Benches MacBooks

17

Any GTX 285 owners?

apple Verified

Imported from the Apple Support Forums via the Wayback Machine 🔗

I've been holding out for a mac edition radeon 5870... but I'm starting to think I can't wait anymore.

I'm curious if any GTX 285 owners have any feedback regarding performance of this card in snow leopard with aperture 3 compared to a previous card. (I guess this would apply to aperture 2 as well...)

I've read all the speed tests and issues with the drivers of the card and power management... but I'm particularly interested in comparing this with an Nvidia 8800GT.

This is almost impossible to benchmark, because at this point it seems the card will only affect image adjustment operations, I believe RAW decoding and background processing/exporting are CPU bound. If anyone has any before/after feedback of "perceived improvement" while adjusting images I'd like to hear it.

Thanks!

17 replies

Sign in or join Beachball Help to reply.

  1. 0

    Eoin Kavanagh

    Imported from the Apple Support Forums via the Wayback Machine 🔗

    All I can tell you as a GTX 285 user, is there seems to have been a huge improvement in Aperture 2 replacing the stock 120 with the GTX 285.

    I took the 120 out completely at that time. With regard to Aperture 3, on my initial install alongside Ap2 there were no problems. everything worked as it should and no crashes. I had a new 2009 Dual 2.66 8 core with 12Gb of ram. I used clean my mac to remove Ap2 and it caused all sorts of problems so I decided to re partition the boot drive and format it. I put down a fresh SL install from the system disks and updated it with the SW Update then put only AP3 and updated that.

    Since then I've been plagued with crashes mostly with brushes and standard sharpening. I'm seriously thinking of starting from scratch again. My data is stored on 3 Velociraptors and hasn't been affected.

    It's a royal PIA at the moment, the Epson 3800 driver is printing upside down in Photoshop, requiring me to rotate 180 degrees for the Hahnemuhle albums I use. But in saying that I love all the extra tools in Ap3. When it's not crashing (staying away from some brushes and sharpening) it works very well. No lag, everything in real time. FWIW I'm processing Sony a900 files 24mp and 35Mb each.

  2. 0

    MSU Matt

    Imported from the Apple Support Forums via the Wayback Machine 🔗

    I just checked the zoom/pan out and I'm in shock! Now, I remember on the old card, it took some time for it to become fully rendered and was blurry.

    I just tested the zoom function on a heavily edited photo and a non-edited RAW photo and both had the same results. When zoomed in, wherever I panned was already rendered so there was no loss in quality while moving around the photo. If there was a slight 'speedbump' where Aperture had not rendered the photo yet during a pab, it was done before I could even start counting. It was almost seamless. Very nice!

    Now, I'm shooting with a D700 (12 MP RAW files) so I'm not sure how these would behave with larger RAW files from a D3x for example.

  3. 0

    Matthew Bergsma

    Imported from the Apple Support Forums via the Wayback Machine 🔗

    Any gtx 285 owners with aperture 3 and 10.6.2 out there?

  4. 0

    Robert Vojta

    Imported from the Apple Support Forums via the Wayback Machine 🔗

    At first, read my blog post at
    http://blog.robertvojta.com/2010/02/27/aperture-3-performance-vram/

    You'll see, that the GPU is not heavily used when you're applying brushes. It's about 40 % with my GT120. When it works, everything is real time even with this
    slow GT120 card.

    The only thing, which is used heavily is VRAM. When my VRAM usage goes up to 90 %, Aperture 3 is very slow, mouse is choppy even if I stop applying brushes and just moving with my mouse. When it goes down below 90 %, it stops and Aperture 3 is normally responsive.

    In my opinion, this can be bug in OpenCL. If not, it's Aperture 3. When this will be fixed, I'll be happy with my GT120.

    I wanted to say with this reply, that it looks like that the VRAM size is much more important than GPU power. GT120 has 512 MB and GTX285 has 1GB, which definitely is going to help.

    But personally, I'm waiting for some new card with more than 1 GB of VRAM because of OpenCL.

  5. 0

    Matthew Bergsma

    Imported from the Apple Support Forums via the Wayback Machine 🔗

    Thanks for sharing -

    I agree with you that VRAM is potentially more important once you start stacking things - Which is why I will often unplug my 2nd monitor if I need to get really intense in an editing session (a stupid solution I know, but it helps to give one display the full amount of vram).

    However I agree with other commenters on your site that the GT120 is a dog, and even the previous 8800GT is a better card... Even my macbook pro's 9600 is probably a better card (at least based off my experience brushing adjustments on the laptop).

    I'm surprised by this, because I suspected brush masks would be stored in system ram, but I can see why they might be stored in GPU RAM.

    Thanks again for sharing your findings. I too am waiting for a next-gen 2GB vram card.

