Electrical problem Using 220, Possible ground problem
apple Verified ·
Imported from the Apple Support Forums via the Wayback Machine 🔗
I'm traveling abroad, at the moment in Peru, and have a strange problem with my MacBook Pro 17 inch. Everything here is 220v, without proper grounds (I haven't been able to test it at 110v). I'm also using a voltage regulator, surge suppressor, etc., although the problem occurs with or without.
When I plug the machine in to charge, I get a strange shocking or vibrating sensation when I glide my fingertips across the top of the machine, particularly across the top of the keyboard and to the left of track pad, also a tiny shock (like static on the sharper edges abound the top of the machine. If I pull the charger off it stops immediately, so I know it's something to do with the power in. It's nothing to do with the charger, because I have another MacBook 13 inch with me and I've interchanged the chargers. I feel the same sensation with the 13 inch, but to much less extent.
It's almost impossible to plug in anywhere here that has a proper ground, but I did find one place with standard wiring and a good ground and it worked fine here, the sensation disappears.
Can anyone tell what's going on here... and wether or not this may damage my charger, battery or machine? Same question with a 24 inch LCD I'm using?
Thanks for any input... I afraid to plug in anything at the moment.
15 replies
Sign in or join Beachball Help to reply.
- 0
Rod Hagen ·
Imported from the Apple Support Forums via the Wayback Machine 🔗
Hi UpstreamSupport and welcome to the boards.
I've run into this myself in outback Australia when working in places with shonky earth set ups with various aluminium PB and MBP Macs. The same thing can also happen when using the "duck head" two prong plug rather than the three pin grounded power cord. My impression is that it is related to feedback through the earth that normally connects the computer to the power adaptor (and which is really intended to earth the computer, not the adaptor!)
Essentially you are intermittently becoming the earth circuit. It doesn't seem to affect the computer at all, but it can be very annoying.
Not sure that you can do much about it other than carry a long piece of wire and a ground spike to create your own earth! You may find that changing your footwear actually has some effect (for better or worse) too!
Cheers
Rod
- 0
carl wolf ·
Imported from the Apple Support Forums via the Wayback Machine 🔗
"Can anyone tell what's going on here... and wether or not this may damage my charger, battery or machine? "
The good news is that it will not damage the charger or your computer. The power adapter places one-half of the line voltage onto the chassis and, therefore, the computer case. Although annoying, the voltage is at a very low current, well within international safety specifications. As Rod mentioned, and you noticed, the sensation can be alleviated by using the 3-prong AC plug in a properly grounded outlet. Another solution is a little Rube Goldberg-ish. You can use a 220-to-110 voltage converter, and then only 55VAC is placed on the case. Most people can't feel the lower voltage.
- 0
Rod Hagen ·
Imported from the Apple Support Forums via the Wayback Machine 🔗
Thanks for that Carl. Intriguing.
Any idea why it places half the line voltage through the chassis and case? Certainly seems like an odd thing to do deliberately!
Cheers
Rod
- 0
F Shippey ·
Imported from the Apple Support Forums via the Wayback Machine 🔗
Rod,
My, my, my... one-half of the line voltage onto the chassis. Imagine that. The things you learn in the Forums. 😉
Fred
- 0
Rod Hagen ·
Imported from the Apple Support Forums via the Wayback Machine 🔗
Well, I've learned that they do it, Fred, but I haven't learned
why they do it! Can you enlighten me? 😉 Is it for some sort of "shielding" purpose or the like, of the kind used in some audio devices?Cheers
Rod
- 0
red_menace ·
Imported from the Apple Support Forums via the Wayback Machine 🔗
It sounds like that is referring to the common, or neutral side of the circuit, although I don't understand why it would be connected to the load side. I haven't torn one apart, but the power "supply" shouldn't be much more than a transformer, which would isolate the load side from the line side anyway (mine doesn't even have a ground prong).
There may be some kind of induced voltage, but I don't know why the chassis would be connected to any of the line side wiring, since there really isn't any guarantee that the receptacle would be wired correctly.
- 0
F Shippey ·
Imported from the Apple Support Forums via the Wayback Machine 🔗
I certainly can't explain it ... (unless it's done with smoke and mirrors)
- 0
UpstreamSupport ·
Imported from the Apple Support Forums via the Wayback Machine 🔗
Thank you for the replies. Although my primary concern was that I wasn't damaging equipment in the middle of nowhere… it really is pretty annoying for a pro user, that's actually working long hours, as apposed to just checking a few emails from a hostel somewhere. You would think it would have been thought through from the beginning, especially for the higher end pro machines.
I set up a 24 LCD this morning and same voltage there, every flat surface from the pedestal to the top.
I also noticed that plugging in an external hard drive, via Fire Wire 800, also causes the same problem. In other words… I can unplug the power adaptor from the MacBook, run on the battery and still feel the voltage on the body… until I pull the Fire Wire cable and it disappears.
Another post I found:
http://discussions.apple.com/thread.jspa?messageID=10213014�Thanks Again...
- 0
eww ·
Imported from the Apple Support Forums via the Wayback Machine 🔗
I'm not sure why it should be Apple's responsibility to design and build computers that work as expected with every kind of faulty wiring and power supply that their users can find in the world. Your problem clearly is the lack of a ground in the building or the larger power grid you're plugging into. You can provide the necessary ground yourself, and when you get annoyed enough by the current on your MBP's case, maybe you'll do so.
