APPLE FIX THIS! Aluminum Keyboard + Mac Mini = DYSFUNCTIONAL
apple Verified ·
Imported from the Apple Support Forums via the Wayback Machine 🔗
I have a Mac Mini 1,1 (1.6ghz CD) and found out the hard way that the EFI firmware DOES NOT support the new Apple aluminum keyboard properly during post startup. You simply cannot use ANY startup modifier keys (cmd-c, option, a-o-p-r etc.) because the EFI firmware doesn't recognize the keyboard until the OS driver loads.
I found this out with a bunk boot camp install which left me with the famous 'no bootable device --' error and was unable use the option key to get to the boot selection screen to return to Mac OS. I called Apple and they were clueless and suggested I take the computer in for service.
After about 50 restarts, and 2 other (and newer) aluminum keyboards, I though i'd try a PC USB keyboard for fun.. and long behold the bloody thing worked and I was able to restart and access the boot screen etc.
I eventually found some mention of this on google where people who also have this problem are recommended to restart the computer while holding the remote's MENU button to get to the boot selection screen.
My question is WHY HAS APPLE NOT PATCHED THE MINI OR AI KEYBOARD'S FIRMWARE TO FIX THIS PROBLEM?
I'm also willing to be most people who buy a Mac Mini probably also pick up the Aluminum keyboard which means there are newbies and long time users who probably don't even know their computers or keyboards are gimped until it's too late.
15 replies
Sign in or join Beachball Help to reply.
- 0
AndyO ·
Imported from the Apple Support Forums via the Wayback Machine 🔗
There's no real point in posting this here, despite the obvious and understandable frustration. It's been raised many, many times, and discussed until everyone is blue in the face, but Apple themselves don't monitor these discussions so your request is falling on deaf ears.
The suggestion to use almost any other wired USB keyboard is the traditional advice given here by other users for owners of aluminium keyboards who need to modify the booting of a Mac mini.
In terms of Apple fixing it - I suspect the fact this has been a widely reported problem for some months now and Apple have not moved to provide an update which enables this functionality either means they can't, or don't intend to. They have certainly had every opportunity to respond to the evident demand and resolve it. However, since no-one here can speak for Apple, or is in a position to discuss their plans, it's not possible to tell you if or when this may be fixed.
- 0
DaddyPaycheck ·
Imported from the Apple Support Forums via the Wayback Machine 🔗
There is a firmware update available this morning for the keyboard.
Maybe the problem has been mitigated.
Luck-
-DaddyPaycheck
- 0
AndyO ·
Imported from the Apple Support Forums via the Wayback Machine 🔗
Sorry Daddy, didn't see your reply!
Sadly I don't see any report of the update resolving the lack of recognition of the keyboard in time to be used for boot control on a mini. I may be wrong (it would hardly be a first!) but since the problem seems to be that the mini doesn't see the keyboard until after it has passed the point at which the boot process can be modified, I suspect an update would have to be made to the mini's firmware rather than the keyboard.
- 0
DaddyPaycheck ·
Imported from the Apple Support Forums via the Wayback Machine 🔗
Well that certainly makes sense and I would have to agree. I suffered this morning from did-not-comprehend-entire-post disease.
-DaddyPaycheck
- 0
Steven Garner ·
Imported from the Apple Support Forums via the Wayback Machine 🔗
Just applied the "Aluminum Keyboard Firmware Update 1.0" (to keyboard product ID 0x0220, Version: 0.69), and the Option key still has no effect at boot time.
- 0
OzMikeH ·
Imported from the Apple Support Forums via the Wayback Machine 🔗
I just loaded the keyboard patch on my 1.7G mac mini and bluetooth has died. I have the ali keyboard and supermouse thingy.
I plugged a USB mouse in and it didnt work, no lights, so I gave the mac mini a hard reset with the USB mouse plugged in. I can select my account to log in but it still doesn't recognise bluetooth devices so I CANT TYPE MY PASSWORD IN!
no worries, I'll just get my old PC keyboard. guess what - no PS2 socket!
now I have to go buy a **ing keyboard just because I updated the firmware.I'm extremely irritated with this thing.
Edit: I find myself imagining the feeling of throwing this thing across the street. This event and the fact it doesn't self start USB devices without a cold boot (such as my mouse and USB hard disk) is too much. I thought macs were supposed to be easy. Now I understand why the really big macs have those big handles on the corners.
Message was edited by: OzMikeH
- 0
AndyO ·
Imported from the Apple Support Forums via the Wayback Machine 🔗
OK, I'll bite!
Firstly, welcome to Apple Discussions.
Secondly:
no PS2 socket!
Which is hardly a surprise really, since PS2 keyboards have been a dead dog ever since USB arrived, and it would be a difficult proposition to find any new system that had a connector for either PS2 keyboard or mouse these days. There are some legacy technologies which are worth continuing to support, but that isn't one of them.