  6. 0

    Robert Vojta

    Imported from the Apple Support Forums via the Wayback Machine 🔗

    You're welcome. I do use
    http://www.atpurpose.com/atMonitor/ tool. It's free and very simple. Just install, run and you'll see floating window with CPU, GPU, RAM, VRAM, ... usage.

    I still think that 0.5 GB of VRAM should be enough, because there's nothing about VRAM in system requirements. In my opinion, it's a bug somewhere which hopefully will be fixed soon. Even if this will be fixed, I'm going for some 2 GB VRAM card too. If there will be something available in the near future 😉

  7. 0

    Matthew Bergsma

    Imported from the Apple Support Forums via the Wayback Machine 🔗

    Hi Robert -

    If you look at any speed benchmarks for HD sized gaming results, you'll find the g120 about 6x slower than the 8800.

    From personal experience going from a radeon 1900xt to an 8800 I can say that there is a tremendous difference in processing speed beyond just having enough Vram. (Those cards both have the same amount). I wouldn't trust that it is a memory issue just because the GPU load meter on the atMonitor display is low while the memory is pegged...

    I just did a quick test on my machine which kept vRam at 90%, but I didn't experience the slowdowns you've described.

  8. 0

    Kevin J. Doyle

    Imported from the Apple Support Forums via the Wayback Machine 🔗

    Matthew Bergsma wrote:

    Thanks for sharing -

    I agree with you that VRAM is potentially more important once you start stacking things - Which is why I will often unplug my 2nd monitor if I need to get really intense in an editing session (a stupid solution I know, but it helps to give one display the full amount of vram).

    However I agree with other commenters on your site that the GT120 is a dog, and even the previous 8800GT is a better card... Even my macbook pro's 9600 is probably a better card (at least based off my experience brushing adjustments on the laptop).

    I'm surprised by this, because I suspected brush masks would be stored in system ram, but I can see why they might be stored in GPU RAM.

    Thanks again for sharing your findings. I too am waiting for a next-gen 2GB vram card.

    Hi Mattherw,

    "Which is why I will often unplug my 2nd monitor if I need to get really intense in an editing session (a stupid solution I know, but it helps to give one display the full amount of vram)."

    Not stupid at all, IMHO...I figured this out when I was editing in the hotel room, then went back to the office plugged in the 30" and got slower performance. Viewing the VRAM in real time told the story....unfortunately we are on the bleeding edge here with A3 and its extensive use of OpenCL.

    At Apple's WWDC event in June this year, the OpenCL sessions had some GPU vendors in them, and their general consensus was as the number of popular programs that support OpenCL are released, they will offer more and more VRAM, probably going to expandable/upgradeable designs. This is the future of computing, and currently Aperture 3 is the poster child for this discipline.

    The good part is that being able to have more VRAM makes all this go away...simple fix!

    Sincerely,

    K.J. Doyle

  9. 0

    Robert Vojta

    Imported from the Apple Support Forums via the Wayback Machine 🔗

    Hi Matthew,

    the problem here is that the problem I have appears under some circumstances only. And no one knows these circumstances. You did mention 8800. Friend of mine has this card and he has same problem as I have. In other words, some people with 8800 do not have this problem, some have. Same probably applies to GT120, because when VRAM usage is below 90 %, all adjustments are realtime (tested on two Mac Pros).

  10. 0

    Matthew Bergsma

    Imported from the Apple Support Forums via the Wayback Machine 🔗

    Yep... I was at those sessions 😉 I'm not sure though about current usage, since version 3 supports 10.5.8... Can't really get into the technicalities of it without breaking the terms of use -

    The one thing I was hoping to see was increased background export speed, but this still seems to be CPU bound. On one hand this makes sense, so that the GPU can be reserved for continued editing of images while exporting is going on... On the other hand there are times where I would prefer a "foreground export" option.

    I'd like someone with 2 openCL compliant cards to test for me - do a background export and see if it still maxes your CPUs...

    All that aside, I love the performance I'm getting in 64 bit on my mac pro with the 8800 - still hoping someone with a gtx 285 can give me an idea of their performance...

  11. 0

    MSU Matt

    Imported from the Apple Support Forums via the Wayback Machine 🔗

    Hey Matt, you had posted in my topic recently about Aperture 3/video cards. I did a quick search on Google and realized how much Aperture relies on a quality video card.

    Anyways, I ordered the GTX 285 and should be getting it Monday of next week. I'll let you know my results... Coming from a GT120, I'm hoping to be VERY impressed.

  12. 0

    Eoin Kavanagh

    Imported from the Apple Support Forums via the Wayback Machine 🔗

    All I can tell you as a GTX 285 user, is there seems to have been a huge improvement in Aperture 2 replacing the stock 120 with the GTX 285.

    I took the 120 out completely at that time. With regard to Aperture 3, on my initial install alongside Ap2 there were no problems. everything worked as it should and no crashes. I had a new 2009 Dual 2.66 8 core with 12Gb of ram. I used clean my mac to remove Ap2 and it caused all sorts of problems so I decided to re partition the boot drive and format it. I put down a fresh SL install from the system disks and updated it with the SW Update then put only AP3 and updated that.

