Benches Mac desktops

2

Mac Pro 3,1 (Early 2008) PCIe x16 2.5GT/s…

apple Verified

Imported from the Apple Support Forums via the Wayback Machine 🔗

Forgive me if this is addressed elsewhere, but I haven't been able to find any other threads with my specific query.

I have a Mac Pro 3,1 (Early 2008) running macOS High Sierra (dosdude1 patched), the one with two PCIe 2.0 x16 slots (the double-width Slot 1, occupied by graphics card, and the single-width Slot 2) and two PCIe 1.0 x4 slots (Slot 3 & Slot 4).

I recently purchased a 256GB AHCI Samsung SM951 (PCIe 3.0 x4) connected it to a Sintech M.2(NGFF) M Key PCI-e SSD to PCIe X4 Adapter Card, and dropped it into Slot 2. Due to a quirk with these Mac Pro motherboards (3,1 - 5,1), when a PCIe 3.0 x4 SSD (like the SM951) is connected to the x16 slot, it defaults to PCIe 1.0 link speed (2.5GT/s), instead of the PCIe 2.0 (5GT/s) link speed of which it is capable. Mac Pro 4,1 and 5,1 owners can just use the x4 Slot 3 or Slot 4, which lets their PCIe 3.0 SM951s operate at PCIe 2.0 speeds (5GT/s), but the x4 Slot 3 and Slot 4 in the 3,1 is already only PCIe 1.0, and therefore limited to the 2.5GT/s link speed.

Now, I haven't tried an official Apple version of the SM951 (the PCIe 3.0 x4 "SSUBX" SSDs with the proprietary 12+16 Pin connector), but I suspect that my results would be the same, since it's essentially the same drive as the one I tried, just with a different connector? Or would the custom Apple firmware somehow allow the 3,1 to negotiate PCIe 2.0 link speed in the x16 slot with the PCIe 3.0 drive?

tl;dr: Has anyone tried an Apple OEM SSUBX (PCIe 3.0 x4) SSD in the PCIe 2.0 x16 Slot 2 of a Mac Pro 3,1 (Early 2008)? Does it negotiate PCIe 2.0 link speed (5GT/s) or does it behave like a non-Apple AHCI SM951 and default to PCIe 1.0 (2.5GT/s) in the x16 slot?

Before I tried the SM951, I'd been using a 256GB Apple OEM SSUAX (PCIe 2.0 x2) drive in Slot 2, and getting 5GT/s link speed for a practical sequential read/write benchmark of 940MB/s read & 785MB/s write. The experience is pretty great, with boot times under 15 seconds and really snappy load times in macOS High Sierra. I'm happy with it, for now...but ultimately, my intent is to find the practical speed limit for a boot drive on this machine.

So far, it appears that the only faster options are:

  1. 512GB Samsung XP941 (PCIe 2.0 x4): Sequential Read: 1170MB/s, Write: 930 MB/s, though this test posts much slower speeds (~$330 on eBay): https://www.anandtech.com/show/8006/samsung-ssd-xp941-review-the-pcie-era-is-here/7
  2. 1TB Apple OEM SSUAX (PCIe 2.0 x4): Sequential Read/Write: ~1200MB/s. As far as I can tell, this appears to be the only PCIe 2.0 x4 that Apple has ever offered. (~$400-$700 on eBay/Beetstech/Amazon)
  3. Amfeltech Squid: This company offers PCIe adapter cards with mounts for either two or four M.2 SSDs, using x16 or x8 PCIe connectors. They are reportedly able to negotiate PCIe 2.0 speeds even with PCIe 3.0 drives in the 3,1's x16 slot 2. When striping up to 4 SM951's they've reached pretty insane speeds. They are also quite expensive; the Gen 2 model that fits four M.2 SSD blades has been quoted at nearly $300. I'm awaiting a quote for the Gen 3 model that fits two M.2 SSD blades. http://amfeltec.com/squid-pci-express-carrier-boards-for-m-2-ssd-modules/?view=list

tl;dr: Are there any faster solutions than the options listed above for a boot drive in a Mac Pro 3,1 (Early 2008)?

If you're still here, thanks for bearing with me!

2 replies

Sign in or join Beachball Help to reply.

