15 replies
Sign in or join Beachball Help to reply.
- 0
Drake Bradley ·
Imported from the Apple Support Forums via the Wayback Machine 🔗
R C-R wrote:
See
iPod: Skips to the Next Song. If the file for the currently playing song is damaged, the Nano will skip to the next song at the point it can no longer read it.I'm not sure how this works. If the song plays fine in iTunes, but not on the iPod (my case), then how will deleting it and restoring it from CD help? (Not to mention that I don't have most of the CD's anymore, although I do have backups on my external drive.)
Apple tech support told me to restore the nano, and that seemed to help for awhile, but now it is skipping again. What I am doing now is documenting which songs skip and at what point into the song. I put this info in the comment column for the song in iTunes. Then I copy the song to a playlist called TEST NANO which contains just the songs that skip on my nano, and periodically I update the TEST NANO playlist on the nano to contain the added songs. Aggregating the bad songs in a dedicated playlist makes it easy to review and test just the songs having problems (without having to search the song library on the nano). I will eventually send the nano in for servicing, and indicate that the playlist TEST NANO has the troublesome songs, which they can play to confirm. I will also send (if requested) copies of the iTunes mp3's for the same songs (which play fine in iTunes). This should help nail down the problem.
Unfortunately, my nano warranty lapsed July 17, and at that point I thought the restore procedure had solved the problem. Until today, that is!
Drake
- 0
llcoolguy1 ·
Imported from the Apple Support Forums via the Wayback Machine 🔗
I had this problem back when I had an iPod Nano. I restored it and it stopped doing it. I would give that a try and if it doesn't work, bring it to your local Apple Store and see what they can do. Good Luck.
- 0
outatime88 ·
Imported from the Apple Support Forums via the Wayback Machine 🔗
I had this sort of problem too when I had a Gen. 1 Ipod nano. If the restore doesn't work (Not saying it doesn't work) Then I would suggest, maybe removing that song (or those songs if theres more than just one) and adding it back on your ipod. It helped me and my ipod never did it again. Hope it works!
- 0
lorienleaflady ·
Imported from the Apple Support Forums via the Wayback Machine 🔗
with mine the file isn't damaged, iTunes and every other media player i have has no trouble, but the iPod will start playing, play silence for about 4 seconds, then skip to the next song.
i've tried restoring and everything, and i could try reimporting the file, but i only have the file, it was ripped from a CD i don't have any more.
is there any other solution, or is this a software issue? - 0
lorienleaflady ·
Imported from the Apple Support Forums via the Wayback Machine 🔗
okay, i just realised i have the songs as mp3s, so i just tried making an AAC version of one of the ones that skip, and voila! that one works. hopefully this will work for the others, and maybe some of you =D
- 0
murlough23 ·
Imported from the Apple Support Forums via the Wayback Machine 🔗
I am having this problem with a 4th gen Nano that I bought only about a week ago. It is very frustrating - I just started noticing it at the onset of a long road trip, whichh means I don't have access to my computer or my iTunes library and have no way to re-rip and re-sync the "damaged songs" to my iPod.
I first noticed the problem of iPod pausing for several seconds in the middle of a song and then eventually giving up and jumping to the next song when I had it on shuffle. It was locked at the time, so I knew it hadn't accidentally been shaken (I keep it locked when listening in the car, because I've turned a corner and mistkanely shuffled the thing before) - it was already in the middle of a randomly chosen track and it would pause on its own a few minutes in, not responding to any of my attempts to get it to play again using the pause button.
I was finally able to verify, by playing back one of the "damaged" songs while NOT in shuffle mode, that the problem appeared to be the mp3 file and not shuffle mode. My question is, why would so many of my mp3 files be broken in the first place? Almost all of the files I've got on my iPod were ripped from CDs I own, and relatively new and unscratched ones at that. Are certain applications used to rip audio from CDs known to create problems when iPod or iTunes tries to play them back? (I could just use iTunes to do it, but I don't like not being able to determine exactly how the folder structure and filenames will work out, so I've been using - wait for it - RealPlayer.)
The big problem I'm having here is that if iTunes can handle the file without getting all hung up on it, and other applications such as WinAmp don't pick up any issues, why is an iPod - particularly a brand spankin' new one - having such a hard time?
- 0
murlough23 ·
Imported from the Apple Support Forums via the Wayback Machine 🔗
I'm going to reply to my own post because I think I may have discovered the root cause of the problem. Not sure if this will solve it for others because mine appears to be a special case, but here goes nothing anyway.
