Benches Mac desktops

9

mac pro ram early 2008 model

apple Verified

Imported from the Apple Support Forums via the Wayback Machine 🔗

i just got my refurbished mac pro on tuesday this week, yet already i want to upgrade it.

i was looking into upgrading the ram as my first priority. after a little nosing around i found that it uses 1.8v fully buffered ram. i was wondering if i put unbuffered ram in, how would it react.

as im a music student at college im a little short on cash as you can imagine, so i really don't want to go down the £80 for 2gb of ram route if i can help it.

so i would also ask (other than ebay) if you know of any good places in the uk to get cheap ram for the mac pro.

thanks in advance

9 replies

Sign in or join Beachball Help to reply.

  1. 0

    varjak paw

    Imported from the Apple Support Forums via the Wayback Machine 🔗

    The Mac Pro requires 800MHz DDR2 ECC fully buffered DIMMs. Do not attempt to use non-buffered RAM or anything else out of spec; the system may flat not run, and if it does it's quite likely to be unstable.

    Similarly, don't buy the cheapest RAM you can find. There's a reason why it's cheap, usually because it won't pass anyone else's certification tests (such RAM is referred to in the industry as "floor sweepings"). If you can't afford RAM from a reliable vendor (search this forum for "RAM UK" and you should find a number of recommendations), hold off until you can afford to buy quality parts. Bad RAM will cause you nothing but grief, and while it's not guaranteed that RAM from a "cheap parts vendor", getting bad RAM is more likely from such a vendor. Better to run your system with less RAM than would be ideal for best performance than to struggle with flakey RAM.

    Message was edited by: Dave Sawyer

  2. 0

    The hatter

    Imported from the Apple Support Forums via the Wayback Machine 🔗

    Crucial UK would be top quality, so is Kinston KVA, but you must use FB-DIMM ECC that is specifically geared and qualified for use in Mac Pro 2008 (800MHz RAM) only.

    These people ship to UK and gives you an idea of prices.

    http://eshop.macsales.com/shop/memory/Mac-Pro-Memory

    Cheap and ECC FBDIMM don't go together and you don't want to have trouble, errors, or after 3 months only half the RAM showing up from "marginal" memory quality.

    http://developer.apple.com/technotes/tn2006/tn2156.html

    http://docs.info.apple.com/article.html?artnum=304235

  3. 0

    ubermensch76

    Imported from the Apple Support Forums via the Wayback Machine 🔗

    Hi,

    IS OWC good ? I plan to get 8 Gb ( 2 x 4 ) from them.

    Also Can I combine my existing 2gb ram that came with the system with the 8 Gb from OWC to get a total of 10 Gb ? or would you advise against that ?

    Thanks.

  4. 0

    Robert Newall

    Imported from the Apple Support Forums via the Wayback Machine 🔗

    I endorse the comments that you should use full spec ram. Don't buy it from Apple but note that Apple uses various makes of ram. My MacPro had Hynix and Transcend in their pre install. Some people say use the same make for your pairs or quads but Apple told me it is the functional parameters that matter and their advice for same make re Final Cut pro, is a safety to stop folk using ram with different parameters, including heat sink capabilities.

    The other thing is to plan your upgrade so you don't need to discard existing ram if need be and to bear in mind near future further upgrades.

    There are quite a lot of postings in 'Expanding Your Mac Pro' about ram and about the placing of ram. Look at them. If you plan carefully you will probably be able to get same maker pairs etc in your package. Hynix, Transcend, Kingston and Crucial are all available in the UK in the correct specification but not necessarily all from the same supplier. Buy ECC ram that is Error Correction Coded ram. Some of the 'faster' rams aimed at gamers are not ECC.

  5. 0

    The hatter

    Imported from the Apple Support Forums via the Wayback Machine 🔗

    Any memory you buy has to say it is compatible with Mac Pro 2008, and non-ECC wouldn't even be an option. Any memory that is generic PC memory, even if it is Fully Buffered DIMMs isn't going to.

    Crucial and Kingston have their own memory selection tool to select the correct memory, Apple -> Mac Pro -> 8-core, etc etc.

    Memory will and should only be sold in pairs. Or quad.

    When one DIMM failed for me, I had to return the set, even though it was only a problem on one. Crucial, OWC etc will only sell a set or kit and not individual DIMMs.

    Your comment 'suggests' it is almost optional. Putting Crucial and Apple in a matched pair together will not work 99% of the time, even though ALL RAM sold for Mac Pro should and probably is " functional identical " as much as RAM differs a lot (think DNA, no two are 200% alike).

  6. 0

    Robert Newall

    Imported from the Apple Support Forums via the Wayback Machine 🔗

    Well Hatter, that was what the Applecare technician told me. I did wonder if he was saving Apple's face by confirming correctness of what Apple had installed into my MacPro, but there it was. He did repeat it several times. I suppose I must have been in the lucky 1%. I am not usually so fortunate. The reason I asked them that is that my MacPro had, pre installed by Apple, Hynix in slot 1 and transcend in slot2. The same was the case on the other carrier. The machine ran well for about two months and then I bought some more ram. I do admit I then gathered the makers together into pairs on adjacent slots and it still runs well.

    What are the number of incidences where you have found problems from two makers in adjacent slots where the functional parameters were otherwise identical, and correct for the machine? The proof of the pudding is in the eating so such a practical experience as you assert would be the one to heed, and I would sincerely like to know.

