Benches MacBooks

15

battery health at 95% after only 10 days …

apple Verified

Imported from the Apple Support Forums via the Wayback Machine 🔗

I've had this mbp for about six weeks. i had it sent to my house and then finally got it up to my university and had been using it since sunday (around 10 days ago) and already it is stating under iStat and coconutbattery that i have 93-95% battery health is that normal or should i worry? i took it to a designated apple product dealer at my school to see what was up and they said that they found no problems with my battery after running battery diagnostics on it and they won't give me a replacement. i called applecare again and the guy said that i should monitor how long my mbp actually goes for on battery and if its well below the thresh-hold (5-7 hours) i should take it to the store to get replaced....ahhh i dunno what to do 😟

oh and i have gone through 4 cycles apparently

hope someone can help!

15 replies

Sign in or join Beachball Help to reply.

  1. 0

    JasonFear

    Imported from the Apple Support Forums via the Wayback Machine 🔗

    Hi wumandu,

    iStat Pro and Coconut Battery are two battery monitoring applications that are not approved by Apple by means of accurately reporting battery information. Nor are they way to attract the support of AppleCare to warrant a replacement.

    My MBP is also about six weeks old and it's current full charge capacity is 5359 mAh. It arrived to me with a FCC of 5572 mAh. Which means that technically my battery health is only 96%. Ironically, iStat Pro says my health is 99% and Coconut say it's at 98%.

    So which is it...?

    Personally, I wouldn't worry about it. If you browse this forum, you'll find that a new thread, addressing this exact issue (less than 3 month old machine, battery health between 92-95%) is asked about once day, 7 days a week. Out of curiosity, what is the FCC of your battery? What was it when you received it?

    The "threshold" you speak of is anything but... the battery is capable of getting *UP TO* 7 hours off a full charge. You'll fine users will get varying results, based on usage. I've got well over that before and I've gotten less than half that as well.

  2. 0

    Retired Engineer

    Imported from the Apple Support Forums via the Wayback Machine 🔗

    As long as the battery health is 80% or greater the battery is within Apple's specifications.

  3. 0

    Network 23

    Imported from the Apple Support Forums via the Wayback Machine 🔗

    Do not obsess over small short-term changes in battery capacity because the small changes are meaningless; you'll drive yourself as crazy as watching a stock price every day. The long term trend is what's important. Over the course of a week, my battery capacity stats fluctuate between two readings about 10% apart. If you're consistently down to like 60% after a month, then I'd worry.

    JasonFear wrote:

    iStat Pro and Coconut Battery are two battery monitoring applications that are not approved by Apple by means of accurately reporting battery information. Nor are they way to attract the support of AppleCare to warrant a replacement.

    That's probably a little unfair. Those applications report the same stats you get in Apple's own System Profiler, only in a nicer format.

  4. 0

    LaurieNY

    Imported from the Apple Support Forums via the Wayback Machine 🔗

    I've had my MBP for only two weeks, and it's at 94% health (5151 full-charge capacity, 5070 remaining according to both iStat Nano and System Profiler) after 7 cycles--it's a refurb and came to me with 4 cycles already on it. Even when fully charged, the battery menu icon reads 98%, never 100%. Genius of course says it's fine.

    Frankly I feel kind of ripped off over not getting a new battery, refurb or not. I understand the computer is technically "used," but it's supposed to be sent to me "as new," and I shouldn't have been given the same old battery the previous owner was using for however long. Four full cycles already on it, and a 6% loss of capacity in only two weeks, spells a battery that had a few miles on it. I think I should have gotten a brand-new battery.

  5. 0

    eww

    Imported from the Apple Support Forums via the Wayback Machine 🔗

    The genius says it's fine because is IS fine. When you buy a new car, the odometer never reads zero. Your battery isn't used. You are obsessing over nothing.

  6. 0

    JasonFear

    Imported from the Apple Support Forums via the Wayback Machine 🔗

    Network 23 wrote:

    That's probably a little unfair. Those applications report the same stats you get in Apple's own System Profiler, only in a nicer format.

    I'm going to have to disagree. On my 13" MBP, currently reporting:

    System Profiler:

    Original FCC - 5571

    Current FCC - 5352

    Health Value - 96%

    Coconut:

    Original FCC - 5680

    Current FCC - 5218

    Health Value - 91%

    iStat Pro:

    Health Value - 98%

    Of the 3 machines I have on my desk, all of them report different values across the board. So which one is right? I still maintain that you should always reference System Profiler as the primary source.

