iTunes Has Destroyed My Music Collection
apple Verified ·
Imported from the Apple Support Forums via the Wayback Machine 🔗
The iCloud Music Library has ruined years worth of work uploading CD's, buying music from Apple, and creating Playlists. When I first got iTunes (very shortly after it came out) I thought it was a miracle. I loved how well I could manage my music. Since then with the advent of iCloud Music Library and Apple's whole music match technology, it's all ruined, and every time I make an attempt to re-build, something goes wrong. I have spoken to Apple reps on the phone, been to more than one Genius Bar, even spoke to a very senior iTunes expert at Apple who tried to help, but the workaround he suggested to avoid these problems was hugely cumbersome, and one wrong move and all the work would be lost again. I've read several posts on here about this issue, but no solutions for normal people like me. I'm 55 years old and relatively tech savvy. My first Apple computer was the Macintosh Classic back in 1987. (Yes I really was once 23 years old.) THAT'S how long I've been devoted to Apple. But this whole issue has destroyed my respect for the Apple brand, and I'm convinced they have no interest in solving this problem which seems to effect only a small minority of people, especially if they listen to somewhat non traditional music, or are not willing to go back and buy from Apple every CD they ever owned when the CD is right in the hall closet. I wish we could just go back to the early days of iTunes. If anyone out there thinks they can help, please let me know, but I've probably heard that one already. Sigh :(
12 replies
Sign in or join Beachball Help to reply.
- 0
JohnUKDevon ·
Imported from the Apple Support Forums via the Wayback Machine 🔗
OP - I couldn't agree more. Also in my 50s (though slightly older than you) and consider my self v tech savvy
I have lost count of the number of ...
- random tracks lost in albums
- albums broken up into part albums, some in compilations with loss of tracks and coherence
- duplicate listings of track, but so many ghosts it's almost 50:50 throughout my library that a track I click on will not be "found"
- etc etc
.. in my library.
I don't have enough days left on this earth to sort all that out, whatever the clever "fix" that's offered
iTunes has lost track of its original mission: "to organise, retain and enable swift access to your music collection" ... now it actively hinders that and throws in random track loss and deletion to boot
Don't get me started on iTunes Match / iOs 12 issues ...
So what is my reply to the OP? I'm afraid there may not be a clever and follow-able solution out there to get the iTunes behemoth to behave
- 0
iTunesIsDrivingMeCrazy ·
Imported from the Apple Support Forums via the Wayback Machine 🔗
Wow. Glad to hear from yet another dissatisfied customer that I'm not alone, but this still leaves me in limbo, and the pleasure of listening to music has been serious hampered by all of this.
- 0
iTunesIsDrivingMeCrazy ·
Imported from the Apple Support Forums via the Wayback Machine 🔗
Mismatched songs: i.e. Song A (Live in Concert) from a CD gets converted to Song A (Studio or other version, sometimes not even by the same artist.)
Yes albums broken up in to multiple parts.
One CD I keep uploading to iTunes and then sync my phone, and shortly after the CD is gone from the phone. That particular CD is not found in Apple Music I do know that, but so are MANY others of mine as I listen to some (not all) obscure music.
I uploaded a 2 CD set, each as a separate CD (because frankly I couldn't figure out how to get it all under a single album listing.) Shortly after, one of the two CD uploads is gone, but now a single listing appears with both CDs combined, as I'd wanted, but with no artwork and the Album does not appear under Albums when I search, but under Artists.
I had an uploaded CD that functioned fine for years but it got all screwed up in iTunes so I deleted entirely recently and re-uploaded. Now, it appears as what looks like two of the same CD, but one has only six arbitrarily chosen songs four of which are greyed out, and the other has the 23 correct songs of the CD all fine followed by another 23 tracks from a completely unrelated album which I have no recollection of ever even buying. It's a bunch of classical music songs which appear to be from one artists/orchestra but I purchase very little classical, usually a song here or there as I wish and don't recall ever buying an entire CD. (PS Just looked at my "Purchased" list while investigating this and see only 21 songs in iTunes on my laptop when I've actually bought many more, but on the iPhone under "Purchased" there are many, I imagine most, of my purchases, but also a few that I KNOW I uploaded from CD's I own. Did not purchase.)