  1. 0

    DonH49

    Imported from the Apple Support Forums via the Wayback Machine 🔗

    I'm still here. Nice writeup but unfortunately I gave up on the older technology a few years back. I use to have the early 2008 Mac Pro and I ran 6 internal drives with an internal blu ray optical, three SSD and three platter drives. I do use a Samsung 970 NVMe with the Sintech adaptor or my 2013 Mac Pro. I'm stuck at PVl 2 not 3 and Gt/sec =5 not 8. Both these make world of difference in speed. Although I've learned to accept what I have currently because its better than what I had when I first bought this machine. The only thing I can say about this stuff is its much better NVMe wise on a Mac 2015 or later if the hardware can be addressed.

    I can't really help because I don't have the hardware but when I did swap out the SSD in a late 2013 rMBPro with the 2013 Mac Pro SSD the 4 lane default SSD from the Mac Pro only showed 2 lane in the late 2013 MBPro. AND...the SSD from the late 2013 MBPro showed only two lane in the 2013 Mac Pro. BUT....when I swapped out both of these SSD with a Samsung NVMe 970 in either machine it was 4 lane and trim=YES. That was nice. But...the write & Read speed was capped off as Gt/sec =5 and PCl=2 and when I swapped in that Samsung in my mid 2015 MBPro then it showed 4 lane, Trim=YES and Gt/sec =8 and write speed went from 1224 to 2508 and read speed 1438 to 3119. A shame that little 2015 MBPro crushed the 8 core 2013 Mac Pro but that's the way it is...I still have 8 core to over ride so that's worth something to keep hold of...good luck

  2. 0

    PoRican

    Imported from the Apple Support Forums via the Wayback Machine 🔗

    Thanks for reading (and the reply)!

    Here's a resource that might help when sorting out the various quirks of Apple SSDs and the machines that run them: https://beetstech.com/blog/apple-proprietary-ssd-ultimate-guide-to-specs-and-upgrades

    I'm still researching so I'll post my findings here in case it might help someone else still holding onto a vintage 3,1. I got mine for $75 in 2015 and despite some annoying quirks, I've been able to keep up with pretty much all of my multimedia needs with some key upgrades. My current setup boots macOS High Sierra from a 256GB Apple SSUAX SSD (the Samsung XP941 with a proprietary connector & firmware), with my home folder on a 2x2TB RAID 0 array in SATA bay 2 & 3. The RAID 0 array is cloned nightly to a 4TB HDD in bay 4, and the entire system is backed up via Time Machine to an 8TB HDD that shares the optical bay with a Blu-Ray burner (both the 8TB & burner are connected to the two ODD SATA ports on the mobo).

    Here's what I've learned since my original post:

    In order to trick the 3,1 into letting me use a PCIe 3.0 x4 SSD at PCIe 2.0 link width (5GT/s) in my x16 Slot 2, I need to use a PCI switch, which essentially uses some trickeration to spread the PCIe 3.0 x4 bandwidth over x8 or x16 PCIe 2.0 lanes. These are not cheap. Popular Mac Pro-compatible PCIe adapter cards with PCI switches include the 4-bay Amfeltec Squid Gen 2 ($385.57), the 4-bay High Point SSD710-A ($398.60), and the 2-bay I/O CREST SI-PEX40129 (~$200, depending on retailer). As far as I can tell, you can't boot into macOS or OS X from the Amfeltec Squid, the High Point card is the only one with an onboard hardware RAID controller, and the I/O Crest uses a different PCI switch than the other two, which is limited to about half the bandwidth. That said, the total bandwidth on these cards borders on the insane: 3000MB/s for the I/O Crest and 6000MB/s for the other two. If you have High Sierra or above, you can use NVMe SSDs in any of them.

    I saw someone post on a MacRumors forum thread about a "pcitool" that allows you to force the x16 Slot 2 to run at PCIe 2.0 link width (5GT/s); I've posted a query for more info but haven't heard back yet. If such a magical piece of software exists, I might be able to make full use of x4 lanes of PCIe 2.0 speeds in Slot 2 without buying an expensive PCI switcher...at least for now. Now that I know my almost 11-year old Mac Pro can potentially have a boot drive with sequential read/write speeds of 6000MB/s, it's only a matter of time before I make that move.

    For more info on the fastest SSD blade setups in classic Mac Pros (2008-2012), check this highly informative thread on MacRumors: https://forums.macrumors.com/threads/blade-ssds-nvme-ahci.2146725/

    Long live the Mac Pro 3,1.