Benches macOS

15

How do I mount an ext3 drive?

apple Verified

Imported from the Apple Support Forums via the Wayback Machine 🔗

Hi,

I'm completely new to Macs. Please be kind.

Before I purchased this new Mini I went to the apple store and asked about file system support and ext3. The guy in the store looked up some OS X specs on line and we found ext3 so I thoought it was cool. I purchased the Mini, got it home and running, and tried to mount a 1394 ext3 drive I use with my Linux systems. OS X sut tells me there's nothing on the disk that's mountable. I tried taking another drive and asking OS X to format it but it seemed to only do HFSPlus and MSDOS.

I searched around here and didn't find any posts on Linux file systems.

Can someone fill me in on how I go about doing this? What's really supported? Do I need to load an ext3 support module or something to get it to work?

Thanks,

Mark

15 replies

Sign in or join Beachball Help to reply.

  1. 0

    Karl Zimmerman

    Imported from the Apple Support Forums via the Wayback Machine 🔗

    OS X (Panther, at least) doesn't appear to have built-in support for ext2/3.

    You can check on Tiger by viewing the mount(8) man page (Terminal : "man mount"); if it's not listed as one of the arguments to the "-t" option, do "ls /sbin/mount_*"; if you don't see mount_ex2, then it's not there.

    However, there is a port of ext2 to OS X at
    http://sourceforge.net/projects/ext2fsx ; and it's been reported that it works for ext3 as well (since ext3 is backward-compatible with ext2).

  2. 0

    Bill Scott

    Imported from the Apple Support Forums via the Wayback Machine 🔗

    Hopefully someone will tell me I am wrong, but I think that ext2 and ext3 support does not exist with OS X v. 10.4. With 10.3, there was some 3rd-party software at

    http://sourceforge.net/projects/ext2fsx

    but I think it does not work for 10.4.

    On the linux side, you can add HFS+ support (but last time I went through this, not case-sensitive HFS+ support). So to share an external drive, I needed to format it as HFS+. I made the mistake of thinking ufs formatting would be the most interchangable, but Linux seems not to recognize that.

  3. 0

    Camelot

    Imported from the Apple Support Forums via the Wayback Machine 🔗

    There is no built-in support for ext3 drives in any version of Mac OS X.

    Your easiest solution is probably to attach it to the Linux machine and share it via NFS.

    Probably not the answer you wanted, but it's the easiest solution.

  4. 0

    Mark Knecht

    Imported from the Apple Support Forums via the Wayback Machine 🔗

    Karl,

    First, thanks for responding. Yes, I did look at man mount, and then also looked around at the different specific mount commands at the bottom and didn't find what I hoped to find.

    Unfortunately the ext2fsx project seems a bit unmaintained at the moment. The news link in the upper right, entitled 'Tiger and ext2' says:

    <quote>

    Posted By: bbergstrand

    Date: 2005-06-16 17:39

    Summary: Tiger and Ext2

    I've had a request to post something about Tiger support -- so here it is:

    Apple completely changed the kernel interfaces in Tiger and as such, a lot of work needs to be done to get the Ext2 driver running on Tiger. I started some of this work last year after WWDC, but there is still a lot to do and I don't have the time to finish things up right now.

    I do plan on getting back to this at some point (hopefully before the end of the year -- but no guarantees). In the meantime if anyone wants to help out, check out TOT from CVS and have at it. Patches can be submitted via the patch tracker.

    </quote/

    So this doesn't appear to be an option.

    I think Camelot's proposition to do it via NFS isn't bad, but not great for my more realtime audio work. I'd hoped to be able to physically move the 1394 drive. I hate getting the network involved in recording and playback operations.

    I will next investigate the HFS/HFS+ option. I built it into my kernel but I don't know how good that is on Linux. The problems with msdos partitions are legion, but in my case it just plain doesn't work. I've got about 60GB of audio existing in a hierarchy where the path names are jsut too big for that file system type.

    I am hopeful that I won't have that problem with Mac's file system.

    Thanks for the answers, if more than a bit disappointing. Maybe I should write Apple about supporting this? As a new user who was, apparently led astray by the folks at the Apple store, it sure would be great to get support for this. (Fat chance I'm sure...)

    Cheers,

    Mark

  5. 0

    Mark Knecht

    Imported from the Apple Support Forums via the Wayback Machine 🔗

    Bill,

    I wonder if you could share how you formeatted your external drive (1394 I presume?) to use HFS+? Working in the GUI the only thing I've found so far is something called 'Disk Utility'. I plug in my 1394 drive, and it's recognized, but it only seems to want to let me use FAT32.

