Benches iPod

15

Why isn't there a disk mode for iPod Touch?

apple Verified

Imported from the Apple Support Forums via the Wayback Machine 🔗

I had and iPod Mini and I have an iPod Nano 3G, both supported "disk mode" and were available to use as a removable drive. I've recently purchased an iPod Touch and this is no longer available, I thought at first that there was some kind of problem with the drivers or something, but apparently this is "expected behavior".

Isn't there a way to allow the iPod Touch to work as a removable drive? Why did they took that option?

Thanks a lot

Harry

15 replies

Sign in or join Beachball Help to reply.

  1. 0

    iain220

    Imported from the Apple Support Forums via the Wayback Machine 🔗

    this is because it uses a flash memory, not the old hard-drive for memory.. sorry but i guess you could still use your old ipod nano's harddrive for memory . 🙂

  2. 0

    harrypotel

    Imported from the Apple Support Forums via the Wayback Machine 🔗

    That makes sense, but I thought that the new iPod Nano (3G) also used a flash memory. Does it use a hard drive?

  3. 0

    Zevoneer

    Imported from the Apple Support Forums via the Wayback Machine 🔗

    *this is because it uses a flash memory*

    Actually the Nano also uses flash memory so this is not the reason the Touch cannot be enabled as a removable drive. Apple have disabled this function on the iPod Touch by design.

  4. 0

    Craig Weiland

    Imported from the Apple Support Forums via the Wayback Machine 🔗

    I have been curious about this well. I bought an iPod Touch
    expecting that there would be a disk mode .. as all of my previous iPods (save for my shuffle) had this capability.

    Why did Apple cripple the iPod Touch?

  5. 0

    FledMorphine

    Imported from the Apple Support Forums via the Wayback Machine 🔗

    iLounge:

    However, Apple has implemented neither and the reason is probably pretty simple - do you think Apple really want your average consumer to have direct access to the iPod Touch when the entire filesystem is then visible? The older iPods had a firmware that was not accessible via disk mode, hence the difference.

    You're going to have consumers left and right trying to move and change things around. The last they want to have to deal with is thousands of people every day crowding into Apple Stores and tying up their support because they decided that all these folders with .app extensions (like MobileMusicPlayer.app) are taking up space for their Spice Girls songs... Grandpa Joe does not need access to the filesystem where he can accidentally delete stuff.

    Apple didn't disable disk mode because it's worthless - 1) it wouldn't support disk mode because of the changes to the operating system and 2) they really don't want people who have no business in a filesystem messing it up...

    http://forums.ilounge.com/showthread.php?t=217123

  6. 0

    Simon Teale

    Imported from the Apple Support Forums via the Wayback Machine 🔗

    Thanks for the insight,

    but I too am a little miffed that this isn't there. It doesn't take a rocket scientist to be able to put up and restrict access to a single folder for disk mode.

    Or a selection of folders, for documents to be read by the PDF / Excel reader, and for general storage without using iTunes.

    A missed opportunity some would say. But probably more to do with the SDK, why give users the functionality when you can charge them for it ? Changed days from when the users had the power to achieve what they wanted, Apple products now appear to be crippled with the promise of the desired functionality only being made available if you pay for it again. This doesn't breed customer loyalty. I had to persuade someone today not to buy an iPod Touch because of the general lack of functionality unless you're in a wireless hotspot.

  7. 0

    FledMorphine

    Imported from the Apple Support Forums via the Wayback Machine 🔗

    Perhaps when the SDK is available they may allow that access to devs?

  8. 0

    JOHN ALBERGO

    Imported from the Apple Support Forums via the Wayback Machine 🔗

    Agreed, the disk mode thing seems rather arbitrary and Apple should have a good explanation for removing a feature that many long-time ipod users take for granted.

    I disagree with the "general lack of functionality" though. Loss of wireless seems more of a specific lack of functionality than a general one. It's still a fine music and video player when not connected to the internet. I don't see this as any kind of intentional crippling. If you want wider coverage you've got to ride a proprietary mobile network -- meaning a paid account. Ergo, there is iPhone.

