Benches Mac desktops

15

Kernel panics whenever RAID card conditio…

apple Verified

Imported from the Apple Support Forums via the Wayback Machine 🔗

I have an early 2008 Mac Pro running 10.5.8, with an Apple RAID card with M-2.0.5.5 firmware. This has two Seagate Barracuda drives attached, formatted as RAID 0, and this RAID 0 is the OS drive.

Periodically, the RAID card conditions the battery. In the past I've been able to work while this was happening but, about three weeks ago, the conditioning started and the computer became completely unusable: there were kernel panics every minute or two and, on restarting, the report showed "AppleRAIDCard Controller Panic...". I eventually gave up and left it alone until the conditioning finished, and it's worked fine since.

This situation has just started again. It's only three weeks since the last conditioning; the gap was 6 weeks last time; and 12 weeks the time before that. Is the battery failing? Does that explain the constant AppleRAIDCard Controller-initiated kernel panics?

I didn't set up this computer and could happily live without RAID but this OS drive now has lots of software installed, much of which needed to be authorised by challenges/responses and explanations to software manufacturers as to why it was being reinstalled etc. Reformatting and reinstalling everything again would be a major PITA.

Is it possible to move the drives to a software RAID 0 without reformatting them? Is this likely to be less problematic than the Apple RAID card?

Thanks in advance,

Steve = : ^ )

15 replies

Sign in or join Beachball Help to reply.

  1. 0

    japamac

    Imported from the Apple Support Forums via the Wayback Machine 🔗

    Hi-

    If it were a RAID 1, you would be golden.

    A RAID 0 won't allow the set to be broken without reformat.

    One could install a third drive and clone the startup volume to the new drive.

    Use SuperDuper! to get a bootable clone.

    This should alleviate any problems with your software authorizations, and give you a single drive that contains your current working environment.

    Beyond this, I would inquire with Apple as to the repair/replacement of the Apple RAID card.

    You paid a premium for this device, and you should problem free service from it.

    A new battery may be all that is required.

  2. 0

    Community User

    Imported from the Apple Support Forums via the Wayback Machine 🔗

    Thanks. Everything you say is right. I'd just like someone to comment on whether they think the battery alone could be responsible for unending KPs whenever the controller is conditioning the battery, or whether the card might be faulty.

    Thanks again,

    Steve = : ^ )

  3. 0

    japamac

    Imported from the Apple Support Forums via the Wayback Machine 🔗

    I'd just like someone to comment on whether they think the battery alone could be responsible for unending KPs whenever the controller is conditioning the battery, or whether the card might be faulty.

    I wonder about both points.

    Did some searching, and there are several reports of other users with battery problems.

    For some, the battery fixed the problem, for others, no remedy.

    One example:

    http://forums.macrumors.com/showthread.php?t=439873

    For troubleshooting, identifying the source through eliminating causes related to the symptoms would be a reasonable approach.

    Since the KP's occur only during battery conditioning, it places the most suspicion on the battery.

    Personally, I see this as most telling.

    Since you can't run without the battery, a replacement is the only way that I can think of to test the battery.

    Other possibilities could be firmware related.

    Is the card and the MP running the most current firmware?

    If the firmware of the card and the MP are up to date, the battery, again, comes to the top of the suspect list.

    And, of course, there is always the possibility that a component on card has failed.

    Unfortunately, as with the battery, a replacement is needed to test.

    I wouldn't move on this point until the battery theory were tested.

    Not to dismiss the potential for software involvement, I'm wondering what are the OS X kexts that are involved with the processes leading to the KP's?

    Logs in Console may provide some information.

    Portions of the KP report immediately after the word "backtrace" also provide the best information.

  4. 0

    Community User

    Imported from the Apple Support Forums via the Wayback Machine 🔗

    Thanks. Yes the firmware is up to date and, as you point out, the obvious way to proceed is in replacing the battery.

    Except that I'm considering the other response, and looking at temporarily installing another drive and cloning the RAID to it, then back to one of the the currently-RAIDed drives with the card removed. I'd then use the second drive for a SuperDuper clone. This seems a better use of the drives than the current RAID) for the OS drive.

    The Mac Pro was actually a refurb and was advertised with the standard configuration; the RAID card was a bonus (we thought!) and so were the two Seagate Barracadu 15000 rpm drives, in place of one 7500 rpm drive. (It was also advertised a 2.8 gHz but it's 3.2.)

