Imported from the Apple Support Forums via the Wayback Machine 🔗
Yesterday well driving after finishing about a 10 min conversation about 2:05 PM in MN I put my iphone in my breast pocket of my leather sport coat. After about what seemed like a min i noticed my chest felt really warm (thought to myself wow the phone heated up) then I smelt smoke, my chest started to burn and when i reached in my pocket there were flames, like big ones not little ones! I obviously almost lost control of the car and Wife and I patted the flames out quickly! all that was in my pocket was an iphone a business card and a receipt. I pulled the iphone out and it was hot and still emitting like a burst of flame. The business cards and receipt are burnt i have pictures of all of this including ruined jacket and shirt.
I went to at&t asap and they directed me to apple and we spent an hour there and recorded this but quickly made the phone go away. they saw the phone and were amazed after looking at it and my jacket and receipts that were burnt. They quickly agreed to replace the phone at no charge and upgrade to a 3gs but had no procedure in place for my Jacket and shirt that were ruined (about 700.00) and as polite and helpful as they were really were not to interested in helping with the shirt and jacket issue let alone the danger this really could have resulted while driving in a car.
Has this happened to anyone else and what would you do concerning the Jacket / Shirt and what do you think Apple should do? I love Apple and continue to be a loyal fan and I'm about to convert our small business to all Apple but im a little disappointed considering the circumstances and potential injury. Would love all comments! Thank You
Imported from the Apple Support Forums via the Wayback Machine 🔗
I believe you but you don't have to convince anyone here, including me... we don't matter. I would do a bit of research for cellphone battery fires but I've never heard of an iPhone battery fire. Of course, that certainly doesn't mean they haven't happened before. Personally, I wouldn't bother for a couple hundred bucks but I would try to get my clothes paid for if they were worth that much ($700). Good luck. http://www.apple.com/contact/
0
Tamara·
Imported from the Apple Support Forums via the Wayback Machine 🔗
Apple did as they should and then some. They replaced your phone with a newer model without a quibble.
As far as your clothes, you can always file a claim with your insurance. It's not Apple's responsibility to give you money for a new wardrobe.
0
Tamara·
Imported from the Apple Support Forums via the Wayback Machine 🔗
Apple took responsibility for their defective product but we don't know if user damage caused the product to malfunction.
As far as replacing clothing that would be up to the insurance company just like if your Sony tv burned your carpet. Sony would replace the tv but not the carpet or your insurance would replace both items.
0
deggie·
Imported from the Apple Support Forums via the Wayback Machine 🔗
That is not true Tamara, I actually had a Sony product that caught fire and burned the piece of furniture it was in, the wall, and the carpet. Sony replaced the product and provided me with a check for the damages to the other property with no hassle whatsoever. Their product caused the damage, it is their responsibility to provide the remedy.
If I were the insurance carrier for the OP, and it can be proven that the overheating iPhone did cause the damage to his coat and shirt I would in no way issue a check for the damages, or I would cover it and file a claim against Apple to recover the money sent to the OP. If the iPhone caused the damage due to a malfunction it is Apple's responsibility.
I'm not really aware of any user damage that could cause an iPhone to overheat and catch fire.
0
paulcb·
Imported from the Apple Support Forums via the Wayback Machine 🔗
This is definitely Apple's responsibility. I absolutely hate frivolous lawsuits but if it were me, I'd be in touch with Apple legal department ASAP to get my clothing (but nothing else) paid for.
User damage?... please. There's nothing a user can do to cause an iPhone to catch fire except throw it in a fire, especially when it's just sitting in his pocket. Even if there were, it's still Apples responsibility to some extent... it's called reasonable and foreseeable misuse and is part of the typical risk and failure mode analysis done when developing any product. The extents to which people will go to defend Apple sometimes amaze me.
0
Tamara·
Imported from the Apple Support Forums via the Wayback Machine 🔗
In other words, the person at the Apple store should have just forked over $700 for the jacket and shirt with no proof that the clothing cost that much or even if the phone were responsible for damaging the clothing.
The only google references to the iPhone catching fire involve the phone being plugged in to a power source. I don't see how the phone could magically catch fire in someone's pocket. I also don't understand how his shirt and coat could burn but he had no burns on his skin or hands in the process of putting out said flames.
0
paulcb·
Imported from the Apple Support Forums via the Wayback Machine 🔗
In other words, the person at the Apple store should have just forked over $700 for the jacket and shirt with no proof that the clothing cost that much or even if the phone were responsible for damaging the clothing.
Of course not... that's not what I said at all and was not implied in any way. The guy at the store did the right thing but, if he didn't, should have escalated it up the chain.
The only google references to the iPhone catching fire involve the phone being plugged in to a power source. I don't see how the phone could magically catch fire in someone's pocket. I also don't understand how his shirt and coat could burn but he had no burns on his skin or hands in the process of putting out said flames.
Just because you can't see it happening or don't understand it, doesn't mean it can't or didn't happen. There have been numerous reports of lithium battery based notebooks catching fire just sitting on a desk and the battery technology between the iPhone and notebooks is nearly identical. Having his jacket burn with burn marks on his shirt is highly plausible. While I do find it highly unlikely and unusual, I don't find his story unbelievable at all.
0
BPkirchert·
Imported from the Apple Support Forums via the Wayback Machine 🔗
The fire was real. I have the apple staff that witnessed the shirt /jacket and burnt receipts/ biz cards and the phone itself. All of us were amazed. It's real it happened. I didnt post to discuss if it happened or not, it did and if I could post pictures I would. I posted for opinions as to if it's happened before and what others would do in this situation? Thank you all for you comments!
0
Jimmer07·
Imported from the Apple Support Forums via the Wayback Machine 🔗
Isn't it Apple's responsibility that their phones don't catch on fire during normal use?