Benches MacBooks

9

MacBook Pro Problems with WPA Security

apple Verified

Imported from the Apple Support Forums via the Wayback Machine 🔗

I am having some trouble using my home network with my MacBook Pro. My network consists of: a modem, which is connected to my router, which connects to all of my WiFi devices, just like many regular networks do. I rely on WEP security because all of my WiFi devices support it and it is the only form of encryption that works consistently. Now what I mean by this is that I cannot use WPA encryption on my home network without problems on my MacBook Pro. In Network Utility, my MBP reports several received and incoming errors while my network is using WPA security. However, I can still connect to and use the web. I want to find out where these errors are coming from and why. This problem affects only my MacBook Pro; I don't think I have ever seen them on my iMac G4.

No errors are reported under WEP or when I disable security altogether. I have used other WPA networks with no problems whatsoever; it just seems to be here with my gear and the MBP.

But here's the thing: my current MBP was a new replacement for my old original 2.16Ghz MBP. That Mac displayed the same errors as I can detect with this one, although it had trouble connecting to
any network whatsoever. This MBP works great with everything. Sometime after it was replaced, I replaced my old D-Link router with a new Belkin "n" router, and then I replaced my old Speedstream DSL modem with a 2Wire gateway model. I configured the 2Wire to work in "bridge mode" (I disabled the built-in router) in order for the faster Belkin device to function as the main WiFi router. This prevents dual-NAT issues, allowing me to use Back To My Mac with no problems. Using the 2Wire by itself doesn't fix the issue either. In short, all of the networking gear works, so long as I use anything but WPA with my MBP. As far as I can tell, everything else supposedly works with it. The only other network issue that I may have is that my Xbox 360 seems to have trouble with my firewall, meaning that a few Xbox Live services do not work properly. This is truly frustrating.

Basically, this issue has persisted through all of these different hardware combinations when I try to work with WPA forms of security. This would seem that the incoming DSL connection is having some trouble. There are only 3 or 4 other networks in the neighborhood, and none of them appear to be running on the same WiFi channels. Changing my own channels does not help at all. I have wrestled with this problem for quite some time now, and I still haven't fixed it. I've practically replaced every major networking device, and I know they all work. And just by looking over the majority of the details, I think that the DSL connection could be responsible. Honestly, I don't know. I may have to call my ISP and ask them some questions... still, if the problems can be resolved with software methods, I will look into them. I'd really appreciate any recommendations or suggestions. Thanks in advance.

-MacUser

9 replies

Sign in or join Beachball Help to reply.

  1. 0

    rvaro

    Imported from the Apple Support Forums via the Wayback Machine 🔗

    what i would do to try out is to disable the wireless function on your all in one modem... connect your access point into the modem and use the wireless signal from that... maybe i missed something in your post tho...

  2. 0

    ARealMac(PPC)User

    Imported from the Apple Support Forums via the Wayback Machine 🔗

    Actually, this is exactly what I have done. My modem serves only as a bridge; I disabled its WiFi functions and other router abilities. My other router, which is faster, handles everything for it. Removing the external router does not solve anything. Wireless networking works fine either way.

    I am coming to the assumption that my incoming DSL signal may just get interference be it from other networks, or poor/damaged lines somewhere. I have tried several things in order to use WPA, but to no avail. Ah well... I'm still open to any tips and all, but for the time being, I am going to stop experimenting on my own; I've run out of ideas to try.

    -MacUser

  3. 0

    rvaro

    Imported from the Apple Support Forums via the Wayback Machine 🔗

    are you able to ask your ISP for a new modem that is only a modem... DSL company here does the same thing... they give you an all on one and of course there is always an issue but if we call them then we can exchange for just a plain modem.

    the all in ones are also the 2wire ones, but the plain modems are the speed stream...

  4. 0

    ARealMac(PPC)User

    Imported from the Apple Support Forums via the Wayback Machine 🔗

    Well I upgraded from a Speedstream to the 2Wire. While I wasn't exactly expecting to receive an all-in-one gateway, I made it work, and it is better than the old modem that I had, which did not function properly. It couldn't handle any sort of high-speed connections or bandwidths at all. Download speeds were terrible. But this problem existed with that modem too.

    I don't think there is too much I can do here. My ISP probably doesn't know how to fix this issue, and my hardware is not the source of the problem. The errors exist only when certain encryption methods are used and yet the connections still go through... I'm stumped on how to approach this because there seems to be little that I can do.

    -MacUser

  5. 0

    Inquisitive

    Imported from the Apple Support Forums via the Wayback Machine 🔗

    I 'm having the same or a similar problem. I switched my network from WEP security to WPA. Since then, I have had trouble staying connected to another computer on my home network. Whenever I try to copy a large file, 150 mb or so, from one computer to the other, the connection often breaks and I get the following message: "The wireless network appears to have been compromised and will be disabled for about a minute." This stops me from copying the file and I have to start over again. The MB will copy the file, but its hit or miss. I have a DSL modem, but it is not an all in one wireless unit. I have a netgear router connected to it. I had been using WEP without a problem for years, so I'm sure it is the wpa security that is the cause of the problem.

    I don't have a solution, I just thought I would add my experience to the thread.

  6. 0

    ARealMac(PPC)User

    Imported from the Apple Support Forums via the Wayback Machine 🔗

    Thanks for the input. I guess there may or may not be a real solution for this... I appreciate the info though.

    -MacUser

  7. 0

    Inquisitive

    Imported from the Apple Support Forums via the Wayback Machine 🔗

    Sorry to read that. Thanks for the response. At least now I know.

  8. 0

    Dogcow-Moof

    Imported from the Apple Support Forums via the Wayback Machine 🔗

    Your "wireless network has been compromised" message means either your router is getting various encryption values wrong, or there is noise or interference from other routers or devices in your area corrupting packets.

    To simplify the concepts as much as possible, there's a specific value that is supposed to accompany each encrypted packet received, and if that value is incorrect it's treated as if an attacker is trying to spoof packets on your network, thus the message.

  9. 0

    Inquisitive

    Imported from the Apple Support Forums via the Wayback Machine 🔗

    So what's the solution?