Benches Mac desktops

9

Christmas present Mac mini - keep or retu…

apple Verified

Imported from the Apple Support Forums via the Wayback Machine 🔗

Hi all - I was hoping for some advice about a Christmas present I received. My wife got me one of the new Mac Minis (3ghz i5, 8 Gb ram, 1Tb SSD) to use in our office. I already have a MBP bought in early 2017 (2.9 ghz i7, 16 GB ram, 1Tb SSD, Intel HD 530 graphics with Radeon Pro 460 4096 mb in addition). The purpose is that Ive been using my MBP for gaming on the couch and then upstairs in an office at a desk connected to a monitor, keyboard, mouse etc when needing to do work related things. I’m a doctor so work related things means spreadsheets, powerpoint, accessing patient charts (so word processing via an internet connected program, looking at radiology images etc). I also take call, which means I have to wake up randomly throughout the night and use my computer to do all of the above, hopefully in as fast a method as possible to get back to sleep. So far this means finding my MBP, collecting it and unplugging the adaptor, and getting it all set up to my monitor every night before bed. This process is a bit of a hassle which is why she bought this for me.

My question now is whether I should return it (while it is expensive she’s obviously said it’s affordable for us and what she says goes I guess haha). The monitor I have is only 1080p 27inches - size is enough but for some reason the display looks super grainy and the color is all off (probably because I’m used to the MBP display). So a replacement for the Mini would be a better monitor (4K, probably less than $400; current monitor has speakers built in so would probably need to buy those as well). I could also maybe return this Mini and replace it for the one with only 500gb SSD, but I’m already using about that much on my MBP so would probably need an external drive.

Gaming on a desktop would be nice but I know the mini will never really be able to do that, and I already never take my MBP up the the office to game with it using my monitor.

I would probably also connect our already purchased external HDs (for MBP backups) to the Mac Mini so I can get the MBP to to stop reminding me it’s been >200 days since my last backup haha.

I guess the real point of this question is to help me understand how a Mac Mini will be beneficial to me other than the convenience of not having to set up my MBP on my desk every day, which seems an expensive way to be lazy.

9 replies

Sign in or join Beachball Help to reply.

  1. 0

    VikingOSX

    Imported from the Apple Support Forums via the Wayback Machine 🔗

    You have 14 days (U.S.) from purchase date to return the mini for a full refund, if that is your final decision.

    After Mojave consumes around 4GB of your Mac mini RAM, you will have to make do with the balance. I believe this is sufficient for "office" usage, but not gaming. Also, I am wondering outloud if you can view radiology images in the remaining 4GB RAM (provided other applications are not running), and whether that Intel Integrated GPU can reproduce them with the accuracy, or performance that you are accustomed to on your MacBook Pro.

    The RAM in the 2018 Mac mini is user upgradeable, but not for most, as one has to completely remove the motherboard to get at the RAM slots. The local Apple Store can give you a quote on a RAM upgrade to 16 GB, or more. As a doctor, I was thinking of the best use of your time…

  2. 0

    Ted Park

    Imported from the Apple Support Forums via the Wayback Machine 🔗

    It will save you from having to set up your MBP on your desk every day.

    It's also another computer, so if your MBP is out of commission for whatever reason, you'll have it to fall back on (or if you decide to keep it, I guess it would be the other way around, but you get the idea)

    I think you already realize the MBP outperforms the mini in almost every situation, so I guess it's really a judgement call based on the merits of having a dedicated desktop machine for your office/work, and using your laptop for everything else.

    IMHO, I don't think it's a bad investment, not just for the hassle it saves you to set up your laptop for work every day, but all the more because of the fact that it's another machine. (I'm not sure how dependent your work is on your MBP, but my father is a physician, and I remember an occasion his whole practice all but shut down for half a day because a central computer malfunctioned or shut down or some other)

  3. 0

    VikingOSX

    Imported from the Apple Support Forums via the Wayback Machine 🔗

    You have 14 days (U.S.) from purchase date to return the mini for a full refund, if that is your final decision.

    After Mojave consumes around 4GB of your Mac mini RAM, you will have to make do with the balance. I believe this is sufficient for "office" usage, but not gaming. Also, I am wondering outloud if you can view radiology images in the remaining 4GB RAM (provided other applications are not running), and whether that Intel Integrated GPU can reproduce them with the accuracy, or performance that you are accustomed to on your MacBook Pro.