Thirdly:
now I have to go buy a **ing keyboard just because I updated the firmware.
I suspect there's more to it than that. Having updated firmware on a series of systems, and monitored reports from lots of users, your problem is not at all common, and therefore suggests there may have been a problem existing on your system prior to the firmware update which the update merely served to trigger. If so, then you would likely have faced the problem sooner or later.
It isn't clear from your description exactly what is happening with your system. You report hat you connected a USB mouse but it didn't appear to work, but subsequent to that it isn't clear what you mean by a 'hard reset' or whether the mouse worked after that. Obviously with a dead keyboard (presumably bluetooth, though you don't say) you can't log in, but if the USB mouse now works, then there is reason to expect a USB keyboard will get you into the system and then allow a little more troubleshooting and problem solving.
What
is clear is your frustration at the system and the USB issues you have had with it, though you don't really explain what those issues are either. However, given that many people have Macs that wake up from sleep and have functional USB mice and external drives (which is what I assume you mean yours does not) then there's clearly something wrong with your system - or the components you have connected to it.It would help to know what you do have connected to the mini, and whether you have USB hubs etc also. Many wake from sleep issues are the result of devices which are not entirely standards compliant, drawn too much current, or hubs which for one reason or another are not fully compatible. Of course they can also be because the computer is faulty!
Have you always had these problems with this system? If so, I can understand the frustration. If not, at what point did these issues start, and what was the last item before that which you added to the system?
Troubleshooting USB issues is often down to disconnecting everything and then trying one component at a time until you discover the one that seems to generate issues. Before you start that however, it would be a good idea to perform reset on your system - you describe it as a 1.7G model, though the nearest actual product to that is a 1.66GHz Intel Core Duo. If that's it, then what you need is an SMC reset (the SMC is he system management controller which looks after the functioning of ports etc). To reset it:
-From the Apple menu, choose Shut Down (or if the computer is not responding, hold the power button until it turns off).
-Unplug all cables from the computer, including the power cord and any display cables.
-Wait at least 15 seconds.
-Plug the power cord back in, *making sure the power button is not being pressed* at the time.
-Then reconnect your keyboard and mouse to the computer.
-Press the power button on the back to start up your computer.Following that, test USB components one by one and see if you can pin-point the culprit that way.
- 0
OzMikeH ·
Imported from the Apple Support Forums via the Wayback Machine 🔗
ok, thanks for offering to help. I apologise for my earlier rant.
First the minor things out of the way, I bought the mac mini as a media centre, in particular high quality music. My monitor is a plasma tv, I have a 250GB Buffalo external USB hard disk, the kind that has it's own power supply for 12V and 5V. It has a USB2 interface and it can be set to be on all of the time or power up when it detects 5V on the USB cable. The only way I can use this disk is to force it to be on all of the time and power up the (1.8GHZ dual core) mac mini. then I can see the disk. The disk is in Windows format and is full of music in .WAV format. If I plug the disk in after the Mac is switched on the mac does not notice it. It's a minor issue and I think we can forget about the hard disk for now.
The other USB device is an Edirol UA-1EX sound card. currently running at 16 bit 44.1kHz.
The way I use the machine I only use the apple bluetooth mouse and keyboard.
I'll step through it..
1: I install about 10 updates, one of which is the keyboard update.
2: mac mini restarts.
3: I perform the keyboard update procedure.
4: mac mini restarts.
5: bluetooth mouse does not work, I cannot select my account.
6: I get a "microsoft comfort optical mouse 3000" from my old PC.
7: I plug the mouse into the mac, the red light under the mouse does not come on.
8: I press and hold the power switch on the mac mini to make it turn off.
9: I turn the mac on, the microsoft mouse works.
10: I click on my account, aluminium keyboard does not work.
11: press and hold power switch, remove power cord. wait 30 seconds and repeat steps 9 and 10
12: play with power switch on keyboard, power LED does a double flash.
13: Get laptop PC, search for help, find my way here and <rant> <rant>.
14: borrow a USB keyboard, Login, get into system preferences and the mac thinks it doesn't even a HAVE bluetooth adapter. I was intending to re-associate the bluetooth Keyb and mouse,conclusion: something in the software update has stopped the bluetooth network device from working.
originally the only 2 usb devices I connected were the sound card and the hard disk. hard disk is disconnected at the moment.
hard reset = press and hold power switch, also note at one time I pulled the power cord out and left it for a while.I really want bluetooth working first, sitting on the floor craning my neck to write this is somewhat uncomfortable. next I'll pull out all USB devices and see what happens.
- 0
OzMikeH ·
Imported from the Apple Support Forums via the Wayback Machine 🔗
1: start with nothing, bluetooth works.
