15 replies
Sign in or join Beachball Help to reply.
- 0
Christopher Price ·
Imported from the Apple Support Forums via the Wayback Machine 🔗
While in theory it looks like it will work, it doesn't appear to work in practice.
It appears that Apple modified the ZIF pins on their connection (or on the drive, as a custom order). When people insert the 120 GB PATA into the first-gen MacBook Air, it results in an I/O error when zeroing the drive.
Bottom line: Despite a lot of time and money, nobody has gotten it to work as of yet.
To those that aren't familiar, you can't use a current-gen MacBook Air drive either, as they are now SATA (the original MacBook Air uses a PATA interface).
- 0
FireFox88 ·
Imported from the Apple Support Forums via the Wayback Machine 🔗
Thanks for the answer. The only way is to buy a new MBA.........
- 0
ebonhomme ·
Imported from the Apple Support Forums via the Wayback Machine 🔗
Hi FireFox88,
I have the same problem as you.
I really run out of space. For the moment, I transport with me an additional external HDD to compensate.
If you find something about it don't forget to post, and so I do.Cheers,
- 0
chambone01 ·
Imported from the Apple Support Forums via the Wayback Machine 🔗
Yes, this is quite annoying. After comparing the pin layout of the Samsung MCCOE64GEMPP-01A and the Kingspec KSD-ZF18.1-128MJ (they're identical), I naively ordered the latter SSD. The drive has yet to arrive, but after using some search engines, I now realize that the chances of getting this to work are slim to non-existent (well, since we're dealing with Apple's escapades here, make that 'non-existent'). Funny thing is that both SSD's work perfectly in quite a few netbooks, as do other SSD's that the MBA apparently won't boot from when installed.
I think I will not even open the box my SSD comes in. I'll put it on eBay right away.
I wonder what Apple was thinking when these decisions were made. If my out-of-warranty first gen MBA's hard drive breaks, my only options are to buy an overpriced replacement off of eBay (because most sellers there are not stupid), or bring it in for repair, paying for labour that I'm perfectly capable of doing myself. HeII, given the stupidity Apple techs have displayed on previous laptop repairs, I'd rather do it myself even if there were no financial difference. And even if I brought it in at Apple, they still can only provide the 80GB HDD or the 64GB SSD. So, to recap, while 128GB PATA ZIF SSD's and 160GB PATA ZIF HDD's (or so I read) are available, they won't work in a Macbook Air. Only the Samsung 80GB and 64GB stuff does.
.
In essence, Macbook Air revision A is dead on arrival. Thanks Apple. Way to go. - 0
RonAnnArbor ·
Imported from the Apple Support Forums via the Wayback Machine 🔗
Here's what Apple was thinking: You want to do this, pay us, we'll do it, use our own equipment, and charge you for the upgrade. Or buy the newer version from us that already comes with an SSD drive.
Apple is not consumer-centric.
- 0
necronym ·
Imported from the Apple Support Forums via the Wayback Machine 🔗
Why not just buy a 32 or 64GB USB stick. I have a 32GB I carry around, but I mostly make use of the 20GB online storage I have on MobieMe.
I have the 80GB first gen model and I think it's excellent.
- 0
Glorfindeal ·
Imported from the Apple Support Forums via the Wayback Machine 🔗
Your sense of reality has been distorted. Apple made it known up front that the mba was not user upgradeable. If this doesn't suit your needs, you should have never purchased it.
Glor
- 0
chambone01 ·
Imported from the Apple Support Forums via the Wayback Machine 🔗
You probably don't see it that way, but your sense of reality has a few problems of its own, my friend. A particularly glaring one is the urge to excuse Apple when they do stupid things. Killing a computer's upgrade options is not the most consumer-centric move I can think of anyway.
MacbookPro, Imac, iPod, Macmini etc aren't user upgradeable either - they say that with half of their products. That doesn't mean that you can't stick in a bigger drive. And besides that, the issue isn't user-upgradeability, the problem is that the machine doesn't support any other hard drive than the ones it originally shipped with. Is this sinking in? Apparently, rev 2 has the same problem. When forced, I'd pay Apple to swap my hard drive for one with more space if they'd offer the possibility. But they don't.
