Benches MacBooks

15

Shared home movies won't play

apple Verified

Imported from the Apple Support Forums via the Wayback Machine 🔗

Running iTunes 9.0.3.15 on XP sp3 (host) with sharing enabled.

I have several digital copy movies and several home movies in mp4 format on a local drive on the host. All of these movies play fine in iTunes when played on the host.

I have sharing enabled on other machines on the network (also running latest version of iTunes). Every machine can play the digital copy movies through iTunes shared library (they have all been authorized).

None of the home movies play on any of the other network machines *when played through iTunes shared library* (the movies play fine when copied onto the network machine itself).

This is not due to firewalls (I disabled them as a test).

All of the network machines are on the same subnet.

This problem is not related to wireless networking (home movies failed to play on wired desktop that can play same movie from local drive).

Perhaps I (and others) are tripping over some broken DRM code?

15 replies

Sign in or join Beachball Help to reply.

  1. 0

    Katrina S.

    Imported from the Apple Support Forums via the Wayback Machine 🔗

    I'm seeing this between my Mac and an XP PC.

    The Mac will play home shared videos & songs from the XP machine.

    The XP machine will only play songs from the Mac - no videos.

    Home sharing is obviously set up correctly, since songs can play.

    The XP machine just skips over videos.

    Like you, I know they are in the right format for itunes since threy play OK. Most of them are free music videos from the itunes store, anyway.

    My advice is to send a bug report to Apple.

    itunes menu > help > provide itunes feedback

    The more folks who report this, the greater chance of it being fixed.

    You can give them the URL of this thread.

  2. 0

    Laurent Seroude

    Imported from the Apple Support Forums via the Wayback Machine 🔗

    NOT related to DRM! None of my movies contain DRM (all ripped with protection removed as allowed by Canadian laws) and I have the same issue.

    After hours of testing, in my case, the problem is there only for files bigger than 2GB, I can play all my shared movies that are smaller than 2GB. Furthermore I can reproduce this 100%:

    - play a small shared movie, stop it and close the windows

    - try to play a big shared movie and as mentioned here nothing happens

    - try to play the same small shared movie again: does not work anymore

    - back to local library, play any local movie (small or big), stop it and close

    - can play shared small movie again

    Big movies play well if I add them to the library (but not copied to the local drive), they play fine so I'm sure my network can handle the bandwidth and the PC has all necessary codec to play them. Clearly a problem with sharing in iTunes for Windows...

  3. 0

    Katrina S.

    Imported from the Apple Support Forums via the Wayback Machine 🔗

    You're right, it's not related to DRM. I'll check and see if some of my personal movies will play- surely they are smaller than 2GB

    I'm not sure it's a Windows problem - it could be a Mac problem not serving things up correctly for Windows. Either way, it's a bug, and I hope you report it!

  4. 0

    durbc

    Imported from the Apple Support Forums via the Wayback Machine 🔗

    Add me to the list of users who cannot share ripped and home made movies. I run itunes from my desktop XP to laptop XP connected to a big tv and can play music, podcasts, and purchased tv shows and movies on my big TV on a shared library over a wireless network with no lag.

    The few ripped TV shows that i do have dont play, although they play fine on the host.

    I can play them no worries via the wifi with VLC media player.

  5. 0

    durbc

    Imported from the Apple Support Forums via the Wayback Machine 🔗

    BTW this thread says there's 2 hepful posts and 1 solved. Where's the solution please? Excuse me im new.

  6. 0

    Katrina S.

    Imported from the Apple Support Forums via the Wayback Machine 🔗

    durbc, that's 2 helpful posts and 1 solved still available , meaning no points have been given out by the thread starter for helpful or solved replies.

  7. 0

    durbc

    Imported from the Apple Support Forums via the Wayback Machine 🔗

    Right! Cheers for that.

  8. 0

    | phurley |

    Imported from the Apple Support Forums via the Wayback Machine 🔗

    Laurent Seroude wrote:

    NOT related to DRM! None of my movies contain DRM (all ripped with protection removed as allowed by Canadian laws) and I have the same issue.

