My CPU is running > 109 C degrees
apple Verified ·
Imported from the Apple Support Forums via the Wayback Machine 🔗
I have been trying to look for information both on google and this forum but found them inconclusive. I ran handbrake to convert my videos to .mp4 or .m4v so the cpu cores were running 100% for more than 1-2 hours. Upon running this application for few minutes, the CPU temp would shoot up to 109 degrees before fans start to kick in and bring the CPU to 90 degrees.
I expect MBP to be able to run serious applications such as prolonged video encoding or photo rendering, thus such CPU high temperature (if causing issues/shortening life span) is not acceptable.
My questions:
1) Is it normal for CPU to reach over 100 degrees celcious upon high load?
2) Although the fans will bring down the temperature, what is the exposure/risk having it exceeding 100 degrees for few minutes (Some websites mention this as the max. operating temp for Intel core duo).
3) Any idea what can be done?
Apple care first line support can't really answer this one.
15 replies
Sign in or join Beachball Help to reply.
- 0
iVmichael ·
Imported from the Apple Support Forums via the Wayback Machine 🔗
1) No, above 100C is not "optimal" according to Intel
2) The fans should kick in before it gets above 100C and if it stays above that for any length of time I believe the machine will shut down as a fail-safe measure.
3) Try using SMC Fan Control or a similar utility and set the fans to run at maximum revs (6000rpm) before starting the software that loads the CPU so heavily ... turn them down when finished. - 0
Michael Flynn ·
Imported from the Apple Support Forums via the Wayback Machine 🔗
definitely not normal but handbrake does consume all of the cpu and running the cpu at 100% will cause hot temps. The issue is whether your fans are kicking in or speeding up. When I got my unibody MBP, the fans would not ramp up, they stayed spinning at 2k. I reset the SMC which resolved the issue, and I recommend trying that if you have not.
SMCFanControl is something I also highly recommend, its shows you the temps on the menu bar and you can also manually set the fan speed so if you are doing something intensive you can spin them at max speed to keep the temps down.
- 0
Travis A. ·
Imported from the Apple Support Forums via the Wayback Machine 🔗
I use Handbrake too. However, the temps on my MBP have never gotten higher than 90ºC on my MBP. Usually just below that the fans kick on and lower things down to around 75ºC, where it stays with the fans spinning at ~3500RPM.
If the system is letting your CPU get to ~110ºC before kicking the fans on then something is wrong. Possibly a bad temp sensor or something similar. It should not get that hot. I personally would give Apple a call about it.
I don't trust SMCFanControl, though many people recommend it. I'm not putting it on my machine. Apple designs these MBPs in particular to be pro machines and intends that people use them for intensive tasks. I'm sure that they've programmed these machines to kick the fans on before anything becomes problematic. I do think that ~110ºC is too hot though.
--Travis
- 0
Lukas Svoboda ·
Imported from the Apple Support Forums via the Wayback Machine 🔗
Setting the fans speed manually is totally unacceptable for an $2500 notebook. The built-in hardware sensors MUST detect the rising CPU (and GPU) temperature soon enough to be able to spin the fans AUTOMATICALLY and keep the CPU (and GPU) low. It works this way on cheap PC notebooks, it has to work the same way on an Apple MacBook (Pro).
- 0
demolasko ·
Imported from the Apple Support Forums via the Wayback Machine 🔗
try resetting the SMC:
http://support.apple.com/kb/HT1411?viewlocale=en_US
Note: Starting with MacBook Pro (Late 2008) and MacBook (Late 2008) models, you may instead use the reset method for MacBook Air to reset the SMC. All earlier models of MacBook and MacBook Pro must use the method described, which involves removing the battery.
- 0
Leonard Ong ·
Imported from the Apple Support Forums via the Wayback Machine 🔗
Exactly with what I have read so far. Over 100 degrees Celcious is not desirable. Therefore, I'm concerned about the exposure of the CPU running over the that threshold before fans kicked in.
I tried SMCfanControl before with my iMac. I found it not really working as well. I mean, if I wanted to be on the paranoid side, it works fine. It'd activate fans earlier than the system would on default setting. I found the fans would spin faster even at the slightest increased temperature. I uninstalled and for iMac, it is fine. My CPU never exceeded 90 degrees and the fan would kicked in before it even reach 90 degrees.
For my MBP, as mentioned it is different. With fans, 88-95 degrees is not good when I queued handbrake for 3 days! I end-up doing everything on my iMac, but then it is not why bought MBP at USD 2600.
The apple care specialist (after going through 'rather not useful but polite and courteous first line support', the specialist mentioned that the 3rd party sensors/apps (e.g. istat) can't be trusted and Apple has built a safety mechanism which the machine would sleep if the temperature exceeded the set threshold.
So, it's really still open... to SMCfanControl or not. I'll try resetting the SMC as suggested, is there any 'impact' I should expect from resetting SMC?
- 0
Leonard Ong ·
Imported from the Apple Support Forums via the Wayback Machine 🔗
I'll reset the SMC and monitor the temp with iStat Menu. If it does't help, I'll try SMCfanControl.
Can it be uninstalled easily? Last time I check it is not.
- 0
Leonard Ong ·
Imported from the Apple Support Forums via the Wayback Machine 🔗
Wow, I guess you are in a better condition. My MBP is warm after using for many hours and only for browsing with wireless is on. The CPU is about 60+ degrees Celcious without any heavy load.
