Benches iPhone

5

iPhone banned from Princeton University n…

apple Verified

Imported from the Apple Support Forums via the Wayback Machine 🔗

My phone has been
blocked from accessing the wireless network at Princeton University. The reason they gave me by email:

+"OIT has detected that your iPod is using DHCP in a way that's not acceptable on the campus network. The problem is that the iPhone is effectively running two or more simultaneous, independent DHCP clients on the same wifi interface. That is, one network interface is attempting to obtain multiple unique IP address leases at the same time."+

I have no idea what can be causing this. They couldn't tell me if it must be a particular third party application or if it is a bug in the iPhone software. If it is a bug, eventually all iPhones will be banned from the network at Princeton; they have a strict policy where "if you think you solved the problem" they will unblock the access to the wireless network, but if it happens a second time they will ban it forever. There has been a growing number of cases of iPhones and iPod Touch exhibiting this behavior. From their website:

*+"iPhone and iPod Touch+*

+While not all incidents of this nature involve an Apple iPhone or an Apple iPod Touch, a large increase in the number of these incidents since September 2008 is associated with these devices.+

+In more than half of these incidents since September 2008, the malfunctioning device is an Apple iPhone or an Apple iPod Touch. Less often, the device is another workstation owned by a customer who also owns an iPhone or iPod Touch.+

+In these cases, the customer has apparently installed some additional software (not part of the software that comes standard on the device) that has caused either the iPhone, iPod, or workstation to malfunction in this way.+

+The reason it sometimes happens on the workstation apparently is that sometimes the customer installs software on the iPhone/iPod and the workstation to provide some communication between the two beyond that which is provided normally by Apple's standard software.+

+Note that when we block service to a malfunctioning iPod as described above, it remains a functioning music player; the customer just cannot use the University's network to extend network service to the iPod.+

+Note that when we block service to a malfunctioning iPhone as described above, it remains a functioning cell phone and even a functioning Internet device (using the cell phone provider's services); the customer just has to rely on the cell provider for network service instead of the (faster) University network."+

This information is at:

http://www.net.princeton.edu/multi-dhcp-one-interface-handling.html

Also the growing list of blocked devices (including iPhones and iPods misbehaving like mine but also all sorts of weird cheats people attempted on the network with their computers) can be found at:

http://www.net.princeton.edu/hostmaster/oit-wireless-blocked.html

Has anyone experienced this elsewhere? Is this happening only at Princeton? Do you know what can be causing this? I need wi-fi because it is not only faster than 3G, it is also essential (for example, talking on Skype using the application Fring can't be done over the 3G network, also there are places on campus where there is wi-fi but no cellphone reception -classrooms in the basement). Any help or hints are appreciated.

Thanks,

Paulo

5 replies

Sign in or join Beachball Help to reply.

  1. 0

    Lawrence Finch

    Imported from the Apple Support Forums via the Wayback Machine 🔗

    Have you hacked or jailbroken your phone?

    Are you using any apps that sync with a desktop app? Examples are TravelTracker, iTalk, Air Sharing, etc?

    Although I just tried those 3 and none of them create a 2nd connection.

  2. 0

    The Economist

    Imported from the Apple Support Forums via the Wayback Machine 🔗

    Thank you for your reply. I should have mentioned it in my description of the problem: I have never jailbroken or hacked my iphone and I installed all apps through iTunes.

    The only app I have that has a desktop companion to which it talks is Simplify (www.simplifymedia.com) to listen to the songs stored on the computer on the iPhone through the network. I wouldn't mind getting rid of it. How can one test if this is the problem?

  3. 0

    Randy Fast

    Imported from the Apple Support Forums via the Wayback Machine 🔗

    Well that sounds like an app that is trying to establish a separate wifi connection. You could go to IT support and ask them if they can identifiy the IP when you use that app and when you use something like safari. If they can't then try removing that app, then start up safari and see if they are getting any strange IP requests from the iPhone.

    Can you not just put songs on the iPhone and listen to them there? You can use smart playlists or genius to make new ones every day and have fresh music from iTunes. Or get an iPod big enough to carry around everything.

  4. 0

    DTFM

    Imported from the Apple Support Forums via the Wayback Machine 🔗

    I have the same problem. I haven't jailbroken my phone either.

    It started after I ditched MobileMe and installed NuevaSync to keep my iPhone contacts and calendar synched with my Google contacts and calendar.

    I can't really see why NuevaSync would reach down to the Network layer of OSI and start futzing around there, but it's the only change that happened in that timeframe.

    I talked to someone in the OIT center in Frist and he told me the problem was due to me having WiFi turned on when I plugged my phone into my computer. I don't see why this would make it happen, either, but given the level of competence I've seen demonstrated by a few of the staff there, I wouldn't be surprised if he's misunderstood or just miscommunicating the true problem.

    Sorry I can't be more of a help.

  5. 0

    Bob Rodenburg

    Imported from the Apple Support Forums via the Wayback Machine 🔗

    Take a look at this:

    http://www.msnbc.msn.com/id/19836992/

    Sound familiar? Then, this a bit later:

    http://news.duke.edu/2007/07/cisco_apple.html

    Sounds very similar to what's happening to you on the Princeton campus. Perhaps you should forward these sites to the campus IT folks to see if they've fallen victim to the same Cisco network hardware fault.