Today while playing through an entire album that contained one of the "problem tracks" I noted the other day that would get "stuck" in the middle and then iPod would skip to the next song, I noticed that several tracks within the same album were having the same issue, and that they would get "stuck" about halfway through the song. (I'd have looked at the screen and verified that it was exactly halfway, but I was driving at the time.) It occurred to me that the "problem" tracks I'd encountered over the past few days all had one thing in common - they were from albums that were more than a couple years old. Since I knew the age of the CDs shouldn't be an issue, I then thought about how I might have managed my music differently a few years back compared to now.
Then it hit me. I used to rip everything to my office computer at 96 kbps to save space. My speakers weren't that great anyway, so I didn't notice any loss in sound quality. But more recently, after getting upgraded to a larger hard drive, I started ripping everything at 192 kbps. When I got the iPod and noticed that some of those old songs didn't sound so great, I went through and re-ripped almost all of those old CDs at 192, replacing the old files. Then I re-synched the iPod. My hypothesis is that iTunes is to blame - it may have copied the updated information for some of the files (which had the exact same file names as the old 96 kbps versions), but didn't copy the actual audio, or vice versa. Whatever the case, it seems to have about half of the audio for some tracks, and then either it hits a premature "end of file" and gets confused, or it hits the true end of file because the audio was copied incorrectly.
I'm going to assume that completely wiping everything off of my iPod (basically by unchecking everything in my iTunes library and telling it to sync, then re-checking the albums I wanted and forcing it to re-copy everything back to the iPod) should fix it. It will then think it has to make a fresh copy of all of those mp3 files rather than just looking for updated files. But I won't be able to test this for another 5 days... until then I have to endure the rest of my road trip with a bunch of corrupted albums on my iPod. Grrr.
- 0
Drake Bradley ·
Imported from the Apple Support Forums via the Wayback Machine 🔗
murlough23 wrote:
I'm going to assume that completely wiping everything off of my iPod (basically by unchecking everything in my iTunes library and telling it to sync, then re-checking the albums I wanted and forcing it to re-copy everything back to the iPod) should fix it. It will then think it has to make a fresh copy of all of those mp3 files rather than just looking for updated files. But I won't be able to test this for another 5 days... until then I have to endure the rest of my road trip with a bunch of corrupted albums on my iPod. Grrr.Murlough23,
Before you try the more drastic solution above, let me bring you and others up to date on the solution to my skipping problem. It may work for you as well.
First -- Apple decided to send me a replacement Nano. I assumed that meant they found a hardware problem and that things would now work. The first thing I did was sync the new Nano to my Test NANO playlist to load the problem songs, and then I played them. No cigar. They still skip.
In talking to a very helpful iPod specialist today (Joe), he suggested I try the following:
1. Select the General Tab under iTunes Preferences, and then click on Import Settings.
2. Select ACC encoder, and check the "Use error correction..." box.
3. Exit preferences, and locate the song in your music library that is giving you the problem.
4. Click on the song, and then select Advanced>Create ACC Version.
5. After the song is converted (with error correction), sync it to your iPod and test to see if this solves the skipping problem.
6. If it does, mark the problem as SOLVED!While this solution worked for me on all three songs, the down side is that you have to go and manually add the new version to whatever playlists the old one was stored in, and then delete the old one (assuming you want to save disk space). This is a pain. It would be nice if Apple provided a way to pass the playlist membership of one song to another.
Good luck, and keep us briefed as to what works.
- 0
murlough23 ·
Imported from the Apple Support Forums via the Wayback Machine 🔗
Well Drake Bradley, it wasn't THAT drastic of a solution. I just unchecked the only playlist that I had synced to the iPod and then told it to sync, thereby removing all mp3 files from the iPod, and the re-checked and re-synced. Unfortunately, while this wasn't drastic, it also wasn't a solution. The same files still fail to play properly.
However, I've determined pretty conclusively that the iPod isn't the problem. Silly me, I went to all of that trouble of re-ripping tons of songs right before my vacation, and I never bothered to listen to any of those songs in iTunes until today. Same problem in iTunes, completely independent of the iPod. The only difference is that iTunes doesn't get hung up for several seconds without knowing what to do - it hits what it thinks is the end of the file, and immediately skips to the next track, upping the play count as if it had played the file all the way through. I've watched the little marker that shows how far into the song you are as it scrolls across... as soon as the time elapsed and the time remaining match, it jumps immediately to -0:00 (the end of the track) and then plays the next one. It's as if I had edited the file's Options and set "Stop Time" to halfway through the track. (Exactly halfway makes sense - the old file was 96 kbps, the new file is 192 kbps, and 96 is half of 192.)
A few interesting things that I discovered after further experimentation:
1. I can fast-forward past the halfway point of any of these files, and it will play the rest of the song just fine. It's only when it actually hits that "halfway" point that it skips. So the full song is there in iTunes and on the iPod, it's just thinking the end of file is in the middle of the file.