  9. 0

    Chris CA

    Imported from the Apple Support Forums via the Wayback Machine 🔗

    all of my previous iPods (save for my shuffle) had this capability.

    This is available on the shuffle also.

  10. 0

    seaside

    Imported from the Apple Support Forums via the Wayback Machine 🔗

    iain220 wrote:

    this is because it uses a flash memory, not the old hard-drive for memory..

    Sorry, but this isn't even a bit of a reason. Flash can perfectly be used to read and WRITE data.

    A recent test of a computer mag reported, that they failed to kill a USB-stick by means of performing an enormous amount of read/write of the same memory address. After days of continuous writing/updating, they stopped the test.

  11. 0

    Eric Lindsay

    Imported from the Apple Support Forums via the Wayback Machine 🔗

    Craig Weiland wrote:

    I have been curious about this well. I bought an iPod Touch
    expecting that there would be a disk mode .. as all of my previous iPods (save for my shuffle) had this capability.

    I also expected to have access to the disk mode in the iPod Touch. I was using the museum feature to take a variety of notes with me on my first generation iPod Nano. However the font size was too small for me, and the limited HTML access not enough to select a larger font. Then it turned out the current model Nano had an even smaller font. I had hoped the larger Touch screen would be better. Instead the iPod Touch is far less flexible.

    Why did Apple cripple the iPod Touch?

    That is how I feel too. The iPod Touch is crippled for certain things I was able to do with a first generation Nano. Now I will have to put my notes into a Data URL, so I can use a Safari bookmark to see them when out of reach of Wifi (which is almost all the time). Not a happy user at this time.

    Especially when I don't want to sync all my Safari bookmarks with my iPod. I just want to sync the subset I would use while surfing with the iPod Touch. Hmm, that seems like a Feature Request for iTunes.

  12. 0

    Simon Teale

    Imported from the Apple Support Forums via the Wayback Machine 🔗

    The general lack of functionality means that all but three of the features are useless away from wifi.

    How hard would it have been to let us load HTML pages to view offline, or to load Maps (via wifi) for us to view while in transit ? Even letting us load notes, which we could do previously, even on my ancient 3rd Gen iPod, and read them while in transit.

    As I said, it doesn't help customer loyalty, I won't be buying another, key areas of functionality that I have grown to expect, perhaps demand, are crippled. I've helped sell untold volumes of iMacs, PowerMacs, PowerBooks and iPods with my PBG4 and 3rd gen iPod in constant use in the many companies I've consulted for. Friday was the first time I've had to insist that someone stays away from the new iPods.

  13. 0

    Chris CA

    Imported from the Apple Support Forums via the Wayback Machine 🔗

    After the 2.0 upgrade, all your reasons that you "insist that someone stays away from the new iPods" will most likely be moot.

  14. 0

    Simon Teale

    Imported from the Apple Support Forums via the Wayback Machine 🔗

    I admire your faith, but I expect little or nothing from what will arrive in June.

    I've seen the revenue-driven nature of the AppleTV 2.0 "upgrade" which only provided benefit for ATV customers in the US wanting video rentals. It provided absolutely nothing that the existing customers had been asking for through feedback.

    And whatever the iPhone v2.0 firmware provides, it's not going to help the iPod Classic users wanting the disk mode, or a notes reader. Or any of the functionality they've come to expect.

    I was able to install OSX (10.3) and OS9 on my 3rd gen iPod, along with all the music and notes and general file storage it used to carry. I could boot my PBG4 off the iPod if I needed an emergency disk on the road. No need to carry the stack of original cd's around with me. No need to backup documents onto cd, I could mount the iPod and backup onto that. This was a great device. It makes the iPod Touch look like a toy.

  15. 0

    Phi Guy

    Imported from the Apple Support Forums via the Wayback Machine 🔗

    I think you miss the point of the touch. If carrying around your stuff is what's important, you should do what I did. I got a SimplTech portable drive. Fits in your pocket, holds 160GB, and costs $70. Back up your whole computer, including your iTunes acct!

    The touch is a video iPod with Wi Fi capabilities. It's more than a big memory stick. 🙂