I'm sparse on more detail as this started at least a year ago and I have spent all this time attempting a fix. Some of these issues have occurred and changed over time, others are new.
That's about the most I can think of to share right now.
- 0
iTunesIsDrivingMeCrazy ·
Imported from the Apple Support Forums via the Wayback Machine 🔗
I appreciate your reply and hate to say this, but as I said above, I am a reasonably tech savvy 55 year old with a long history of using Apple products, but I just don't have it together enough to process that solution. I really need someone to walk me through it, and that aside, it's a shame because it illustrates the total elimination of the simplicity of music management that once made iTunes great. Been trying to get help at my local store but not a lot of good done there. I am actually chatting with a support person right now who is tryin to get me an appointment there where I can discuss in person. I will bring a printout of your response and the one above it to see if they can walk me through this. But as I said, it's a shame.
- 0
Jimzgoldfinch ·
Imported from the Apple Support Forums via the Wayback Machine 🔗
Hi,
Sorry to hear of your problems. You have not highlighted your issues but it seems to me that you should salvage what you have (or restore from original backup) and rebuild your iTunes library with iCloud music library turned off. Once you are satisfied with your iTunes library back it up.
If you want to continue to use Apple Music or iTunes Match, Next is to consider creating a new library and then turn on iCloud music library - delete all previously matched and uploaded music. Previous iTunes purchases will remain. Download what you want from Apple Music and then add whatever you want from you own library that is not in Apple Music.
Read also this user tip https://discussions.apple.com/docs/DOC-7392.
Jim
- 0
turingtest2 ·
Imported from the Apple Support Forums via the Wayback Machine 🔗
As noted above your post seems short on the details of what has actually gone wrong with your library. When I signed up for iTunes Match I deliberately made a separate library and was selective about what I added into the iCloud Music Library. I also keep both libraries mirrored to a backup and check what is about to get updated when backing up in case there is something unexpected that I need to undo. How long ago did things start to go wrong? Is the library backed up in Time Machine or elsewhere? See Empty/corrupt iTunes library after upgrade/crash - Apple Community for a possible way to restore your library to a recent working state, or share some more details about the situation in case either Jim or I can think of something else to offer.
tt2
- 0
iTunesIsDrivingMeCrazy ·
Imported from the Apple Support Forums via the Wayback Machine 🔗
I appreciate your reply and hate to say this, but as I said above, I am a reasonably tech savvy 55 year old with a long history of using Apple products, but I just don't have it together enough to process that solution. I really need someone to walk me through it, and that aside, it's a shame because it illustrates the total elimination of the simplicity of music management that once made iTunes great. Been trying to get help at my local store but not a lot of good done there. I am actually chatting with a support person right now who is tryin to get me an appointment there where I can discuss in person. I will bring a printout of your response and the one above it to see if they can walk me through this. But as I said, it's a shame.
- 0
turingtest2 ·
Imported from the Apple Support Forums via the Wayback Machine 🔗
The user tip explains how to revert to a recent state of the library by copying one file, and renaming two files. The process is only slightly more involved if you have iTunes Match as that needs turning off first so that the restored library isn't immediately replaced with the current state of the cloud library. This assumes the media itself hasn't be deleted, or can be recovered from backup, and the process usually works best if performed immediately after something has gone wrong. Whether or not is even the appropriate advice depends very much on what you think has gone with your library, which we have still yet to hear.
The iCloud Music Library has ruined years worth of work uploading CD's, buying music from Apple, and creating Playlists.
How? What is missing? The music, the playlists? Does music in the library play or is it littered with exclamation marks? Is the issue that metadata you've set the way that you like it changes to show what was originally in the store? Are your albums broken into multiple parts, or are the tracks shown in the wrong order? Or perhaps you damaged things while cleaning duplicates? If we don't know what the issues are how can we help?
tt2
- 0
iTunesIsDrivingMeCrazy ·
Imported from the Apple Support Forums via the Wayback Machine 🔗
Mismatched songs: i.e. Song A (Live in Concert) from a CD gets converted to Song A (Studio or other version, sometimes not even by the same artist.)
Yes albums broken up in to multiple parts.
One CD I keep uploading to iTunes and then sync my phone, and shortly after the CD is gone from the phone. That particular CD is not found in Apple Music I do know that, but so are MANY others of mine as I listen to some (not all) obscure music.
