Macbook Pro metal casing shocking me
apple Verified ·
Imported from the Apple Support Forums via the Wayback Machine 🔗
I am having issues with the metal case of my macbook pro developing some kind of electrical charge to the extent it shocks me and has a vibration to it as you run your hand across it. I can unplug the power cord and it stops. I am overseas with the military and have tried it on the 240v and a 110v transformer to see if either made a difference, both have the issue.
Has anyone else seen this?
14 replies
Sign in or join Beachball Help to reply.
- 0
Fleagar ·
Imported from the Apple Support Forums via the Wayback Machine 🔗
I have also had this issue with my MacBook Pro. I noticed it earlier today. The charge that was on the surface was of low charge. i am on normal 110 voltage. when i unplugged the computer it stopped happening.
i am a little worried that this could to further issues with my computer - 0
UltraNEO-__ ·
Imported from the Apple Support Forums via the Wayback Machine 🔗
also... could be that your wearing something containing Nylon? cause movements in your clothing can generate a static charge and touching the metal case of your MBP is just earthing you.
Umm. having 3 prongs on the mains wont do nowt, considering the adaptor only takes two anyway and you can't earth plastic since it's non-conductive.
- 0
carl wolf ·
Imported from the Apple Support Forums via the Wayback Machine 🔗
The situation is normal and, as another person posted, use the 3-prong AC cord, a 3-prong AC plug adapter, and plug them into a properly grounded AC outlet. The situation is caused because the power adapterp laces 1/2 of the input line voltage (at a low current level) onto the computer chassis.
- 0
afmanusa ·
Imported from the Apple Support Forums via the Wayback Machine 🔗
Thanks for the info. As the power adapter comes with both the 2 and 3 prong plugs, it seems odd that they would have a design that can allow for this surface charge to occur that causes pain to their customers. Being overseas the outlets are not graced with nice grounded plugs where I am to rid me of this issue.
Does it not seem a bad design on their part ? (or design flaw to me when i have to unplug power cord to discharge the built up charge that keeps shocking me) This can't be an acceptable design for their product to me and seems a bit of a safety hazard to me.
- 0
UltraNEO-__ ·
Imported from the Apple Support Forums via the Wayback Machine 🔗
The situation is normal and, as another person
posted, use the 3-prong AC cord, a 3-prong AC plug
adapter, and plug them into a properly grounded AC
outlet. The situation is caused because the power
adapterp laces 1/2 of the input line voltage (at a
low current level) onto the computer chassis.A regular car also "laces 1/2 of the input line voltage" into the chassis, does that shock you too? You should bear in mind a 12 volt car battery carries enough current to send you 15-30 feet!!!
- 0
carl wolf ·
Imported from the Apple Support Forums via the Wayback Machine 🔗
"A regular car also 'places 1/2 of the input line voltage' into the chassis, does that shock you too?"
No, genius, because it's 6VDC, not 120VAC.
"Does it not seem a bad design on their part ? (or design flaw to me when i have to unplug power cord to discharge the built up charge that keeps shocking me)"
You're talking about 2 different things here. Not all AC outlets will accept a 3-prong power cord, so a 2-prong AC cord is also available. Two, an IEC spec calls for a 2-prong cord, and Apple needs to meet that spec for international shipments. When you unplug the AC adapter, a large capacitor starts to discharge and, if you touch the AC prongs before the cap is discharged, you will get a shock. It's won't hurt you, but it is very annoying. If a larger bleeder resistor is used (to discharge the capacitor), the power adapter will not meet the latest Energy Star ratings.
- 0
afmanusa ·
Imported from the Apple Support Forums via the Wayback Machine 🔗
Not sure we are on same page. With the laptop plugged into 2 prong outlet the case will build up a charge that when i rest my arms on to type on the keyboard, the thiner skin on the bottom of my arm feels like I am getting stabbed with needles, I am getting electrical discharge from the metal case. By unplugging the power cord from laptop it fades away immediately. Also, while it is sending a charge into my skin, I can rub my hand on sides of laptop or across the back of display and feel a vibration from the charge. The fact that this issue is not happening 24/7 is odd to me, let alone the fact it happens at all. Regardless of the physics behind this issue, it is unsat to me that i am getting this charge into my arm. It's hard for me to fathom this is a normal operating condition for my laptop.
