 replies
Sign in or join Beachball Help to reply.
- 0
thomas_r. ·
Imported from the Apple Support Forums via the Wayback Machine 🔗
There's a new feature in Snow Leopard... Go to System Preferences -> Security -> General and check out the new pop-up next to the "Require password" check box.
- 0
swtfoley ·
Imported from the Apple Support Forums via the Wayback Machine 🔗
Thanks for that suggestion, but that does not solve the problem. It simply let me choose an amount of time that my Mac will be unsecured, i.e., I display sleep at 1 minute to maximize battery life and full sleep at 3 minutes, so using the intervals of that "Require password" dialogue, I either choose between one minute of secured time that I do not want or two minutes of unsecured time that find unacceptable - especially for those instances where I close the Mac, immediately putting it into full sleep.
Any other ideas?
- 0
thomas_r. ·
Imported from the Apple Support Forums via the Wayback Machine 🔗
So set it for 5 seconds. If you're right in front of the machine, reading something on the screen, and the screen shuts off, you'll be able to press a key right away. You should also be aware that, if someone gets their hands on your laptop, this won't protect your data in any way. Encryption is the only thing that works... anything else can be bypassed fairly easily, given enough time alone with the machine and a system install disk.
- 0
Kahlil Pfaff ·
Imported from the Apple Support Forums via the Wayback Machine 🔗
I am having this issue too. Setting the "5 second rule" only helps if I am at my desk and can stop it from locking, but other times I don't need or desire the system to lock as it does when the display sleeps. If I am out in public I would close my MacBook or lock it if I wasn't going to be using it for a while, but there are times when I don't mind the display sleeping...I would just rather not having to keep entering my password every time the display goes black, such as when on battery.
I miss the way that 10.5.8 did it...I don't think it is asking too much for that to be added back, it wasn't a problem or bug that needed to be removed.
- 0
Eric Tiffany ·
Imported from the Apple Support Forums via the Wayback Machine 🔗
Yes, I've noticed this too.
The option in the Security Preference (General) pane says "Require password (menu) after sleep or screen saver begins". However, when my screen goes in to *display sleep* it requires a password; this is neither
sleep nor +screen saver+. My settings for sleep and screen saver are set to Never.Either the Security Preference option wording is wrong, or the password locking is being applied incorrectly. So one of these things needs fixing.
I would prefer that the 10.5 behavior be restored.
- 0
Allen Dulles ·
Imported from the Apple Support Forums via the Wayback Machine 🔗
I too am annoyed by this.
The only workaround I've found is to turn off "require password" in the security setting and use the little lock symbol you can put in the toolbar at the top of the screen. Choose Lock Screen before putting computer to sleep.
That way the display will sleep and not require a password to wake and a password will be required to wake the computer.
It's inconvenient and doesn't cover all contingencies, but it's the best that can be done till Apple hears our pleas and fixes this bug.
- 0
PeroDelMar ·
Imported from the Apple Support Forums via the Wayback Machine 🔗
I've just upgraded my work MacBookPro and this is really a problem for me - lots of time I sit in front of my computer, but am doing something else. Then I want my screen to go off to save battery, but when I touch the keyboard I want to be able to continue working - I don't want to enter password.
But when I put my computer to sleep - I want to be asked for password.
What annoys me the most is that this was working just fine since 10.3 at least and is now broken.
- 0
thomas_r. ·
Imported from the Apple Support Forums via the Wayback Machine 🔗
All this fuss baffles me. Are you guys all aware that this really provides no better than protection against casual snooping? I think you're putting more trust in this password protection than it deserves. If someone has physical access to your computer and wants your data, it wouldn't take more than a few minutes for them to bypass your security. The only real way to protect your data is to encrypt it.
- 0
Eric Tiffany ·
Imported from the Apple Support Forums via the Wayback Machine 🔗
Thomas,
I think you have missed the point of this thread. We are not concerned with security in this case, but convenience. I suspect most of the people on this thread are working at home, or are using their home computer, and are not worried about unauthorized access if the computer is left unattended for some period of time.
The issue is this: when you return to your computer after it has gone into display sleep, you are required to unlock the screen with a password. This behavior is a change from 10.5 (and earlier) where simply hitting a key or moving the mouse would wake up the display. It is also at odds with the behavior implied by the wording of the sleep preference pane. So the conclusion is that this is unintended (certainly undesired) behavior, and thus a bug.
- 0
thomas_r. ·
Imported from the Apple Support Forums via the Wayback Machine 🔗
We are not concerned with security in this case, but convenience. I suspect most of the people on this thread are working at home, or are using their home computer, and are not worried about unauthorized access if the computer is left unattended for some period of time.