- 0
demolasko ·
Imported from the Apple Support Forums via the Wayback Machine 🔗
what GPU are you using? SMCfancontrol is deleted by dragging from the app folder to the trash.
Message was edited by: demolasko
- 0
Travis A. ·
Imported from the Apple Support Forums via the Wayback Machine 🔗
I've just been browsing AD for about 20 minutes and the temp on my MBP is at 43ºC. This is under the 9400M. I've found that temps are 10-15ºC warmer when running the 9600GT though. Seeing as I'm on battery and such here though, I run the 9400M. Unless you are doing any heavy intensive computing I would recommend using the 9400M.
--Travis
- 0
preller ·
Imported from the Apple Support Forums via the Wayback Machine 🔗
we have already a thread about this problem going in here:
http://discussions.apple.com/thread.jspa?threadID=1823105&tstart=0btw:
this fan control problem affects EVERY (yes EVERY) late '08 MBP. this is a FACT.
everyone who predicts his MBP is not affected, *isn't testing it correct*.
the 2.8GHz models heat up to 110°C until the fans speed up and
the 2.4/2.53GHz models heat up to ~95-100°C until the fans speed up (under normal surrounding temps and surfaces). - 0
Travis A. ·
Imported from the Apple Support Forums via the Wayback Machine 🔗
everyone who predicts his MBP is not affected, isn't testing it correct.
the 2.4/2.53GHz models heat up to ~95-100°C until the fans speed up (under normal surrounding temps and surfaces).
Could you please enlighten me as to how I would test my MBP? I have transcoded videos using Handbrake, encoded and burned using iDVD, and tested quite a few games. All of that gets the processors well into the 150% range. It heats up to ~85ºC and then the fans kick in and it cools to ~75ºC with the fans around ~3500RPM. You have no facts to back up your claims, just anecdotal evidence and a few forum posts. I can attest that not every MBP has this issue (if it is even an issue at all), as mine certainly doesn't. Further, I am quite confident that Apple knows the thermal limits of the machine and processor quite a bit better than any of us, seeing as they
designed the computer.--Travis
- 0
Leonard Ong ·
Imported from the Apple Support Forums via the Wayback Machine 🔗
I'm using default 9400 GPU, If I were to use 9600 it'd be even a lot hotter w/o CPU usage.
My ambient temperature according to istat is 28-30 degrees.
- 0
Plecostomus ·
Imported from the Apple Support Forums via the Wayback Machine 🔗
I posted a while back in the thread you cross-referenced. My MacBook Pro has the same behavior as yours. I contacted Apple and a Product Specialist said it should be sent in for hardware repair.
They kept it about a week and returned it with nothing changed, with the explanation that they couldn't duplicate any of the problems reported. (I emphasized the heat issue, but I had also experienced several incidences of hard freezes, and one kernel panic involving "com.apple.driver.AppleIntelCPUPowerManagement".) On getting it back, I immediately tested and duplicated the fan behavior, with both 9400 and 9600 GPU's.
I asked that this information be forwarded to the engineering team. This included plots of fan speed and temperatures versus time, showing that the fans do not begin to ramp up until more than 100 deg-C (about 108 deg-C in the case of the 9600 GPU). After running a while, the temp drops to about 90+ deg-C, and during this time the fans never reach maximum speed. This occurs when the CPUs are stressed, which for test purposes I do by running "yes > /dev/null" for each core. (When the CPU is not fully stressed, the fan begins to ramp sooner, at 80-90 deg-C, although the behavior seems erratic.)
I have not yet had a response to the last information I gave Apple.
- 0
preller ·
Imported from the Apple Support Forums via the Wayback Machine 🔗
Travis A. wrote:
everyone who predicts his MBP is not affected, isn't testing it correct.
the 2.4/2.53GHz models heat up to ~95-100°C until the fans speed up (under normal surrounding temps and surfaces).
Could you please enlighten me as to how I would test my MBP? I have transcoded videos using Handbrake, encoded and burned using iDVD, and tested quite a few games. All of that gets the processors well into the 150% range. It heats up to ~85ºC and then the fans kick in and it cools to ~75ºC with the fans around ~3500RPM. You have no facts to back up your claims, just anecdotal evidence and a few forum posts. I can attest that not every MBP has this issue (if it is even an issue at all), as mine certainly doesn't. Further, I am quite confident that Apple knows the thermal limits of the machine and processor quite a bit better than any of us, seeing as they
designed the computer.--Travis
set your MBP to sleep, let it cool down, wake it up, start immediately an application which really uses ~195% CPU, tilt your LCD backwards to the max, watch at your temperature monitoring app (istat pro?).
you have to heat up your weaker MBP model as fast as possible. than you'll see that the fan control is faulty.
if l let my MBP heat up slowly (150% CPU) the fans kick in @ 85-90°C. just like yours (and i have the 2.8GHz MBP!).
the good thing on the 2.4GHz model is, that it's really slowly heating up, even if it's at the maximum usage (~195%).
on the 2.8GHz model, the temps dash formerly up to 110°C @ maximum CPU usage. so this whole thing is just a time factor...
the people with the weaker MBPs don't really notice that the fan control is faulty because it takes so long until the CPU reaches this mad temps and as soon as the CPU reaches this temp the fans kick in and cool the CPU down. would the 2.8GHz models heat up that slowly, this whole thing wouldn't be such a big problem...