    Just because the video doesn't contain DRM, doesn't mean this problem isn't related to DRM. DRM encompasses more than just encoding formats - from Wikipedia:

    +"Digital rights management (DRM) is a generic term for access control technologies that can be used by hardware manufacturers, publishers, copyright holders and individuals to try to impose limitations on the usage of digital content and devices."+

    Consider that Apple may have felt it necessary to disable network play of videos over a certain size, (mistakenly) believing that they are protecting the license rights of the studios.

    Of course, my casual suggestion that it may be related to DRM is pure speculation...

  9. 0

    Laurent Seroude

    Imported from the Apple Support Forums via the Wayback Machine 🔗

    | phurley | wrote:

    Laurent Seroude wrote:

    NOT related to DRM! None of my movies contain DRM (all ripped with protection removed as allowed by Canadian laws) and I have the same issue.

    Consider that Apple may have felt it necessary to disable network play of videos over a certain size, (mistakenly) believing that they are protecting the license rights of the studios.

    I don't think so since the big size videos can be played from any mac in my house (including 6yrs old PowerBook and iBook G4 if using wired connection), it's only the windows machine that cannot play those through iTunes (but can through the network if the shared file is added to the windows machine iTunes: not a network issue). The macs can play them wireless or wired (Gigabit) but not the wired Windows machine (also Gigabit!).

  10. 0

    Katrina S.

    Imported from the Apple Support Forums via the Wayback Machine 🔗

    I forgot about this thread.

    I did try playing a small home movie on my XP machine. No dice.

    Again, I hope everyone who runs into this problem reports it to apple.

    windows: itunes menu > help > provide itunes feedback

    mac: itunes menu > provide itunes feedback

  11. 0

    silver1973

    Imported from the Apple Support Forums via the Wayback Machine 🔗

    I discovered this problem about an hour ago and I'm ready to smash both computers into 1000 pieces. I'm walking away and praying someone finds a fix, until then I'll just deal.

  12. 0

    Bockit

    Imported from the Apple Support Forums via the Wayback Machine 🔗

    Was wondering if anyone has come up with a solution to the problem, I just ran into it as well 😟

    My macbook pro has an external hard drive with my itunes media folder on it. I enabled home sharing and authorised my macbook pro and my vista pc with the same account. Turned home sharing on with both machines (both are running iTunes 9.2) and I can load and see the libraries of both machines on either.

    I can:

    Play music from my mac's library

    Copy movie files across to my pc's hard drive, load them into the pc library and play them on the pc

    Those files I copied and could play on the pc, I can also access them and view them on my mac

    I can't:

    Play any video files from my mac, on my pc, through the home sharing feature.

    I didn't run into any of the size constraints that other users reported.

    Any help would be appreciated!

  13. 0

    Bockit

    Imported from the Apple Support Forums via the Wayback Machine 🔗

    This is still a problem for me and is getting quite frustrating. Since my last post I've determined that the problem still occurs when I'm loading from the internal hard drive of my mbp, not just if the library is stored on my external.

  14. 0

    devils.chaplain

    Imported from the Apple Support Forums via the Wayback Machine 🔗

    I have the same problem on vesta 64, got it to work a couple of times when I opened port 3689 of the firewall but after a while it gave up. Tried it on my daughters Win Vesta 32 with the port opened and nothing happened. Like you said mac to mac no problem, playing music and downloading a movie to win and playing it also no problem. I've been using computers since Dos 5 & Win 3.1 they were different systems then and it looks like nothing has changed. The game keeps on going and going and going $$$$$$$$$$. Maybe I should trade in my win machine any takers?.

  15. 0

    Bockit

    Imported from the Apple Support Forums via the Wayback Machine 🔗

    Still got the same problem, even with the semi-recent itunes update.

    Is it possibly the quality of my wirless network? It's running in b & g mode, I don't have a wireless n router..

    I'm going to get a friend with a macbook to come over and do some more testing see if I can't narrow down what's happening.