2. Just to see if the problem was intrinsic to the mp3, I tried to play a few in RealPlayer (the application that I used to rip the songs). They play fine in that application.
3. Removing the songs from my iTunes library and then manually re-adding them to the library appears to fix the playback problem. However, all data that was specifically set in iTunes (album artwork, play count, date last played) and not intrinsic to the ID tags is lost when I do this. I would find it irksome if I had to lose all of that data for hundreds of songs just to get them to play, but I suppose I could live with it.
Your suggestion about re-encoding in AAC format just isn't gonna cut it, because I have several hundred files that I'd have to do this for. I've experimented with the iTunes encoder - it does its job just fine, but I don't like how it names the files or what folder it puts them in. I have to manually delete the old duplicate files from the library. That's a pain. iTunes should be able to recognize that a file has been modified and bring in all data relevant to the new file, even if it has the same filename as the old file. One thing I did make sure to do when I re-ripped all of those songs was to click "Edit Info" in iTunes after highlighting an album's worth of them, and watch as the bitrate updated to 192 and the album artwork disappeared (which I then re-downloaded), and iTunes seems to understand that the file changed, but is still ending at the point in memory where the old file ended. It's a bug in iTunes. I will report it in great detail when I talk to an Apple technician on the phone later today, and I will expect that they will fix it by the release of iTunes 9 at the very latest.
- 0
Drake Bradley ·
Imported from the Apple Support Forums via the Wayback Machine 🔗
However, I've determined pretty conclusively that the iPod isn't the problem. Silly me, I went to all of that trouble of re-ripping tons of songs right before my vacation, and I never bothered to listen to any of those songs in iTunes until today. Same problem in iTunes, completely independent of the iPod.
Ah, well, then you have a different problem, that's for sure.
Your suggestion about re-encoding in AAC format just isn't gonna cut it, because I have several hundred files that I'd have to do this for. I've experimented with the iTunes encoder - it does its job just fine, but I don't like how it names the files or what folder it puts them in. I have to manually delete the old duplicate files from the library. That's a pain.
True, but no more work than deleting them from the iTunes library and then reimporting them again, which is the other solution you discovered. Hopefully the bug will be fixed in the next rev of iTunes and you won't have to do either! Good luck, and please post any final solution you come up with.
- 0
Drake Bradley ·
Imported from the Apple Support Forums via the Wayback Machine 🔗
murlough23,
Just one other test you might want to try -- you mentioned that the songs played fine in RealPlayer. Did you also try Quicktime? While normally used to play movies, you can drag an mp3 file to the QT icon on the task bar in order to load the song into that app. Try that, and see if it only plays halfway through or not. It might be useful for the Apple tech to know if the problem is unique to iTunes or also present in QT.
- 0
maxtrack ·
Imported from the Apple Support Forums via the Wayback Machine 🔗
Interesting to read someone else has encountered a problem similar to the problem I have. I have an original coloured iPod nano 4 GB. I have never replaced 96 kps with 192 kps, but I do have a few songs (which previously played to completion in the same nano) that now ALWAYS stop in the middle of the song. The nano seems to hang for a few seconds then it proceeds to play the next song. I am still in debugging mode....
- 0
Zainyboy ·
Imported from the Apple Support Forums via the Wayback Machine 🔗
I had a similar problem where certain tracks that I copied on my iPod would skip to the next song before the current track had finished(usually with about 30 sec rem.)
If I play those tracks off my iPod through iTunes until they finish completely, they work fine the next time I listen to them on my iPod. - 0
pat_mc_64 ·
Imported from the Apple Support Forums via the Wayback Machine 🔗
I'm struggling with almost exactly the same problem except before there were I pods and much memory in machines I ripped 100's of my CD's at 56 Kb Mp3. But, as computer space increased and I go time, I re-ripped them to 128 Kb Mp3. These re-ripped songs, if copied onto the iPod stop exactly halfway . I use an 80 Gb iPod Video. These songs play fine on iTunes and on every other Mp3 player. I do need to keep them in Mp3 mode because I use several different players (some cheap ones for running in the rain). As you stated I'm sure it has to do with old 'end of file' flags from the original rip at 56 Kb. I am very diligent about song naming conventions so the rerip version would be exactly name and probably the problem. To test I will re-rip some CD's that have this problem but compeletely remove the old files from my hard drive and iPod before ripping. Also, like you, if I skip past the 1/2 point it will ply to the end of the song...
- 0
R C-R ·
Imported from the Apple Support Forums via the Wayback Machine 🔗
See iPod: Skips to the Next Song. If the file for the currently playing song is damaged, the Nano will skip to the next song at the point it can no longer read it.