Benches macOS

2

An Applescript error appending to list ob…

apple Verified

Imported from the Apple Support Forums via the Wayback Machine 🔗

Try this on your machine....

Step 1: Paste this script into your Script Editor and Save it to any file name you want to give it.

Step 2: Run the script and hit Command-S to save the script.

-------

set xLimit to 8144

set aList to {}

repeat with I from 1 to xLimit

set end of aList to I

end repeat

-----------

This should work just fine.

Step 3: Now change the value of 8144 to 8145 and run the script

-- no problem either ... UNTIL you TRY TO SAVE THE FILE.

Control-S, File/Save and File/Save as ...don't work.

Script Editor says "The document xxxx.scpt could not be saved"

I also tried this on a different computer with the same result.

Both machines are up on the latest version of Leopard and I am running

on my Imac which is configured as follows:

Model Name: iMac

Model Identifier: iMac8,1

Processor Name: Intel Core 2 Duo

Processor Speed: 3.06 GHz

Number Of Processors: 1

Total Number Of Cores: 2

L2 Cache: 6 MB

Memory: 4 GB

Bus Speed: 1.07 GHz

Boot ROM Version: IM81.00C1.B00

SMC Version: 1.30f1

Now I also tried this with Script Debugger 4.5.2 (Latest release)

Here the error on saving is more precise:

" Cannot Save Document

Signaled when the runtime stack overflows

(errOSAStackOverflow:-2706)"

The error is in CocoaSpeak but a Stack Overflow is potentially dangerous to

execution stability. I dont feel comfortable with just trying to ignore this.

Page 233 (appendix B) of the Applescript language guide is not more descriptive

than the above.

Anybody else know about this? Am I doing something wrong in trying

to append to an existing list? I've tried other variations before posting

this note. Some of them are:

1) Initializing aList with 1 or 2 elements first -- same result but xLimit

has to be set to 8146 (for 1 element) or 8147 for (2 elements) to fail.

2) Using a reference to aList such as

set refaList to a reference to aList

No luck here either --- Same result.

3) Putting ()'s around aList or using my I or my alist constructs

all yield the same result.

4) Just for completeness I tried the following dreadfully slow technique

inside of the loop.... ah yes, you can go above 8150 but somewhere on or

before 8190 it results the same as all the other ways.

set aList to aList & {I}

Even the sledgehammer failed.

You will not notice this error if you make a change to the script and then save it.

It will only be obvious if you run the script and try saving immediately

afterward -- without making any changes.

Ken Higgins

🔧 Closest iFixit match: iMac Intel 27" Retina 5K Display 2019-2020
Take-apart guides & videos on iFixit →
Double-check this is your exact model before ordering parts.

2 replies

Sign in or join Beachball Help to reply.

  1. 0

    red_menace

    Imported from the Apple Support Forums via the Wayback Machine 🔗

    I believe this is a known issue that involves the size/number of items saved in the script file (properties and globals are saved with the script). This goes away if you set the list to {} after you are done with it or put your statements in a handler (to make the list local).

  2. 0

    KenHiggins

    Imported from the Apple Support Forums via the Wayback Machine 🔗

    Hi Red...

    Good call.

    I tried this script. When I commented out "bb" it showed the error as

    as I indicated. However, when I UNCOMMENTED the bb line, as suggested, it worked.

    I also tried this inline (outside of a handler) and replicated the same result.

    So the idea is -- we have to make sure that we close out these

    lists prior to terminating the script. That's not great but its a valid workaround.

    thanks so much.

    Ken Higgins

    ---

    set bb to myHandler()

    set bb to {} <------

    on myHandler()

    local aList

    set xLimit to 9000

    set aList to {}

    repeat with I from 1 to xLimit

    set end of aList to I

    end repeat

    return aList

    end myHandler