    Thanks again,

    Steve = : ^ )

  5. 0

    japamac

    Imported from the Apple Support Forums via the Wayback Machine 🔗

    This seems a better use of the drives than the current RAID) for the OS drive

    RAID can be fast, and have it's uses, but I tend to agree that a better use for the drives can be found.

    RAID 0 is a fragile thing, and without a backup, there is too much insecurity.

    A RAID 5 or 6 would be a much safer bet.

    Then again, not everyone needs a RAID.....

    And, to further the case against the installed RAID card, it seems that there are simply more efficient, better performing alternatives for those who require a hardware RAID.

    The card is much maligned.....

  6. 0

    Community User

    Imported from the Apple Support Forums via the Wayback Machine 🔗

    Thanks again. Assuming the box works okay after the battery conditioning finishes, I'll leave it till next weekend and implement the strategy that doesn't use the card.

    Steve = : ^ )

  7. 0

    The hatter

    Imported from the Apple Support Forums via the Wayback Machine 🔗

    Seagate 15K drives are known as Cheetahs, and a really nice loud but fast server drive, though 10K WD VelociRaptors or SSDs are nice, cheap, quieter - and don't require Apple RAID card (needed to use SAS)

    http://www.seagate.com/www/en-us/products/servers/cheetah/

  8. 0

    Community User

    Imported from the Apple Support Forums via the Wayback Machine 🔗

    Thanks. Yes, my mistake, they're Cheetahs and I just learned that they're SAS and what that means and these drive actually
    require the RAID card, right? So I can't do what I was planning to do and use them without it. 😟

    Steve = : ^ )

  9. 0

    Community User

    Imported from the Apple Support Forums via the Wayback Machine 🔗

    The battery conditioning has finished, but I just had another kernel panic. When I rebooted I saved the report, and it shows "AppleRAIDCard Controller Panic etc...". If anyone who knows how to read one of these things wants to have a look it's here:

    files.me.com/steveball2/y7etaz

    Thanks in advance,

    Steve = : ^ )

  10. 0

    Community User

    Imported from the Apple Support Forums via the Wayback Machine 🔗

    And now, just to make sure I get no work done, the card has again started conditioning the battery, just 12 hours after finishing. The computer has just KPed twice while I wasn't even touching it.

    I need to get the RAID card battery replaced. I assume that pulling the card out is simple and I hope the geniuses at the Apple Store can replace it.

    Steve = : ^

  11. 0

    Community User

    Imported from the Apple Support Forums via the Wayback Machine 🔗

    But wait, there's more! I had to take the computer to an Apple Authorised repairer to get the RAID card battery replaced. This was a much bigger deal than it should have been because the courier hung onto the battery for two days before delivering it.

    I finally picked the computer up Friday. It's been running since Friday night and I just got another AppleRAIDCard Controller panic and the card's started conditioning the battery again! (It conditioned the battery when it was fitted on Thursday.)

    I guess this means the problem is with the RAID card and not the battery after all. Looks like another trip to the repairer this week. Oh, joy.

    Steve = : ^ )

  12. 0

    Community User

    Imported from the Apple Support Forums via the Wayback Machine 🔗

    I've now had the RAID card replaced and the computer is running smoothly, but it looks like I
    still have a problem. 😟 System profiler reports that the battery is not charging, is not conditioning, is not discharging and doesn't have sufficient charge. It reports "faulted battery" and it, along with RAID utility, reports that battery is precharging and can't be read. RAID utility also reports that the write cache is disabled due to insufficient battery charge. It's been this way since I turned the computer on 17 hours ago.

    Loos like a thirds trip to the repair shop o get another new battery. 😟 At least I can get my work done first.

    Steve = : ^ )

  13. 0

    japamac

    Imported from the Apple Support Forums via the Wayback Machine 🔗

    Good Grief!!!

    You are having a time of it, aren't you?

    One step forward, another back......

    Unfortunately for you, your experience with that card is mirrored by the web reports about it... not favorable. 😟

  14. 0

    Community User

    Imported from the Apple Support Forums via the Wayback Machine 🔗

    But wait, there's more! After the computer had been on (not sleeping) continuously for nearly two days, RAID utility popped up today to report that the card had started conditioning the battery. It took about 6 hours (which is about how long previous conditionings have taken) and now everything seems to be working normally.

    The repairer ordered a new battery when I called yesterday and explained the current state, and I think I'll still let them fit it when it arrives.

    As ever, I'll keep y'all posted...

    Steve = : ^ )

  15. 0

    japamac

    Imported from the Apple Support Forums via the Wayback Machine 🔗

    No panics?

    Sounds like you're just about home free! 🙂