    I made the point about ECC in case one was looking at speed FBB and other features, that is being partial in what one regarded as the material points, as Apple alleged they were. I don't think I suggested any option for non ECC but in some listings the stuff like Crucial's 'Ballistic' can look tempting.

    You are correct that vendors will likely sell in pairs but that does not mean that a user will install it in pairs. I could have placed the Kingston ram I bought as Apple had done with the Hynix or the Transcend, one in one carrier and one in the other.

    You may have made a typing error in your last sentence, if not tell me. I take it you meant to say 'as such' and not as you did "as much". Frankly I fail to see what a computer does that is not a 'function'. If there is some real feature that varies between manufacturers then tell us what it is and what it does and we we can steer clear. I suppose it could be the conductance of the heat sinks which is not specified in the listings. However assuming a reputable manufacturer he clearly thinks his heat sinks are adequate. I do see different temperatures between cards within the slots I have and that is with pairs installed. It is all within acceptable limits even over the whole carrier.

    I have not seen, on the module that is, that memory is compatible with the MacPro. I would not expect it to as there are many sorts of computers and the MacPro memory might be the bees knees for them as well. You do however get to the package you get to through a search, manually or using a configurator, by looking for Mac Pro and the MacPro type details.

    I did not say that FBB was the sole or even the most important feature. The man posting raised that specifically so I said FBB, and incidentally said ECC, and also at risk of repeating myself that it should have all the functional parameters required by the MacPro.

  7. 0

    The hatter

    Imported from the Apple Support Forums via the Wayback Machine 🔗

    http://developer.apple.com/technotes/tn2006/tn2156.html

    A guy from Crucial talked to use on AD back in '04 when Apple tightened memory specs and it affected every vendor making for problems and more testing.

    Apple should make it clearer? that you have to move the Apple DIMMs when adding more memory.

    People from G5s get the idea that pairs are across Risers. They are not.

    No two DIMMs are 100% identical. Nor from different batches, so you could get more Crucial memory later that doesn't work with the original for odd reasons. And forget using Ballistix - some have tried.

    My own personal choice is TechWorks (Buffalo) from OWC (MacSales).

    It is rarer for two brands to work in adjoining DIMM slots.

    The more you understand the ABM FBDIMM controller, and how quad-channel works, the easier it is to get a picture.

    http://developer.apple.com/documentation/HardwareDrivers/Conceptual/HWTechRAM/Articles/RAM_implementation.html#//apple_ref/doc/uid/TP40003899-SW11200331177

  8. 0

    Robert Newall

    Imported from the Apple Support Forums via the Wayback Machine 🔗

    I note in the description you point me to on the controller, nothing that says it needs adjacent slots with same manufacturer. It does talk about pairs but not in connection with adjacent slots. Pairs could mean same size or some further identities. The risers each have transitive links between slots 4 and 3, and 3 and 1 there are no transitive links between adjacent slots. The channels linked directly to the controller are to adjacent slots though. I don't see that proving any point about manufacturers. There may be something that is unknown except in effect that is why I ask about the number of instances you have found.

    The tech note 2156 you refer to is mentioned in the one on the controller but it does not say same manufacturer. It does suggest adequacy. I would doubt that heat bottlenecks would arise from issues of conduction between the heatsinks per se, and the flow paths between the cards are a little more complex than required to permit an inference of heat conductance problems through the pins if adjacent cards are not same manufacturer.

    You do indeed direct me to advice I should listen to from Crucial. Unfortunately you do not say what that advice was except that memory specs were tightened. You still have not said what spec tightened or not, argues to 'same maker'.

    There is advice about moving DIMMs but it relates as far as I can recall only to doing the good thing about module sizes, not makers. I think I have seen it from Apple whose installers at Cork will have set up quite a lot of computers and they did not put same maker in my adjacent slots. They may have erred but it worked for two months and then I took it all out and put it back in differently. It did not fail with the vendors set up.

    I have never had a G5 so can't and didn't, argue from that incorrect (as you suggest it) position. I have not said the pairs should be across the risers. What I did say was that my original config made by Apple in Cork, was across the risers and I did say it worked well. I have also said that my installation when I got even more ram was with same makes (and same functional parameters), in adjacent slots. It still works well.

    I am (was) one of those rare cases you allude to in your seventh sentence where two makers in adjacent slots did work. Perhaps you can set my mind at rest and tell me how many instances have you have met of ram from different makers (and only that variance)in adjacent slots not working. You mentioned 99% so should remember at least a ball park figure. You seem to 'play around' a lot , to put it that way, with your devices so some quantities should be persuasive and available.

    You mention "No two DIMMs are 100% identical.", and that difference only, that they are not an identity s.s. That so, what assurance is same maker if there are no identities even within a batch. I am sure you are not in that remark trying to construct a self fulfilling prophecy.

    You must be right, 'Ballistix' would not work it is not ECC. I thought I made that clear with the context. I did say use ECC.

    I am not an evangelist for a casual placement of ram modules by the way.

  9. 0

    RobertoH

    Imported from the Apple Support Forums via the Wayback Machine 🔗

    I've had great success from
    RAMJet. I bought 2 GB from them last year and they are running great so far. I also recently bought another 4 GB from them, and so far they are great!

    --->Robert

    8-)