Benches iPhone

8

Security Issue | App has access to all pi…

apple Verified

Imported from the Apple Support Forums via the Wayback Machine 🔗

Hi

just found this issue, where an app can access all my pictures on the iPhone without asking for permission.

It works with Google Translate (Version 5.26.0, German AppStore)

1. Open Google Translate

2. Click on the camera icon in the app (no permission is allowed for the camera, check under: Settings>Translate)

3. Click on the down left corner on the picture icon of the app

4. All the pictures are accessible (it's not even asked for permission!)

5. You can browse and open any picture!

My iPhone: iPhoneX 256GB iOS 12.1.2 (16C101)

Phone 7 256GB, iOS 12.0.1 same issue.

I have two more Apps from Google installed: Gmail & Youtube.

Neither is allowed to access my pictures, still Google Translate is able to do it.

Can you reproduce this error?

This is how it works for me (yellow circle indicates click):

8 replies

Sign in or join Beachball Help to reply.

  1. 0

    florianemanuel

    Imported from the Apple Support Forums via the Wayback Machine 🔗

    No one can reproduce this error?

    I made smaller pictures, so you can see it better.

  2. 0

    gothinkaboutthis

    Imported from the Apple Support Forums via the Wayback Machine 🔗

    https://www.apple.com/business/docs/iOS_Security_Guide.pdf

    Page 25 - Extensions, 2-3. Paragraf:

    ”A system area that supports extensions is called an extension point. Each extension point provides APIs and enforces policies for that area. The system determines which extensions are available based on extension point–specific matching rules. The system automatically launches extension processes as needed and manages their lifetime. Entitlements can be used to restrict extension availability to particular system apps. For example, a Today view widget appears only in Notification Center, and a sharing extension is available only from the Sharing pane. The extension points are Today widgets, Share, Custom actions, Photo Editing, Document Provider, and Custom Keyboard.

    Extensions run in their own address space. Communication between the extension and the app from which it was activated uses interprocess communications mediated by the system framework. They don’t have access to each other’s files or memory spaces. Extensions are designed to be isolated from each other, from their containing apps, and from the apps that use them. They are sandboxed like any other third-party app and have a container separate from the containing app’s container. However, they share the same access to privacy controls as the container app. So if a user grants Contacts access to an app, this grant will be extended to the extensions that are embedded within the app, but not to the extensions activated by the app.”

    Page 75 - Access to personal data:

    “iOS helps prevent apps from accessing a user’s personal information without permission. Additionally, in Settings, users can see which apps they have permitted to access certain information, as well as grant or revoke any future access.”

  3. 0

    florianemanuel

    Imported from the Apple Support Forums via the Wayback Machine 🔗

    No one can reproduce this error?

    I made smaller pictures, so you can see it better.

  4. 0

    gothinkaboutthis

    Imported from the Apple Support Forums via the Wayback Machine 🔗

    https://www.apple.com/business/docs/iOS_Security_Guide.pdf

    Page 25 - Extensions, 2-3. Paragraf:

    ”A system area that supports extensions is called an extension point. Each extension point provides APIs and enforces policies for that area. The system determines which extensions are available based on extension point–specific matching rules. The system automatically launches extension processes as needed and manages their lifetime. Entitlements can be used to restrict extension availability to particular system apps. For example, a Today view widget appears only in Notification Center, and a sharing extension is available only from the Sharing pane. The extension points are Today widgets, Share, Custom actions, Photo Editing, Document Provider, and Custom Keyboard.

    Extensions run in their own address space. Communication between the extension and the app from which it was activated uses interprocess communications mediated by the system framework. They don’t have access to each other’s files or memory spaces. Extensions are designed to be isolated from each other, from their containing apps, and from the apps that use them. They are sandboxed like any other third-party app and have a container separate from the containing app’s container. However, they share the same access to privacy controls as the container app. So if a user grants Contacts access to an app, this grant will be extended to the extensions that are embedded within the app, but not to the extensions activated by the app.”

    Page 75 - Access to personal data:

    “iOS helps prevent apps from accessing a user’s personal information without permission. Additionally, in Settings, users can see which apps they have permitted to access certain information, as well as grant or revoke any future access.”

  5. 0

    florianemanuel

    Imported from the Apple Support Forums via the Wayback Machine 🔗

    Thanks for your answer gothinkaboutthis!

    So do I understand this correctly:

    The app only has access to the picture which I select and the API hands it over to the app?

  6. 0

    gothinkaboutthis

    Imported from the Apple Support Forums via the Wayback Machine 🔗

    That’s correct!

    The new EU privacy rules are making companies think twice, before potentially breaking new sets of rules. Heavy penalties!

  7. 0

    florianemanuel

    Imported from the Apple Support Forums via the Wayback Machine 🔗

    Thanks!

    So actually this app from Google is the only one so far, which doesn't ask for accessing all my pictures.

    That's why I thought it's a bug. But it's a feature! ;)

  8. 0

    gothinkaboutthis

    Imported from the Apple Support Forums via the Wayback Machine 🔗