    The RAM in the 2018 Mac mini is user upgradeable, but not for most, as one has to completely remove the motherboard to get at the RAM slots. The local Apple Store can give you a quote on a RAM upgrade to 16 GB, or more. As a doctor, I was thinking of the best use of your time…

  4. 0

    AndrewG7862

    Imported from the Apple Support Forums via the Wayback Machine 🔗

    The images are less important, no more different than loading a picture from the internet. The bottleneck in experience usually tends to be the internet connection, as you scroll through something like a CT scan so quickly loading the next image changes the experience. This is an issue with the MBP already which I take the be a reflection of the hospital’s ability to push the data, and not my computer. Maybe it would be a bit faster with Ethernet as opposed to WI-FI, which is maybe a win for Mac mini.

    It is is true that being down a computer can be a major hassle - really that means I would have to stay at work until all the work is done (so leaving at 8 or 9 instead of 5 or 6) and having to rely entirely on what the other person on the phone is telling me at 2AM to understand their question (I’m a visual person, so that scenario leads to being awake longer).

    My wife has the same MBP as me, so I could always use hers if mine crashed but because of the sensitive nature of material you have to install a lot of security features and programs to deal with the patient data, and that set up process takes hours. In truth this is the reason I started using my MBP on my desk with a keyboard, because it has had a few broken keys as for at least a year (the one that model is known for). I’ve been avoiding taking it in for repairs simply because of this downtime.

    I actually really enjoy enjoy tinkering with computers so upgrading the ram myself would be something I would look forward to - as long as I don’t have to like solder anything. Plus the frugal side of me always notices that Apple markup on ram. That’s probably the source of this whole thread - not feeling comfortable with spending money even though it was a present

  5. 0

    hcsitas

    Imported from the Apple Support Forums via the Wayback Machine 🔗

    For me, it’s a keeper. An absolutely gorgeous machine inside and out! Having said that, your monitor issues are solvable either by swapping it for a 27 iMac or purchasing an HDMI 2.0 monitor or an LG Ultrafine 4K monitor or awaiting an Apple standalone monitor, expected 2019. Enjoy!

  6. 0

    VikingOSX

    Imported from the Apple Support Forums via the Wayback Machine 🔗

    Apple's order upgrade for the 16GB RAM is $200. OWC offers the either a single 8GB upgrade for $87.89, or 16 GB RAM upgrade for $164.68 for a final 16GB or 24GB RAM solution. Add to this, the specialty tools to access the different Torx screws that Apple uses. I personally have ordered RAM from OWC for my own Macs, and remain satisfied with their quality of service.

    The first paragraph may remain moot depending on how you find the 2018 Mac mini memory installation process.

  7. 0

    lllaass

    Imported from the Apple Support Forums via the Wayback Machine 🔗

    You said "OWC offers the either a single 8GB upgrade for $87.89, or 16 GB RAM upgrade for $164.68 for a final 16GB or 24GB RAM solution."

    To my knowledge the base 8 GB mini comes with 2x4 GB installed.

    The OWC $87.89 is for 1x8 GB which gets you max of 12 GB (4+8)

    and the $164.88 is for 2x8GB which gets you 16 GB

    OWC sells a 1x16 GB for $159.99 so you can replace on 4 GB with the 16 and get 20 GB.

    Note if both modules are not the same memory access is not as fast since match pairs uses dual memory access.

  8. 0

    Ted Park

    Imported from the Apple Support Forums via the Wayback Machine 🔗

    I take it you're leaning towards keeping it then? :D

    Re: the slow loading of images, I'm surprised network connection is being a bottleneck, unless you're accessing them remotely through a tunnel or other slow connection? I had thought compositing the scan data into actual pictures you can look at is done on the imaging system itself, so at the viewing end, it ends up as maybe a few dozen megabytes at the most...

    At any rate, with the kinds of radio used today, I wouldn't expect throughput to be the issue with wired vs wireless. Latency and stability of the link maybe, but not "mb/s" speed.

    Since memory was being discussed, I thought of something I forgot to mention: on the mini, you share your main memory with the integrated graphics, while the amd chip in your MBP has dedicated graphics memory in addition to the 16GB system dram, so the available system memory would be less depending on the graphics load. (This is included in the big chunk of memory used by the os, you can check the dynamic maximum it can use in "About this Mac" under the Apple menu).

    So... yeah. an upgrade in the near-ish future is definitely something to consider.

    I didn't know 8GB was the base config for the new Mac mini, I guess it's some relief they're not soldered on this time around.

  9. 0

    VikingOSX

    Imported from the Apple Support Forums via the Wayback Machine 🔗

    If it comes with 2x4, then you are correct, and I was incorrect. Overlooked the single 1x16 option too. Distracted driver here. Thanks.