- 0
UpstreamSupport ·
Imported from the Apple Support Forums via the Wayback Machine 🔗
No need to defend Apple or anyone else here… Personally I've never owned a Windows machine. My first PC was a 128k Mac in 1984, when they hit the stores. I bought 6 of them for my business at the time. I've since owned 30 or 40 personally and have been responsible for hundreds between the three companies I had over these years. I currently keep probably 10,000 dollars in Mac equipment personally that is changed out every couple of years. In fact everything mentioned in my post I just bought in Ecuador for about 30% more than you would probably pay in the states. So again no need to defend Apple here.
In the last 12 years, I have worked in more than 20 different countries, probably less than 10% of these locations has had American or European standards in anything much less electrical wiring, yet you could buy a Mac legally in almost every single one of them. I have in fact seen Macs being used on numerous occasions in places with nothing more than dirt floors and grass roofs. So there may well be more Macs out here than the average Apple engineer suspects.
The only point I was trying to make in my last post was that after 25 years of Mac experience with a fairly large number of different machines to look back on… this one looks, and in this case feels, like a bit of an design oversight.
- 0
Rod Hagen ·
Imported from the Apple Support Forums via the Wayback Machine 🔗
Its an annoying and common enough problem to wonder about, though eww. I suffered it myself on occasion with the PB12, even on a "good" , properly earthed power system, if I used the unearthed "duckhead" plug on my power adaptor, for example, and I've seen many other posts about it on the PB and, to a lesser extent, MBP, forums over the years.
Given that Apple actually sell these computers with an ungrounded two pin plug (at least in Australia) as well as the cord, you'd think it might be seen as a matter of more concern. Mind you , I haven't experienced it with my current MBPs, but that is probably because I use the earthed cord as a matter of course these days and haven't been off into the wilds of western Queensland as regularly as I used to!
I've always wondered what the real cause was.
Cheers
Rod
- 0
F Shippey ·
Imported from the Apple Support Forums via the Wayback Machine 🔗
Rod,
I just checked the white power supply that came with my 2004 12" PowerBook G4 with my VOM (volt-ohm meter). Using the two-prong "duckbill" plug, NEITHER side of the line plug shows any continuity with any of the 4 possible connections on the computer power plug (shell, or tip or 2 rings on the center plug).
- 0
Rod Hagen ·
Imported from the Apple Support Forums via the Wayback Machine 🔗
My own suspicion has always been that phenomenon is caused by a simple old leakage to earth within the computer itself, F. Until Carl's comment I had assumed that it was accidental, rather than deliberate.
I guess given that the transformer in the power supply induces the current in the output stage you wouldn't expect to detect continuity between either of the pins and the mains voltage pins and the output side of things.
You'll find (well, at least, I did when I tested it with my PB a few years back) if you hook the charger up using the three point cord (or just stick one of your probes on the metallic earth "knob" on the adaptor body after removing the plug) though that there is continuity between parts of the body of the computer itself and the earth pin (In other words the computer itself, and not just the power adaptor, is definitely earthed by the lead).
Cheers
Rod
- 0
carl wolf ·
Imported from the Apple Support Forums via the Wayback Machine 🔗
"Any idea why it places half the line voltage through the chassis and case? Certainly seems like an odd thing to do deliberately!"
Hi Rod! You're the first person to ask this, seriously. First, it isn't something that only Apple does - it's an industry standard approach to solve a problem. Second, you should realize that all designs are compromises. Here goes: personal computers, just like many other devices, have governmental and corporate standards that need to be met. An example of the latter would be "operating temperature", and example of the former would "presence of hazardous materials". Ever since WWII the government realized that many household goods produced electrical emissions that could cause problems with communications. The US government pretty much ignored the situation until the Vietnam war era, and then introduced regulations for the emitted electrical noise. Specifically, the FCC, and other countries, allow a certain level of noise over a specific range of frequencies. The use of low level line current introduced on the computer chassis greatly improved the attenuation of emitted electrical noise. Implementing a design that would eliminate virtually all electrical noise, without the current leakage, would require substantial (and expensive) casing and air filtering (electrical noise escapes through all openings, including fan vents). Your computer would no longer be "portable", and it would cost in the neighborhood of $15K. The US government needs computers with this significant amount of shielding and, if you like more information, you can Google "TEMPEST" (in the context other than William Shakespeare's play).
In summary, the current leakage on the case is normal, and the computer works exactly as designed, and I hope that my answer has proved to be informative.
- 0
red_menace ·
Imported from the Apple Support Forums via the Wayback Machine 🔗
Consumer products wouldn't have any TEMPEST requirements (too expensive), they use FCC Part 15, with various shielding constructs around the RF generating components to minimize (not eliminate) the emissions. I would very much doubt the deliberate placing of any kind of voltage on the chassis of a piece of equipment, since such a thing would pretty much guarantee a lawsuit - there are ongoing suits related to overhead power lines about this very thing.
Way back in the old days, you would sometimes see a neutral bonded to the chassis of an appliance such as a stove or washing machine, but this had the problem that if things were not properly wired, there could be potentially lethal voltages on the chassis. Since there are more do-it-yourselfers these days, the codes have evolved over the years to make these kind of things a bit less error prone by requiring the manufacturers to provide appropriate equipment grounds and grounding conductors.
As mentioned in other posts, there is no direct connection between the line and load side conductors, although I would wonder if an improper ground in the receptacle could be allowing a voltage to be induced on the chassis. It would be interesting to note the exact voltages between the various conductors, the chassis, and any ground.
Another thing to consider would be if phone lines are involved - is there a modem in use? I have seen telco voltages wind up on a (non computer) chassis due to improper grounding. The ring/battery voltage can be around 90-250 VDC, which tends to have a bit of a bite - regular AC voltages have a different feel.