Benches Mac desktops

8

Decisions, decisions, decisions...

apple Verified

Imported from the Apple Support Forums via the Wayback Machine 🔗

I am presently using a PB G4. I recently upgraded the memory to 2GB and I put a new 150 GB HD in a year ago. This will become my "upstairs" computer that I keep by my chair while watching TV (old iBook that I used for this purpose just died - think it is the motherboard).

I've had a laptop now for many about 10 years. I love the smaller footprint. I now only travel with it once a year when I go away in the summer for 4 weeks. My iPhone serves me well on shorter trips.

I'm considering buying an iMac, either the last 24" version or the new 20.5 version. I will buy it with the minimum RAM and upgrade it myself. I would also buy the 1TB HD, even though I have a new external HD (1TB). I'm still also considering a new MacBook. The reason I'm even considering an iMac is that the screen is so nice and big and my elderly eyes ain't getting any sharper. I also get a LOT more for my money.

I usually keep my computers 5-6 years. I do email, web browsing, play music, upload lots of photos of my grandchildren (minor editing) and that's pretty much it. I've had Macs now for nearly 20 years - started with the old all-in-one B&W ones. I'm pretty computer literate for an old lady.

I'm worried that I may not like having an iMac. I will keep it down my semi-finished basement on the table I use for a desk. It WILL take up more room, even there! Price does matter.

Will I really see pictures better on the iMac than on a MacBook? Will I hate it or love it? Do I want the old 24" (they're still around new and also some refurbs) or do I want the new 20.5?

Help!

8 replies

Sign in or join Beachball Help to reply.

  1. 0

    Apple Support Community member

    Imported from the Apple Support Forums via the Wayback Machine 🔗

    Thatchcote wrote:
    I'm considering buying an iMac, either the last 24" version or the new 21.5 version.
    Will I really see pictures better on the iMac than on a MacBook? Will I hate it or love it? Do I want the old 24" (they're still around new and also some refurbs) or do I want the new 21.5?

    1. You want the new 21.5-inch iMac and not the old 24-inch. The 21.5 uses LED backlighting which means a higher-quality image. More colors and no washout. In theory, a much longer life.

    2. If you can buy a 24-inch with at least 1 year of AppleCare remaining AND the price is less than $900, then you should consider the older machine. That means that the old machine would be about $450 less than a new one.

    3. If you don't need the 1TB capacity today or within the next year, I would not buy it. I would wait until you need it and then have a repair shop upgrade the drive.

  2. 0

    Apple Support Community member

    Imported from the Apple Support Forums via the Wayback Machine 🔗

    You mentioned

    The reason I'm even considering an iMac is that the screen is so nice and big and my elderly eyes ain't getting any sharper.

    The new iMacs have large screens, but that does not necessarily mean the default text size that you see on the screen will be larger. In fact, it may be smaller, because the pixels are more densely packed onto the screen than previous iMacs. The 21.5-inch iMac has about 102 pixels per inch (PPI). The 27-inch iMac has about 109 PPI. In contrast, the previous 24-inch iMac has about 94 PPI.

    Since your current Mac is a laptop, it may actually have higher PPI, depending on the model. However, people tend to use laptops with the screen closer to their eyes, compared to a desktop computer. If you post back with the screen resolution and diagonal size of your PowerBook, I can tell you the PPI number.

    If possible, you should visit an Apple Store to see if the iMacs have displays that will be comfortable for you to use.

    Another consideration would be to get a Mac mini. They are very small, and you can connect up to two displays of your own choosing, including the 24-inch Apple Cinema, which gives you LED backlighting like the NEW iMacs with an LCD of the same resolution and dimensions as the OLD 24-inch iMacs. That Apple display also gives the Mac mini nice speakers, an iSight camera, and extra USB ports (sometimes it's available on Apple Store's "Special Deals" page as a refurb for $599). And performance is surprisingly good, as long as you are not using it for high-end applications such as Final Cut Pro. I recently helped set one up; the newest version has more standard RAM and faster CPU.

  3. 0

    Apple Support Community member

    Imported from the Apple Support Forums via the Wayback Machine 🔗

    I have a 15" PB G4 - native resolution 1280x854.

    I hate trying computers at the Apple store as one is standing, not sitting such as one would at home. It's very difficult to really see how using it would be.

  4. 0

    Apple Support Community member

    Imported from the Apple Support Forums via the Wayback Machine 🔗

    True, but you can at least see how far from the screen is comfortable for you, and decide if you can use it that way at home. You can also see if the glassy (glass covered) display is comfortable.

    I have a 15" PB G4 - native resolution 1280x854.

    I think those LCDs were 15.2 inches diagonal, so using that number, it comes out to be about 101 PPI, which is basically the same as the 21.5-inch iMac's display. The only difference is that the screen may be a bit closer when you use a laptop, but that depends on how your posture when you use it. But otherwise, the same objects (such as icons and text) on your current PowerBook screen will be about the same size on the 21.5-inch iMac screen. It will look a bit sharper on the iMac because it has that glossy screen, versus the matte finish on the PowerBook.

  5. 0

    Apple Support Community member

    Imported from the Apple Support Forums via the Wayback Machine 🔗

    Okay - now this is a DUMB question: if things on the screen are the same size as my laptop, what is the point of the huge screen? Is it just to have more windows open and show full spreadsheets?

    I was hoping to see everything a bit bigger, very bright and very sharp. If I won't then perhaps I should just fix my old iBook and keep my PB as my "good" computer.

  6. 0

    Apple Support Community member

    Imported from the Apple Support Forums via the Wayback Machine 🔗

    Exactly... the 21.5-inch iMac screen will give you about double the number of pixels to work with, compared to your current PowerBook. So it would be like having two 15-inch screens instead of one. You can have more (and larger) windows visible at the same time.

    As you can with your current PowerBook, you can lower the resolution setting in System Preferences Displays pane. That will make everything on the screen look bigger, but it will be slightly blurry because one displayed pixel no longer precisely equals one physical pixel on the screen.

    If you get a Mac mini, you can pick a DVI display that has +bigger pixels+. For example, a 19-inch display that is 1440x900 is about 89 PPI, so you not only get a larger screen, but objects on the screen will also look larger. Another common size is 22-inch display at 1650x1050, which is also about 89 PPI. And I mentioned Apple's current 24-inch LED (backlit) Cinema Display, which is 24-inch at 1920x1200, which is about 94 PPI. The previous iMac 24-inch, which is often available on Apple +Special Deals+ (refurb) page, has the same size and resolution screen. So with those screens, compared to your current PowerBook, the screen is physically larger AND things on the screen will look slightly larger, but you also get more pixels to work with.

  7. 0

    Apple Support Community member

    Imported from the Apple Support Forums via the Wayback Machine 🔗

    Thank you SO much! You have given me exactly the info I needed. You have also saved me some money! Again, thanks!

  8. 0

    Apple Support Community member

    Imported from the Apple Support Forums via the Wayback Machine 🔗

    Personally, I prefer the earlier 24" screen to the new 21.5" largely due to the change in aspect ratio.

    Whilst the new screens are perfect for watching films, as there wider but not as tall for most 'long' windows such as webpages or word documents there are actually less practical as you require height rather than extra width.