Bear in mind that we're talking about something BASIC as upgrading a hard drive. Indeed, had I known that such an upgrade isn't possible, I never had purchased it. There really is no excuse.
- 0
chambone01 ·
Imported from the Apple Support Forums via the Wayback Machine 🔗
Yes, down here we call that settling for less
Anyhow, I think it's an excellent computer as well. But to cripple it like this is inexcusable. I can only hope Apple will offer upgrades in the future.
- 0
James Bailey ·
Imported from the Apple Support Forums via the Wayback Machine 🔗
The MacBook Air was the first of its' kind when it was released and is still somewhat unique. I would guess that Apple was more concerned with bringing it to market at a price which would encourage adoption, rather than the upgrade options. Component prices were higher then and I don't think Apple can forsee the future regarding what any individual user might want or have available for upgrades more than a year after release. What you're asking for is basically the ability to "hack" the computer to provide different or greater functionality than Apple originally provided. I agree that it would be nice if Apple had planned to accommodate you but they didn't. When you buy technology like this buy it with the understanding that after a year or two of good use there will be something newer you want to upgrade to.
As to repairing your hard drive should it break, had you purchased Applecare it would be Apples problem, not yours. I took mine in for repair and it was back in my hands inside of a week, no charge. That's what Applecare is for.
- 0
chambone01 ·
Imported from the Apple Support Forums via the Wayback Machine 🔗
Excuses James, nothing more. There's nothing functionality-extending or 'hackey' about replacing a hard drive. You make it sound like I'm trying to build a GPS receiver or a firewire port into the thing. What I am asking for is the ability to replace the hard disk with a unit that has the same interface, the same connector and the same dimensions. A standard PATA 1.8" drive with a standard ZIF connector. Just as standard as the one that's in there right now. Whether I do it myself or have it done is irrelevant. There's no reason whatsoever for not allowing this, so I'm having some slight trouble understanding why you're trying so hard to babble a wrong right.
But yeah, I have to concede that the Macbook Air is unique. Unique in that it's the only laptop around that does not boot from anything other than the two drives it shipped with originally.
- 0
rmoriz ·
Imported from the Apple Support Forums via the Wayback Machine 🔗
Hi,
did you try that 128SSD in your MBA or did you gave up?
I searched the web but was not able to find informations regarding incompatible pata/zif SSDs and Macbook Air so I'm quite curious.
- 0
zxcnlsflkf_asjd% ·
Imported from the Apple Support Forums via the Wayback Machine 🔗
As a customer
As a stock holder
And as one of the 12 people out there that would like to upgrade my Gen A SSD on my Airbook...If Apple saved $1 by using the configuration they did on each Airbook I agree and support their decision.
The 12 of us users who want to upgrade our airbook SSD are IRRELEVANT as a demographic - and if it cost Apple more to accommodate us good riddance I say.
Apple says not upgradable therefore you took you chances when you bought.
To put this back on Apple as not being 'consumer focused' is disingenuous at the least. It certainly leaves you looking like a bitter owner w/o much credibility.
- 0
zaxflash ·
Imported from the Apple Support Forums via the Wayback Machine 🔗
http://cgi.ebay.com/128GB-1-8-PATA-ZIF2-MLC-SSD-for-macbook-air-1st-OQO-02
W0QQitemZ360155216482QQcmdZViewItemQQptZPCC_Drives_Storage_Internal?hash=item53d aec7a62&_trksid=p3286.c0.m14&trkparms=72%3A1234|66%3A2|65%3A12|39%3A1|240%3A1318|301%3A1|293%3A1|294%3A50They say that the SSD works on the Air, although they don't show the underside so we can see if it's too tall (8mm?) or if they used an adapter, on the auction they say you don't need an adapter? can anyone confirm this?
- 0
carl wolf ·
Imported from the Apple Support Forums via the Wayback Machine 🔗
"MacbookPro, Imac, iPod, Macmini etc aren't user upgradeable either"
That's simply not true. Many users have successfully upgraded their MacBook Pro computers.