    Since then I've been plagued with crashes mostly with brushes and standard sharpening. I'm seriously thinking of starting from scratch again. My data is stored on 3 Velociraptors and hasn't been affected.

    It's a royal PIA at the moment, the Epson 3800 driver is printing upside down in Photoshop, requiring me to rotate 180 degrees for the Hahnemuhle albums I use. But in saying that I love all the extra tools in Ap3. When it's not crashing (staying away from some brushes and sharpening) it works very well. No lag, everything in real time. FWIW I'm processing Sony a900 files 24mp and 35Mb each.

  13. 0

    MSU Matt

    Imported from the Apple Support Forums via the Wayback Machine 🔗

    Received the card and installed in my computer today... all I can say is WOW! This is how Aperture should run! Now, let me remind you, I'm coming from a GT 120, so this is probably to be expected. While I don't have technical data to support my claim, I can say that editing a wedding from this weekend was quick, painless and fun!

    Let me just say that the GTX 285 is a huge video card. It's probably 4x the size of the GT 120. The fan looks like something I could use on a hot summer day to cool off with. Installation was a cinch and I didn't have to install any software before installing the card (must be due to Snow Leopard having the necessary drivers already).

    Ok, now on to Aperture performance. My setup is an 8-Core 2.26 GHz, 6 GB memory Mac Pro with the GTX 285 running two 30" cinema displays. Upon uploading just under 1000 photos, I began editing right away. The photos loaded on my full-screen 30" display quicker than the GT 120, but not as quick as I expected. That is until I realized that Aperture was still processing all of the photos I had just uploaded. While it wasn't unbearably slow by any means, it was MUCH quicker once Aperture could give 100% of it's resources to the task at hand. Once all of the photos were processed, I could flip from photo-to-photo with the full resolution photo being displayed in under 2 seconds. On the GT 120, it sometimes took up to 5 seconds for the photo to 'Load'.

    Editing the photos is such a joy now that I have a video card that can keep up. I applied a plethora of heavy edits on a single photo and didn't notice any slowdown in processing or performance. The only time Aperture gives me grief is when I'm applying the 'retouch' edit after doing several other edits. From what I've read, I believe the retouch is supposed to be down first before other adjustments are applied. No biggie, just something I noticed. All of the brushes painted the adjustments on smoothly and when I switched to the 'color overlay' there was no pause or load-time. It instantly showed the areas where the edits were applied! On the GT120, I would be waiting for 10-15 seconds for the color overlay to show on the screen.

    Flipping through the browser is a breeze as well! All of the photos, no matter which size thumbnail they are, are loaded instantly. I literally can't scroll the page fast enough for the photos to not be loaded on the screen. The GT120 would leave several photos with a dashed, empty box when scrolling through the photos.

    These are just some of the improvements I've noticed. Like I said before, I'm not a tech guru, but I love how Aperture is performing on my Mac Pro. It couldn't be any better and I believe the biggest reason for my performance increase was the GTX 285. Aperture 2 never ran this smooth.

  14. 0

    Matthew Bergsma

    Imported from the Apple Support Forums via the Wayback Machine 🔗

    Thanks Matt for posting your promised review...

    I figured 1GB of Vram would be a substantial difference with 2 30" monitors -

    One quick question for you. When you zoom into a photo at 100% and scroll around, how long does it take for the non-visible areas to fully render?

  15. 0

    MSU Matt

    Imported from the Apple Support Forums via the Wayback Machine 🔗

    I just checked the zoom/pan out and I'm in shock! Now, I remember on the old card, it took some time for it to become fully rendered and was blurry.

    I just tested the zoom function on a heavily edited photo and a non-edited RAW photo and both had the same results. When zoomed in, wherever I panned was already rendered so there was no loss in quality while moving around the photo. If there was a slight 'speedbump' where Aperture had not rendered the photo yet during a pab, it was done before I could even start counting. It was almost seamless. Very nice!

    Now, I'm shooting with a D700 (12 MP RAW files) so I'm not sure how these would behave with larger RAW files from a D3x for example.

  16. 0

    Matthew Bergsma

    Imported from the Apple Support Forums via the Wayback Machine 🔗

    Thanks Matt -

    I have one last question to help determine what the biggest factor is in rendering the scrolling while zoomed in.

    If you disable/unplug your 2nd display, so that all 1GB of vram is available to one display, and then zoom in and scroll around on your primary display - do you notice any difference in speed? Is there any difference while brushing on adjustments on images that have a lot of adjustments applied?

  17. 0

    MSU Matt

    Imported from the Apple Support Forums via the Wayback Machine 🔗

    I didn't notice any difference in speed when my second monitor was unplugged. My adjustments and zooming went on smooth with both monitors plugged in so there really wasn't much to improve upon performance-wise.

    Hope that helps.