Benches MacBooks

15

Gamma correction

apple Verified

Imported from the Apple Support Forums via the Wayback Machine 🔗

I am finding that once played on my Sony HDTV, video created in Final Cut Studio 7 looks a bit heavey (slightly too much contrast and slightly dark). I have been reading a lot about gamma in this product and have the following question. Everything looks good on my Macbook Pro monitor but once viewed on the TV screen it's not bad, just not good.

Would setting import gamma in Final Cut to 2.2 help? Or will that just make it look even worse once viewe on the tv?

15 replies

Sign in or join Beachball Help to reply.

  1. 0

    Zebulun

    Imported from the Apple Support Forums via the Wayback Machine 🔗

    How are you spitting this video out to your hdtv?

    What is your delivery format and destination?

    Why do you care how it looks on your laptop display?

  2. 0

    Shane Ross

    Imported from the Apple Support Forums via the Wayback Machine 🔗

    You need to hook an external monitor up to your MacBook Pro via an HD I/O device. FCPs interface and the computer monitor will never show you what you will see on a TV. Getting something like the Matrox MXO2 Mini or AJA I/O HD Express and connecting that to the MacBook Pro and then your monitor will allow you to see exactly what you have, and then correct the image to get what you want to see.

    Never judge the quality of your image on a computer monitor.

    Shane

    User uploaded file

  3. 0

    Merged Content 1

    Imported from the Apple Support Forums via the Wayback Machine 🔗

    Using "share" in FCP to create a blu-ray disk. I've got an external blu-ray burner that I can burn my project to..as a BDMV. So my delivery format is BDMV on blu-ray disk, playable in a blu-ray player to view on consumer HDTV.

    I DON'T care what it looks like on the computer, I want to know if changing import gamma to 2.2 will have an effect on how it looks in the final viewing on the TV set. It looks as though the gamma is a bit high once viewd on the TV set and I just want to know whether importing as 2.2 gamma will help or will this effectively make the gamma even higher and worse once it's viewed on the tv.

  4. 0

    Shane Ross

    Imported from the Apple Support Forums via the Wayback Machine 🔗

    I DON'T care what it looks like on the computer, I want to know if changing import gamma to 2.2 will have an effect on how it looks in the final viewing on the TV set.

    No, it won't. But that won't make your computer monitor show you what it looks like on a TV either.

    Shane

    User uploaded file

  5. 0

    Merged Content 1

    Imported from the Apple Support Forums via the Wayback Machine 🔗

    Yes I understand that, thanks. What then DOES changing the gamma import in FCP do? Does it only change the way it's displayed on the computer's monitor?

  6. 0

    Shane Ross

    Imported from the Apple Support Forums via the Wayback Machine 🔗

    I'll approximate it...but not really show it. Computer monitors and TVs are made of different stuff. Just changing the gamma won't show you the full picture. It might approximate it though. Test and see. Change the gamma, load the footage and compare it to what you see with the DVD on the TV.

    Shane

    User uploaded file

  7. 0

    hanumang

    Imported from the Apple Support Forums via the Wayback Machine 🔗

    CaliforniaJay wrote:

    Everything looks good on my Macbook Pro monitor but once viewed on the TV screen it's not bad, just not good.

    So how does your .264 file look when played back via QT Player on your MacBook Pro? More specifically, is there also a gamma shift between your encoded (.264) file and your original .mov file?

    I ask because a long-standing complaint with FCP/QT/Compressor's other h.264 output (to .mov or .m4v files) is the noticeable gamma-shift, though in the
    other direction (everything gets washed-out).

  8. 0

    Merged Content 1

    Imported from the Apple Support Forums via the Wayback Machine 🔗

    Yes I have done some reading about the problems with QT. Unfortunately I haven't done enough yet to really evaluate this. I am new to Final Cut Pro.