  7. 0

    LaurieNY

    Imported from the Apple Support Forums via the Wayback Machine 🔗

    So batteries generally come to you at 96% health with 4 full charge cycles on them? And lose 6% capacity in 7 cycles, when they're supposed to take 1000 cycles and a few years to lose 20%? I'm an Apple fangirl too, been exclusively and fanatically Apple for over 20 years, but that still doesn't sound quite right to me, mathematically or otherwise.

    I'm not sure why you dismiss the idea that a battery at 96% health/4 cycles that came with a refurb might be used. Seems kind of obvious to me that I have the original battery from the first owner, but the techs deemed it "good enough." However, at this rate, I can't see it lasting " up to five years" and "up to 1000 recharges before it reaches 80 percent of its original capacity," unless of course "up to" actually means like 2 months and 20 recharges. Could be...

  8. 0

    eww

    Imported from the Apple Support Forums via the Wayback Machine 🔗

    Since you don't believe anything you're told, why would anyone bother to tell you anything more?

  9. 0

    wumandu

    Imported from the Apple Support Forums via the Wayback Machine 🔗

    thanks everyone for your speedy replies i think i really am maybe just being paranoid. im going to monitor like the techie guy at school told me for a week or two and see how long it lasts after normal use (ie web browsing and maybe typing up a paper or something) and if it is way too short i'll take it to the apple store to have them check it out. if anyone else has any other input feel free! it's all appreciated!

  10. 0

    JasonFear

    Imported from the Apple Support Forums via the Wayback Machine 🔗

    Hi LaurieNY,

    A refurbished computer, by Apple, is not considered "used" so I'm unsure where you read that on Apple's site. You also more than likely didn't get someone's used battery. I've purchased well over 500 portable computers from Apple over the years and I've seen batteries from brand new (not refurbished) come with anywhere from 1 to as many as 5 cycles. Recently I even came across a machine that brand new had 10 charge cycles right out of the box (2.16GHz MacBook Air).

    The first several weeks and months, the full charge capacity and battery health will bounce around. On my new 13" MacBook Pro and 15" MacBook Pro, throughout the first 10 weeks of ownership my "health" dipped as low as 92% to as high as 100%.

    Secondly, if you're not satisfied with the response from the Mac Genius then call up the Apple online store (800-MY-APPLE), give them your web order # and say you're not satisfied with the product and you'd like to either get a new battery or exchange the machine. They'll then be able to offer you what is within their scope of support.

  11. 0

    kbin

    Imported from the Apple Support Forums via the Wayback Machine 🔗

    i have been using my MBP 13' for a month.

    After reading the discussions and check wit my battery cycle, i found out that i have battery cycle count of 32. I charge my MBP every time it runs out of battery, of course i do use it frequently.

    Is it too much to have 32 batt cycle for a month?

    Should i charge it when i'm using it at home?

  12. 0

    eww

    Imported from the Apple Support Forums via the Wayback Machine 🔗

    You are completely discharging and recharging your battery about every day. Deep discharges and full recharges will age your battery faster than partial discharges and recharges, so yes, whenever you have the opportunity to plug in your AC adapter, you should do so. One or two charge/discharge cycles a week, instead of seven, will keep your battery in the best possible condition for the longest possible time. Of course if the nature of your work requires you to cycle it more often, you'll have to do that, but your battery won't last as long if you do.

  13. 0

    kbin

    Imported from the Apple Support Forums via the Wayback Machine 🔗

    thanks for the advice.

    cheers.

  14. 0

    LaurieNY

    Imported from the Apple Support Forums via the Wayback Machine 🔗

    Thanks, JasonFear. I'm down to 92% health after only 8 cycles, and at this rate, I honestly can't see this battery lasting very long at all, certainly not the "several years" advertised. It's just simple mathematics to me, really. If it's supposed to retain 80% health after 1000 cycles, and I'm already down to 92% after 8 cycles, there's probably something wrong here. It's losing 1% per cycle (actually this last cycle caused it to lose 2%). It's just too soon for this level of deterioration, if the battery was in fact new when I got it. And if it WAS a new battery, it's defective. And BTW, I didn't think Apple stuck a random used battery in, only that they left the same battery in when the machine was returned, instead of putting in a brand-new one for me.

    Anyway, thanks for your patient and kind tone. It's much appreciated. 🙂

  15. 0

    JasonFear

    Imported from the Apple Support Forums via the Wayback Machine 🔗

    Hi LaurieNY,

    I wish you the best in reaching out to Apple. I'm sure they'll make it right for you.