    I'm fine with doing this from the command line if it's necessary. Currently with the drive attached I put FAT32 on and named it Musiclib:

    mini:~ root# df

    Filesystem 512-blocks Used Avail Capacity Mounted on

    /dev/disk0s3 156039264 24775080 130752184 16% /

    devfs 194 194 0 100% /dev

    fdesc 2 2 0 100% /dev

    <volfs> 1024 1024 0 100% /.vol

    automount -nsl [113] 0 0 0 100% /Network

    automount -fstab [118] 0 0 0 100% /automount/Servers

    automount -static [118] 0 0 0 100% /automount/static

    /dev/disk1s1 160797248 512 160796736 0% /Volumes/MUSICLIB

    mini:~ root#

    I would prefer to lay the partition down using the Mac since it's probably better at understanding HFS2 than Linux is.

    Thanks!

  6. 0

    Bill Scott

    Imported from the Apple Support Forums via the Wayback Machine 🔗

    I used Disk Utility. HFS+ (with journaling) is the default OS X disk format. That allows me to use it with both linux and Apple.

    On the linux side I had to install this:

    http://packages.ubuntu.com/breezy/otherosfs/hfsplus

    There are doubtless versions of this for whatever flavor of linux you have.

    I agree though that if you can serve it via nfs it will be a lot easier. But if you need an external drive that is swappable between linux and Apple computers, this was the only way I could figure out. (I guess both will read the windoze formatted disks, but I didn't want to go there).

  7. 0

    Mark Knecht

    Imported from the Apple Support Forums via the Wayback Machine 🔗

    Thanks. This is interesting. I've not seen any options for using HFS+ on my external drive. Now, while roaming around and looking at all the options I see that there are two different partitioning schemes. The drive, as set up by Linux originally, is called the 'PC Partitioning SCheme'. It appears to only allow MSDOS as a file system type.

    There is a second partitioning scheme which is Apple's scheme, and in this setup I can choose

    Mac OS Extended (Journaled)

    Mac OS Extended

    Mac OS Extended (Journaled, Case Sensitive)

    Mac OS Extended (Case Sensitive)

    UNIX File System

    Free Space

    I take it from earlier posts that possibly the case sensitive versions didn't work?

    Now, the $64K question - what is 'UNIX file System'?

    This is very helpful. I'll partition a new drive with 5 partitions and try them all just to see how it works out.

    Cheers

  8. 0

    Bill Scott

    Imported from the Apple Support Forums via the Wayback Machine 🔗

    I falsely assumed ufs (unix file system) would be the universally-recognized disk format. I formatted my disk to that, put on about 100 GB of backups, and then found that linux didn't recognize it.

    Then I formatted with case-sensitive HFS+.

    I found that linux didn't recognize that.

    Then I formatted with case-insensitive HFS+, and that worked.

    You now know as much as I do....

    I quit experimenting when I got something to work.

    I don't know about the partitioning thing, but I did notice when setting up linux that it made separate partitions on each disk, one that you could assign as swap space. Even if you don't explicitly do that, it seems to create a subpartition anyway. So maybe that is what PC partitioning is.

    In any case I didn't format the external drive that way.... I think as long as you don't plan to install linux on that drive you should be ok.

  9. 0

    Mark Knecht

    Imported from the Apple Support Forums via the Wayback Machine 🔗

    Thanks again for all the info. And I'm sure I don't know as much as you do but I'm trying.

    I'm totally sure it's me but the one thing I cannot get past here is that when I'm in Disk Utility and I choose the PC Partition Scheme I'm not allowed to format with anything other than msdos. (FAT32 under the hood)

    This is OS X 10.4.2, and Disk Utility 10.5.1 (198.1) It just doesn't allow HFS+ when using a PC partition scheme.

    So far the tools I've found for HFS+ on Gentoo allow me to mount, unmount, list, copy, etc., but they don't allow me to actually format the filesystem itself. I can mark a partition in fdisk, but so far I haven't figured out what filesystem type is HFS+.

    Anyway, I'll keep messing with it. Maybe I'll make a breakthrough in my understanding. Again, thanks for the help.

  10. 0

    Bill Scott

    Imported from the Apple Support Forums via the Wayback Machine 🔗

    I didn't use a PC partitioning scheme to partition the disk. In fact, this is the first I have heard the term. I just used one unpartitioned disk and formatted it with Disk Utility (same one you are using) as HFS+.

  11. 0

    Michael Newbery

    Imported from the Apple Support Forums via the Wayback Machine 🔗

    As a matter of interest (but of absolutely no help in solving this particular problem), the boot loader apparently understands ext2!

    http://www.kernelthread.com/mac/osx/arch_boot.html

  12. 0

    Mark Knecht

    Imported from the Apple Support Forums via the Wayback Machine 🔗

    OK, I'll continue to look at that. So far I cannot get my Gentoo system to even recognize that a disk partitioned and formatted like that even has a partition on it, much less mount. Tomorrows tasks are defined.

  13. 0

    Mark Knecht

    Imported from the Apple Support Forums via the Wayback Machine 🔗

    Hi Bill,

    OK, I've made considerable headway. Mostly this is feedback for any other poor folks like me who come along in the future.