    Thing is I am not using compressor the way I understand it as FCS7 sends directly to blu-ray without using compressor. It's conceivably possible that I just need to fiddle with the TV's settings, however when viewing commercial DVDs or blu-rays, it looks terrific. Again, mind you FCP produced footage doesn't look bad, it just doesn't look great...a bit contrasty and heavy in the shadow areas. It really could be better.

  9. 0

    hanumang

    Imported from the Apple Support Forums via the Wayback Machine 🔗

    CaliforniaJay wrote:

    Thing is I am not using compressor the way I understand it as FCS7 sends directly to blu-ray without using compressor.

    No, I'm afraid you've been misled.

    That export path (Share -> Create Blu-ray) does indeed use Compressor to output a .264 file. That .264 file is then burned to disc (along with the menus). So, an .264 file should be somewhere in your hard drive. Open it in QT Player and please tell us how it looks compared to your Timeline in FCP.

  10. 0

    Merged Content 1

    Imported from the Apple Support Forums via the Wayback Machine 🔗

    Oh ok...thought I had read on Apple's site for FCS7 that it did not use compressor for this. Will do what you suggest, but it may take a day or two. I will report on it as soon as I can.

  11. 0

    Zebulun

    Imported from the Apple Support Forums via the Wayback Machine 🔗

    Again, how are you spitting the video signal out of your laptop to your hdtv?

    Adjusting your display to make video look better is a very dangerous path to travel down. We have standard test signals to enable the daily setup of a display, example being NTSC or PAL or HDTV bars. Feed bars of the flavor of your video to your tv and do the daily setup. It is then incumbent upon you to make your video look better, not the editing software.

  12. 0

    Merged Content 1

    Imported from the Apple Support Forums via the Wayback Machine 🔗

    Again, how are you spitting the video signal out of your laptop to your hdtv?

    Adjusting your display to make video look better is a very dangerous path to travel down. We have standard test signals to enable the daily setup of a display, example being NTSC or PAL or HDTV bars. Feed bars of the flavor of your video to your tv and do the daily setup. It is then incumbent upon you to make your video look better, not the editing software.

    Sorry, again I am just a beginner...when you ask "how are you spitting the video signal out..." what do you mean? I am using Final Cut to author a blu-ray disk which I then insert into a blu-ray player for play through to the TV screen. I am not looking at the video directly from the laptop onto the TV.

  13. 0

    Shane Ross

    Imported from the Apple Support Forums via the Wayback Machine 🔗

    I am using Final Cut to author a blu-ray disk which I then insert into a blu-ray player for play through to the TV screen. I am not looking at the video directly from the laptop onto the TV.

    But you are asking how you can view your footage so that you know what it looks like...BEFORE you author. And we are telling you, several times now...that a computer monitor is not the way to do it. You can do what I suggested, adjust the gamma on the computer, then look at the footage on it compared to what you see on the TV and see how close they are. But that is a pretty awful band-aid solution. You need an HD I/O box to get the signal from your computer to the TV to SHOW you, "hey, this is what your DVD will look like." Without that, you are stabbing in the dark.

    Shane

    User uploaded file

  14. 0

    Merged Content 1

    Imported from the Apple Support Forums via the Wayback Machine 🔗

    No I am sorry for the misunderstanding but that is NOT what I am asking. I understand that the computer monitor will look different if there is no calibration. I understand that there are gamma issues etc. etc

    All I wanted to know is whether changing import gamma would change the way the final output on my TV set would look. If not, I can accept that. Sorry for the confusion but I think it happened when some of the other guys stated then asking me some more questions 🙂

  15. 0

    Shane Ross

    Imported from the Apple Support Forums via the Wayback Machine 🔗

    Changing the IMPORT gamma? What import gamma? If you capture via firewire, or via some tapeless format, you cannot adjust the gamma when you import.

    Yes, changing the gamma will affect the way it looks on the TV, but you change it after you import...using the color correction tools like the 3-way color corrector and boosting the mids a tad, adjusting the other settings to compensate. And to see how you are really changing the footage and what those changes really look like on a TV, you need to use the suggestions offered.

    Shane

    User uploaded file