Headphone noise
apple Verified ·
Imported from the Apple Support Forums via the Wayback Machine 🔗
Just acquired a new macbook pro. THis question has probably been asked, but I'm getting a lot of noise similar to that when streaming at low quality from audio output when headphones are plugged. I have read that there is many people with this problem, but does anyone know if apple can or are willing to do anything to rectify it? I have Sennheiser HD212 Pro which are quite a low impedance, but most of my sound files are high quality so I'm convinced I have the same problem as many people
9 replies
Sign in or join Beachball Help to reply.
- 0
guy1 ·
Imported from the Apple Support Forums via the Wayback Machine 🔗
I just got a new MacBook Pro myself. I've noticed two issues:
1. There is a "popping" sound when you first play audio (from iTunes, etc). This sound comes from the headphones which are plugged in, and also from the MacBook Pro speakers when the headphones are not plugged in. I've noticed that about 1 minute after stopping audio (like a song from iTunes), the popping sound happens again. My theory is that this popping sound correlates with the turning on and turning off of the speaker system (whether it be from the MacBook Pro speakers that are built in or the audio coming from the headphone jack). Does anybody know if the software of a MacBook Pro controls the turning on and turning off of the audio system? Perhaps if it does, the reasoning behind this might be to conserve battery life.
2. While the speaker system is on (see my theory in issue 1 above), there is noise feedback from the internal workings of the computer. While this is not very noticeable while playing loud music, it is slightly noticeable while playing soft music.
Both of the issues above are more noticeable with headphones due to the clarity of headphones.
I called AppleCare today regarding these issues. The man told me that he has two computers: a MacBook Pro and a MacBook. He said he hasn't noticed these issues and that he uses his computers for music all of the time, even with headphones. He offered to test his computers at home and give me a call either today or tomorrow. This was very generous of him. I'll post his results after he gives me a call.
If anyone reading this could listen hard for these issues on their MacBook Pros, and report back on this forum, I'd appreciate it! While this is not a major issue, it might be something easily fixable and something worth fixing. You know?
Thanks for all your help out there. I'll report back soon.
- 0
Amberdine ·
Imported from the Apple Support Forums via the Wayback Machine 🔗
Yep, it's the same for everyone.
Higher impedance helps. (I gather radio shack sells things you can insert inline.)
- 0
matthew Allen ·
Imported from the Apple Support Forums via the Wayback Machine 🔗
Just got my new mbp yesterday; am concerned about what I'm hearing through my headphones. I think it's the same feedback you're all talking about. I bet many people don't hear the noise, or can't focus on it, but to anyone who listens to music closely over headphones it should be unmistakeable.
There are some suggestions in this thread that people understand the issue. I wonder if there's some kind of a programmable firmware-type fix, or if it's caused by something physical which would have to be replaced, or if it can be fixed at all. Also wonder how issues like this move up the defect food chain at apple to something that should be addressed.
- 0
matthew Allen ·
Imported from the Apple Support Forums via the Wayback Machine 🔗
ps I see this
"Higher impedance helps. (I gather radio shack sells things you can insert inline.)"
and will investigate. But I'd rather not have to do anything to fix it - that's why I'm on a mac... 😉
- 0
legriffin ·
Imported from the Apple Support Forums via the Wayback Machine 🔗
Hi,
I just purchased a new Macbook Pro and i'm having this issue too. Just bought some new headphones and the noise is really bugging me. Can we get an official word on this please?
- 0
another Christopher ·
Imported from the Apple Support Forums via the Wayback Machine 🔗
Same problem. Unless the music is so loud as to drown it out, a crackling and popping sound will be audible when listening to music on headphones. With quiet passages in classical music (imported with Apple Lossless) the crackling can be substantially louder than the music. Listen to the same tracks on the iPod using the same headphones, and there's no problem.
Really disappointing. Paid too much for this thing to have a problem like this right out of the box.
- 0
Anthony Crockett ·
Imported from the Apple Support Forums via the Wayback Machine 🔗
Saw a Mac genius yesterday, and he wasn't able to hear what I was talking about in the store. He even took it out the back to listen. However he did report that a complaint had been made, and that I could go back in the future to try to see if anyone could hear it. I find that it really is only noticeable at low volume, in the quite sections of music, and the "rjd2" noise can be heard when playing music loud through the headphones and then pausing it immediatley, the sound card can be heard to "warm" down, which occurs in quite a lot of hifi amplifiers. I guess if alot of people manage to report the problem/fault then they might consider doing something about it but I think that a lot of people have this problem and have got nowhere with apple. Its a real shame that something designed for professional, some in the music industry , have to put up with such a fault, even if you use external sound modules.
- 0
brooklyn Jason ·
Imported from the Apple Support Forums via the Wayback Machine 🔗
I'm having the same problem. It's driving me crazy! I'm using Ultimate Ears isolating earbuds, so i can hear these sounds, where nobody else can. The sound is even present while listening to DVD audio.
So I've figured out the the noise comes in 2 or 3 parts:
1. The low-level hiss whenever the audio hardware is engaged. (this stops about 10 seconds after any audio is going through the hardware (even system notifications).
1a. The noticeable 'click' or 'pop' when the audio system is clicked on or off.
2. The swirly, 'bad-encoded mp3' sound that surrounds mid-frequency sounds.
3. (may be related to 1 or 2): random pops, beeps, clicks and all-around noise that interferes with complex music.
I've noticed that the sound is more persistent and louder when I'm at work and i have a monitor, power, mouse and a network cable plugged in. My theory so far is that the issue is related to some electrical component that is not grounded.
I really hope this can be resolved; This is the first Mac I've ever owned and $3k seems like a lot to spend on something with crappy audio.
- 0
StephenCCH ·
Imported from the Apple Support Forums via the Wayback Machine 🔗
Yes this is a very big issue for professional audio guys and one that a lot of people would like resolved by Apple. Here is the link to the full discussion about that noise: http://discussions.apple.com/message.jspa?messageID=6057460.