    1) It turns out there are MANY disk partition schemes recognized by the Linux kernel, but the default setting is to recognize only the 'PC BIOS (MSDOS partition table) support'. To get a Linux box to start recognizing Apple partitions you need to enable 'Macintosh partition table support'. These and other formats are located in make menuconfig under

    File systems->Partition Types

    2) Once you are set up to recognize Apple partitions then you have to enable support for Apple's file systems.

    File systems->Miscellaneous filesystems

    Apple Macintosh file system support (EXPERIMENTAL)

    Apple Extended HFS file system support

    With this added to my kernel config I rebuilt, rebooted and start to see some life in my 1394 drives. However, I'm not home yet.

    3) An 'interesting' 😉 aspect of the Apple Partition Scheme appears to be the generous use of partitions. On a 1394 drive formatted in Disk Utility with a single partition the Linux system says there are 11 partitions:

    8 32 80418240 sdc

    8 33 31 sdc1

    8 34 28 sdc2

    8 35 28 sdc3

    8 36 28 sdc4

    8 37 28 sdc5

    8 38 256 sdc6

    8 39 256 sdc7

    8 40 256 sdc8

    8 41 131072 sdc9

    8 42 80286248 sdc10

    8 43 8 sdc11

    This is an 80GB drive. The partition I care about in this case turns out to be sdc10. If I attempt to mount it as an hfsplus partition then I get intersting results:

    lightning ~ # mount -t hfsplus -o rw /dev/sdc10 1394-1

    lightning ~ # df

    Filesystem 1K-blocks Used Available Use% Mounted on

    /dev/sda3 9614148 7278376 1847396 80% /

    udev 255188 340 254848 1% /dev

    shm 255188 0 255188 0% /dev/shm

    myth14:/video 225373664 151698176 62227168 71% /video

    /dev/sdb1 57685532 47539424 7215856 87% /home/mark/music

    /dev/sdc10 80279272 35536 80243736 1% /root/1394-1

    lightning ~ # ls -al 1394-1

    total 4

    drwxr-xr-x 1 root root 5 Oct 19 13:51 .

    drwx------ 22 root root 4096 Oct 20 08:47 ..

    drw------- 1 99 99 7 Oct 19 13:54 .Spotlight-V100

    d-wx-wx-wt 1 99 99 2 Oct 19 14:37 .Trashes

    lightning ~ #

    Nothing necessarily wrong with that. However , if I attempt to mount it as an hfs partition I also get intersting results:

    lightning ~ # umount 1394-1

    lightning ~ # mount -t hfs -o rw /dev/sdc10 1394-1

    lightning ~ # df

    Filesystem 1K-blocks Used Available Use% Mounted on

    /dev/sda3 9614148 7278380 1847392 80% /

    udev 255188 340 254848 1% /dev

    shm 255188 0 255188 0% /dev/shm

    myth14:/video 225373664 151698176 62227168 71% /video

    /dev/sdb1 57685532 47539424 7215856 87% /home/mark/music

    /dev/sdc10 80285412 80285412 0 100% /root/1394-1

    lightning ~ # ls -al 1394-1

    total 1236

    drwxr-xr-x 1 root root 7 Oct 19 13:51 .

    drwx------ 22 root root 4096 Oct 20 08:47 ..

    -rw-r--r-- 1 root root 1257472 Oct 19 13:51 Desktop DB

    -rw-r--r-- 1 root root 0 Oct 19 13:51 Desktop DF

    -rw-r--r-- 1 root root 0 Oct 19 13:51 Finder

    -rw-r--r-- 1 root root 1781 Oct 19 13:51 ReadMe

    -rw-r--r-- 1 root root 0 Oct 19 13:51 System

    lightning ~ #

    So far I trust the second one more than the first. However, every time I mount it as hfs (not hfsplus) I get a message in dmesg like this:

    HFS-fs: Filesystem is marked locked, mounting read-only.

    This may all be related to your comments earlier about which filesystem type you could make work. I need to go back and try all of them out to see what they all do. It may also be realted to the experiemental nature

  14. 0

    Lutz Mader

    Imported from the Apple Support Forums via the Wayback Machine 🔗

    Hi,

    I use ext2fsx (see "http://sourceforge.net/projects/ext2fsx/") to

    mount ext2/ext3 file systems on my Mac (OS X 10.2.8).

    But this little nice tool is available for 10.2.x and 10.3.x

    only, yet.

    Bye, Lutz

    p.s.

    The tool can be used to mount ext2/ext3 partitions, but

    with hdiutil (a line command to mount something) you are

    able to mount disc images to (very nice tool).

  15. 0

    Mark Knecht

    Imported from the Apple Support Forums via the Wayback Machine 🔗

    Hi Lutz,

    Yes, ext2fsx looked interesting but I'm running Tiger and it doesn't work.

    That said I've gone the other way around. I'm now using hfsplus drives mounted on my Gentoo machines. They seem to work fine so at least I have a solution that works with Tiger.

    Thanks!

    - Mark