Then what's the point of having the password turned on at all? If you don't actually need security, why activate a security feature that is both annoying to you and not secure at all anyway?
[...] So the conclusion is that this is unintended (certainly undesired) behavior, and thus a bug.
That's a pretty questionable conclusion. Display sleep is a kind of sleep, so the wording is only inconsistent if you're
looking for a reason to call it a bug. And if everything that changed between Leopard and Snow Leopard were a bug, then the 64-bit support must be a bug! - 0
Eric Tiffany ·
Imported from the Apple Support Forums via the Wayback Machine 🔗
Thomas A Reed wrote:
Then what's the point of having the password turned on at all? If you don't actually need security, why activate a security feature that is both annoying to you and not secure at all anyway?I agree that the password protection is not particularly secure, but it does afford some protection from more casual snooping. For example, if I am in a meeting and need to leave for a few minutes, I will lock my screen (with password required to unlock). The 10.5 behavior would allow this, while not requiring a password to wake the display.
That's a pretty questionable conclusion. Display sleep is a kind of sleep, so the wording is only inconsistent if you're
looking for a reason to call it a bug. And if everything that changed between Leopard and Snow Leopard were a bug, then the 64-bit support must be a bug!Oh, please. The wording on the pref pane is the same for both 10.5 and 10.6 (as near as I can remember). But the behavior is different. So would you say that the 10.5 behavior is wrong, or the 10.6? Or is the wording in 10.6 wrong? Either way, it's a bug (with either 10.5 or 10.6).
And that one change has no implication that every change is a bug -- that's a logical leap that falls pretty far short.
- 0
thomas_r. ·
Imported from the Apple Support Forums via the Wayback Machine 🔗
if I am in a meeting and need to leave for a few minutes, I will lock my screen (with password required to unlock). The 10.5 behavior would allow this, while not requiring a password to wake the display.
Why not just turn on fast user switching (System Preferences -> Accounts -> Login Options), then use the fast user switching menu to go to the login screen? That gives you the ability to secure the machine against casual snooping on demand, rather than attaching it to some other activity.
Oh, please. The wording on the pref pane is the same for both 10.5 and 10.6 (as near as I can remember). But the behavior is different.
Both behaviors fall within the same wording. Why should Apple change it? Changing it like you want would require a check box with multiple lines of text, which is bad from an HIG standpoint.
Either way, it's a bug (with either 10.5 or 10.6).
If you believe it's a bug, that's your choice. I think it's a silly idea, but regardless, this isn't the place for it. Go report it on the [Apple feedback page|http://www.apple.com/feedback>.
And that one change has no implication that every change is a bug -- that's a logical leap that falls pretty far short.
The logic was not mine. Trimming out some of the irrelevant bits from your earlier post (scroll up to see the full text), you said:
This behavior is a change from 10.5 [...]. It is also at odds with the [...] wording of the sleep preference pane. So the conclusion is that this is unintended [...] behavior, and thus a bug.
I agree, that's pretty shaky logic.
- 0
D Mack ·
Imported from the Apple Support Forums via the Wayback Machine 🔗
I'm having the same problem people mentioned. Display sleep now triggers password. It's VERY frustrating.
I used to display sleep on my machine for when I "walk away" but am still working on it. Saves power, increases the life of the display, etc....
--Now I have to enter my password every time I walk away. (ie, constantly)I used a screen saver hot corner to "lock" my screen when I'm done.
--Still works unless I disable 'require password' for the first problem which now makes this a problem.Please note this has *nothing to do with "security"*. I've been using the password screen saver just to prevent random typing from my small children playing or my cat who firmly believes my keyboard is very humorous place to sit.
I'd me quite happy if Apple fixed this "feature" which removes functionality, but until then... I'd love to hear work a around.
- 0
Anthony Caltabiano ·
Imported from the Apple Support Forums via the Wayback Machine 🔗
I must say that I had hoped 10.6.2 would address this issue. It's very frustrating to me as well as most everyone else on this thread. Sad to see it just might be here to stay.
VERY annoyed.
- 0
Толян ·
Imported from the Apple Support Forums via the Wayback Machine 🔗
I agree!!!! I want to have my screen sleep and NOT be required to entire a password when I wake it. When I close the lid and the laptop sleeps is when I want it to prompt for a password. 10.5.x worked like this, why can't 10.6.x
Here are the steps I use for a workaround:
1. Never let the display sleep. (That defeats the purpose of "energy saving settings" and also is not feasible on battery. AND, it shortens the life of my display!!)
2. Set Require Password to immediatelyNow I can walk away and have lunch or whatever while working at home and when I come back I don't have to enter a password. When I actually leave or "need" it locked, I just close the lid.
Whoever came up with the bright idea to change this setting should be flogged.
ARRGGGHHH!!