Not sure from your response if we understand what the other is trying to say...I do appreciate the responses either way.
- 0
Appleabcdefg ·
Imported from the Apple Support Forums via the Wayback Machine 🔗
I have the same with my 15' model. It sometimes happens when it's charging. I only use 230V.
What I sometimes do is connect the MBP to a USB-printer. That way, it is well grounded. But also to me, it's an annoying feeling. - 0
Eenu ·
Imported from the Apple Support Forums via the Wayback Machine 🔗
out of interest what battery lifetimes are the people who are being shocked getting?
Also what is the registered battery health for these people?
I experianced this shocking issue and i have found issues elsewhere.
- 0
carl wolf ·
Imported from the Apple Support Forums via the Wayback Machine 🔗
"With the laptop plugged into 2 prong outlet the case will build up a charge that when i rest my arms on to type on the keyboard, the thiner skin on the bottom of my arm feels like I am getting stabbed with needles, I am getting electrical discharge from the metal case. By unplugging the power cord from laptop it fades away immediately. Also, while it is sending a charge into my skin, I can rub my hand on sides of laptop or across the back of display and feel a vibration from the charge."
This is what you initially reported, and to what I initially responded. It's normal and, if you use a properly grounded 3-prong AC power cable, the sensation will disappear.
"The fact that this issue is not happening 24/7 is odd to me, let alone the fact it happens at all."
It occurs when the skin has a lower resistance, for example, when you're sweating, or after you take a shower. It is exactly the opposite of the conditions necessary for a static discharge.
"Regardless of the physics behind this issue, it is unsat to me that i am getting this charge into my arm. It's hard for me to fathom this is a normal operating condition for my laptop."
Well, is is, and it happens with ALL metal cased notebook computers, not just Apple. If you use a properly grounded 3-prong power cord, the problem will disappear.
Another poster asked about battery life, and it has nothing to do with the battery.
- 0
UltraNEO-__ ·
Imported from the Apple Support Forums via the Wayback Machine 🔗
"No, genius, because it's 6VDC, not 120VAC."
Trust me... Cars don't use six volt battery, nor does it matter if it's AC or DC (DC is actually more deadly)
I think your confusing it with a moped!Anyway, even a six volt battery can give you a shock of the lifetime if there's enough current there.
- 0
carl wolf ·
Imported from the Apple Support Forums via the Wayback Machine 🔗
"Trust me... Cars don't use six volt battery, nor does it matter if it's AC or DC (DC is actually more deadly)
I think your confusing it with a moped!"You are about as sharp as the edge of town. I was referring to HALF of hte voltage. So, half of 12 is 6. One-half of 240 is 120. With the same current, AC is more destructive. Please find a forum that you understand.
- 0
Trevor Ward ·
Imported from the Apple Support Forums via the Wayback Machine 🔗
I must say that I too am experiencing this. And unless you've experience it, you won't say that it's NORMAL. If this is normal, then it's a design flaw. It is quite painful. I type with my wrists in the air. I don't know if it's exactly a safety issue, but it's very uncomfortable and have a hard time understanding why apple would design it such. i think they just didn't test it in other countries that use different voltages. don't give me the 2-prong piece if the 2 prong piece causes me a lot of discomfort.
Try finding a US 3-prong adapter to an India 3-prong adapter. Not exactly something you can buy anywhere.
- 0
gwag ·
Imported from the Apple Support Forums via the Wayback Machine 🔗
2 things
try the cord that came with your mac that has 3 pins and is grounded.
get a 3$ outlet tester from a hard warestor and test your outlets.macbookpro Mac OS X (10.4.8)