Benches macOS

3

USB webcam has slow fps

apple Verified

Imported from the Apple Support Forums via the Wayback Machine 🔗

My firewire socket has failed and I can't afford a new logic board, so I've bought myself a new usb webcam to take the place of my trusty isight. I've got a Logitech quickcam pro 9000. My problem is that I can't get anwhere near the 30 fps it should be providing; usually I don't get more than 5-6 fps. The odd thing is that occasionally I get 15 fps, but i can't replicate it. This is in QT pro and also in ichat using conference recorder to make movies with. Macam doesn't work with the 9000 pro. Do I need to upgrade to Leopard? I tried upgrading to 10.4.9, but software updater won't let me.

3 replies

Sign in or join Beachball Help to reply.

  1. 0

    Markus Altendorff

    Imported from the Apple Support Forums via the Wayback Machine 🔗

    I'm using the same camera on my MacPro, and found that with the current built-in support for USB video class this will not get better.

    There are several things to consider:

    1) In low light (and with the "generic" USB video class drivers on MacOS X), the camera will "slow down" its fps rate to collect more light and reduce noise.

    2) In Quicktime Pro, recording in "camera native" will invariably result in a 1600x1200 JPEG-compressed movie at 5 fps.

    3) In Quicktime Pro, the best frame rate i got out of it was approx. 10-12 fps, but the recorded movie itself has 30 fps, i.e. it's padded by repeating one frame 2-3 times. Granted, this compresses rather well since nothing's changing between those duplicated frames, but it feels like cheating.

    4) Using Apple's own USB Prober tool (comes with the developer tools), one can "see" all the data channels the camera offers to the computer (in the ballpark of 20 data streams the computer could request, ranging from 320x240 to 960x720, each with several frame rates to pick from, and in MotionJPEG or uncompressed). There's just no way (yet?) to pick one.

    I'd suggest using Apple's feedback web form (i did yesterday, filed it in "Quicktime -> Feature requests). While i'm happy the camera works "out of the box", i'd be even more happy if it did record smooth 30fps video as well. Not that it matters much for videophoning, since that's compressed to death anyway, but to see it's all already there, with just a "pick input format" selector missing...

  2. 0

    David M Brewer

    Imported from the Apple Support Forums via the Wayback Machine 🔗

    USB isn't as fast as firewire. That's why you have dropped frames. USB was never intended for video.

  3. 0

    Markus Altendorff

    Imported from the Apple Support Forums via the Wayback Machine 🔗

    David M Brewer wrote:

    USB isn't as fast as firewire. That's why you have dropped frames. USB was never intended for video.

    This "not as fast as firewire" isn't exactly correct, is it? The nominal speed of USB 2.0 is higher than Firewire (400 - we're talking about video devices, right?), but the protocol and structure of USB isn't that well suited for constant streaming of data.

    Anyway, since USB harddisks on Mac can easily sustain more than 10 MB/sec. (i've got one with a 15-16 MB/sec average here, though my Firewire one easily tops that with 25-30 MB/sec), i'd wager it's not the bus that limits the frame rate. For all practical aspects, USB 2.0 should be enough for webcam use.

    Because running the logitec driver in Windows XP in Parallels on the very same machine results in nice, smooth video (not to mention the far better, software-controlled light/color, since the windows driver adjusts/overrides the auto exposure from the camera)...

    Since the original machine is a MacBook, the USB ports are supposedly USB 2.0. I'm still convinced the mediocre performance is just because of the rather generic support that the built-in UVC driver of MacOS X offers.