2: start with sound card: bluetooth still works.
3: start with hard disk, bluetooth does not work, and yes, bluetooth did not work without the hard disk in my previous post.I've been feeding it CDs for weeks ripping my collection, The only thing that has changed is the last pack of software updates.
I guess I'll have to plug this hard disk into one of my PCs and copy the contents onto my Lacie hard disk (which has a fault - it never switches itself off when the PC does)
I remember I did have something else strange happen, sometimes when I load a CD the drive fails to recognise there is a disk in it. If I restart or use the disk utility to eject it and reload it it does recognise the cd.
The whole reason I went with the USB hard disk is because my unix based NAS box would not work with Itunes, I couldnt create a library file on the network drive. The NAS box is at the other end of the house connected to my switch, I run the mac on 802.11G
I'll wander off now and see if I can get Itunes working with the NAS box in an appropriate forum.
Message was edited by: OzMikeH
- 0
AndyO ·
Imported from the Apple Support Forums via the Wayback Machine 🔗
I can see the logic of your conclusion that something in the keyboard update (or indeed, other updates) killed BT on your mini, but I've got 5 Intel minis in my local network here and applied all the current updates to each one (including the keyboard update to two) and none suffered a similar BT outage.
That tells us that even though the application of one or more update may have triggered the failure in your system, the update itself can't be the problem or it would similarly impact everyone. It therefore points to something that was not correctly functioning in your system previous to the updates, or which the update procedure as you applied it caused to go faulty.
The pre-existing issue with unregognised CDs is likely not a symptom of that problem, though if there's an issue with the SMC, it could be.
Has behaviour changed at all after the SMC reset?
I doubt the Buffalo drive is responsible in itself - a number of Mac users have these and there are few unfavourable reports - but in combination with the sound card it could be. Sadly I'm not familiar with that device and any possible issues with it, but changing the experimental order to boot with the hard drive but no sound card might help pin-point the problem.
I must say that in a general sense I have never found USB to be particularly tolerant on Mac or PC systems, and avoid it where possible, favouring firewire where there is any choice. Obviously that's no help in this situation however!
- 0
OzMikeH ·
Imported from the Apple Support Forums via the Wayback Machine 🔗
I'm not sure what you mean by SMC.
Edirol is a part of Roland. They produce very good equipment normally and offer good support for the Mac platform.I'd prefer not to use the buffalo drive at all. I'd like to have my Itunes library on my western digital NAS drive.
Thanks for your assistance Andy, I'm off to search for how to use a mac mini with the WD Mybook world raid NAS.
- 0
Boece ·
Imported from the Apple Support Forums via the Wayback Machine 🔗
Andy described the SMC reset above; it is used on Intel-based Macs:
"SMC reset (the SMC is the system management controller which looks after the functioning of ports etc). To reset it:
-From the Apple menu, choose Shut Down (or if the computer is not responding, hold the power button until it turns off).
-Unplug all cables from the computer, including the power cord and any display cables.
-Wait at least 15 seconds.
-Plug the power cord back in, making sure the power button is not being pressed at the time.
-Then reconnect your keyboard and mouse to the computer.
-Press the power button on the back to start up your computer." - 0
sellmo88 ·
Imported from the Apple Support Forums via the Wayback Machine 🔗
I am experiencing this same problem. I've spent a total of 3 hours on the phone with ATS. They've sent me 3 new aluminum keyboard in 4 days (I am not kidding). It took the one TSR 40 minutes to find the Product ID number for the keyboard (needless to say I wasn't too happy when she got back on the line).
I have a 1.83mhz, Dual Core (late 2006 release).
If Apple spent half as much time on fixing or writing patch as they have on FedEx and DHL (remember, 3 keyboards have arrived at my house in 4 days), they would have this deal done. I'm curious, does anyone know if this issue is only on older Minis?
I'm going to the Apple store to "reboot" a few of their machines to see if they are experiencing the same issue.
- 0
AndyO ·
Imported from the Apple Support Forums via the Wayback Machine 🔗
I'm curious, does anyone know if this issue is only on older Minis?
In my experience, no mini, whether original G4 or latest C2D is capable of reading the aluminium keyboard in time for the modifier keys to be used.
- 0
sellmo88 ·
Imported from the Apple Support Forums via the Wayback Machine 🔗
AndyO,
Thanks for that clarification. ALL!!! PLEASE READ ON.....I received a call (yes, they called me) from a product specialist at Apple today. This guy did some digging, and the "Aluminum Keyboard Boot Issue" is officially on Apple's radar, and their support developers are working on a "software update and/or article". They officially recognized the issue in February according to Carl, the product specialist.So, all hope does not appear to be lost. Maybe a little more patience and us Mini users will have full use of our beloved aluminum keyboards.
Great discussion everyone.
ScottE