I uploaded a 2 CD set, each as a separate CD (because frankly I couldn't figure out how to get it all under a single album listing.) Shortly after, one of the two CD uploads is gone, but now a single listing appears with both CDs combined, as I'd wanted, but with no artwork and the Album does not appear under Albums when I search, but under Artists.
I had an uploaded CD that functioned fine for years but it got all screwed up in iTunes so I deleted entirely recently and re-uploaded. Now, it appears as what looks like two of the same CD, but one has only six arbitrarily chosen songs four of which are greyed out, and the other has the 23 correct songs of the CD all fine followed by another 23 tracks from a completely unrelated album which I have no recollection of ever even buying. It's a bunch of classical music songs which appear to be from one artists/orchestra but I purchase very little classical, usually a song here or there as I wish and don't recall ever buying an entire CD. (PS Just looked at my "Purchased" list while investigating this and see only 21 songs in iTunes on my laptop when I've actually bought many more, but on the iPhone under "Purchased" there are many, I imagine most, of my purchases, but also a few that I KNOW I uploaded from CD's I own. Did not purchase.)
I'm sparse on more detail as this started at least a year ago and I have spent all this time attempting a fix. Some of these issues have occurred and changed over time, others are new.
That's about the most I can think of to share right now.
- 0
JohnUKDevon ·
Imported from the Apple Support Forums via the Wayback Machine 🔗
OP - I couldn't agree more. Also in my 50s (though slightly older than you) and consider my self v tech savvy
I have lost count of the number of ...
- random tracks lost in albums
- albums broken up into part albums, some in compilations with loss of tracks and coherence
- duplicate listings of track, but so many ghosts it's almost 50:50 throughout my library that a track I click on will not be "found"
- etc etc
.. in my library.
I don't have enough days left on this earth to sort all that out, whatever the clever "fix" that's offered
iTunes has lost track of its original mission: "to organise, retain and enable swift access to your music collection" ... now it actively hinders that and throws in random track loss and deletion to boot
Don't get me started on iTunes Match / iOs 12 issues ...
So what is my reply to the OP? I'm afraid there may not be a clever and follow-able solution out there to get the iTunes behemoth to behave
- 0
turingtest2 ·
Imported from the Apple Support Forums via the Wayback Machine 🔗
Thanks, I have a clearer picture now. I guess I took a different approach with iTunes Match than you, mainly because my full library is too large for match, but also because I'd seen the odd complaint. I made myself a separate library to work with match and have added content into it slowly, starting with my purchases. When my custom metadata was reset I hid the offending items from my purchase history and then reintroduced the album the way that I want it. I've been working with iTunes for over 10 years so I've got very familiar with techniques for forcing albums to display exactly they way I want as described in Grouping tracks into albums, and I've written a bunch of scripts to perform repetitive manual edits which can be found at Scripts for iTunes for Windows. FWIW I'm in my mid-50s too.
In my experience iTunes has never actively altered the music in the source copy of my iTunes Match library. I haven't personally run into issues with the wrong version of a track making it to my IOS devices, or playing on my Apple TV or HomePod, but I have seen others discuss how to force tracks to be uploaded instead of matched when that does happen. Typically it requires making an edit to the audio to prevent audio fingerprint matching.
I backup my library using the advice I give in Backup your iTunes for Windows library with SyncToy - Apple Community. Barring once incident (which I recovered from) where iTunes deleted all my podcast episodes because it synced settings from my iPad to my library rather than the other way around, it has never deleted anything from my library that I haven't asked it to.
As above there is no quick fix for inconsistencies in a library, but the using the column browser layout is possible to step thorough the albums one at time fixing the odd split album when it arises, and you can use smart playlists to gather tracks with specific properties that you want to fix, e.g. no artwork, missing album artist, etc. as well as iCloud Music Library specific issues such as those mentioned in About iCloud Music Library icons and status - Apple Support.
tt2
- 0
iTunesIsDrivingMeCrazy ·
Imported from the Apple Support Forums via the Wayback Machine 🔗
Wow. Glad to hear from yet another dissatisfied customer that I'm not alone, but this still leaves me in limbo, and the pleasure of listening to music has been serious hampered by all of this.