Benches Board repair

9

Mystery Problem - MDD G4 dual 1.25

apple Verified

Imported from the Apple Support Forums via the Wayback Machine 🔗

Hi all,

First post from a newbie to the list. Bringing this tricky one to the brain trust in hopes of a solution.

I've got a MDD dual 1.25 gHz Power Mac, 2 GB RAM, OS 10.4.10 that's gone "funny." Symptoms are frequent program crashes (Safari, Disk Utility, Mail - you name it) and regular System Failure freezes, sometimes on boot - just like bad memory.

The messages I receive display as black text on white overlay and don't look like Kernel Panics, excerpted as follows:

system failure: cpu=1;

code 00000008 (unaligned stack)

latest crash info cpu 1:

exception state (sv=0x4FACC80)

pc=0x000ABA08;

msr=0x00001030;

dar=0x0000002E;

dsisr=0x40000000;

lr=0x000ABBCC;

r1=0x2C4EBC38;

xcp=0x00000098 (system failure)

backtrace: backtrace terminated - unaligned frame address; 0x2c4EBC38

proceeding back via exception chain:

exception state (sv=0x41FACC80) ... and more I didn't log.

Running internal Disk Utility I have received: "Disk Utility Internal Error - lost connection with Disk Management Tools and cannot continue."

I have gone through all RAM sticks one at a time, an in each of the 4 slots in turn. When I run REMBER, all memory sticks (4 x 512 Kingston DIMM's and original 256 Apple RAM) fail consistently. But ... all these DIMM's pass REMBER without fault when tested in other machines.

I have reset PRAM, NVRAM and PMU, replaced CMOS battery, run Disk Repair and Repair Permissions utility from Tiger Install DVD and disconnected all peripherals, including PCI cards, internal DVD drive, internal hard drives, FW drives.

I have swapped out the video card and logic board with no change and have tried running with the case's access door open and blasted it with an external fan to increase cooling.

A local PC tech pushed the CPU with some serious fractal tests for 16 hours straight with no errors. His Ubuntu LiveCD 6.1 tests indicated that the computer is only accessing the 4x video card (both the original and a replacement) at 1x, though I don't know if this is relevant.

When I attempt a clean install of Tiger on a fresh drive (either from internal DVD or external FW DVD) it predictably fails during the final language installation section.

Interestingly, when I run Apple Hardware Test (Extended Mode), all components pass, including logic board and all memory. I can also boot my G5 and my G4 iBook from the faulty machine's drive and run without incident.

I got this machine new but quite late (in February of 2005) from Mac Resource out of Texas. Other than the current mystery problem, it has run flawlessly and has never been subjected to excessive dirt, moisture, temperature or physical shock.

I'm stumped. The only component I have not yet tested or swapped out is the PSU. I imagine that it could be the culprit. If so, what's the best way to test it? There are no anomalies other than those that appear to be memory related. Display is stable, red light on logic board glows a steady red, etc.

All your suggestions are most welcome and I thank you in advance.

T

9 replies

Sign in or join Beachball Help to reply.

  1. 0

    Josh Keady

    Imported from the Apple Support Forums via the Wayback Machine 🔗

    Sadly, I don't think it's the power supply. I think you have a bad CPU... more specifically, bad cache on one of your processors. The fact that the ram fails only in that machine is biggie. That you're getting a frame address error leads -to me- means that data's not being copied in to RAM correctly and if swapping boards didn't help, there's not much left. Passing the fractal test doesn't necessarily mean everything's 100% peachy.

  2. 0

    Nadav

    Imported from the Apple Support Forums via the Wayback Machine 🔗

    Hi there,

    I would have to say its your processor.. better get out that shovel and say prayers to it, because it looks like you will have to bury it and move on 🙂 Nah, just kidding! I feel your pain with this problem. I can suggest a new processor card. They can be had pretty cheap these days, well maybe the single ones, the dual MDD processors are still a little up in price though.

  3. 0

    toastyt

    Imported from the Apple Support Forums via the Wayback Machine 🔗

    Thanks for getting back so quickly, Josh and Navav. It took me a while to acknowledge your replies because I wanted to do another test, results as follows:

    Got a hold of a Single 1.25 G4 and took the CPU/logic board combo out of my ailing Dual 1.25 and put it in the Single chassis. The problem moved with the CPU. Rember tests failed.

    Then put the Single's CPU/logic board into the Dual chassis. All Rember tests passed. Kind of eliminates the Dual's PSU and points to its CPU.

    An Apple replacement CPU for this machine (Apple Part #661-2707) seems to be a rare and expensive commodity. Refurbished ones asking from $377 to $599 and a new one $780.

    Your thoughts on alternatives much appreciated. Sonnet Encore/MDX G4 Duet 1.6 GHz perhaps?

    T

  4. 0

    toastyt

    Imported from the Apple Support Forums via the Wayback Machine 🔗

    Pardon my typing. Make that Nadav.

    T

  5. 0

    CEB II

    Imported from the Apple Support Forums via the Wayback Machine 🔗

    The Sonnet Encore/MDX G4 Duet Dual 1.6GHz Processor Upgrade for Mirrored Drive Door is $449 from OWC, so that's no bargain either. Personally, if time wasn't a factor, I'd shop ebay for a while for a used 1.25 GHz DP or a 1.42 GHz DP pull. You might even be able to buy a whole MDD G4 that is in poor shape for $400 or less and cannibalize the processor card.

    You definitely don't want to spend $780 for a new, replacement processor card as you could buy a whole MDD G4 in good condition for that kind of money.

    Sorry I didn't see your original post earlier as I might have been able to save you some time defining your problem. I just went through a 2 month effort on a friend's Sawtooth/AGP G4 and ended up with a CPU replacement. The problem is that most software testing utilities always point to the RAM as the problem. I found a FAQ at OWC that suggested running the game, Chess from OS X applications in computer-vs-computer mode for 7 games. If 2 or more games fail, the CPU is probably defective. See:
    http://discussions.apple.com/thread.jspa?threadID=1113229&tstart=0

    Carl B.

  6. 0

    toastyt

    Imported from the Apple Support Forums via the Wayback Machine 🔗

    Thanks, Carl.

    I hear what you're saying.

    The G4 is a backup in case my G5 goes sideways before I'm ready to upgrade. Meanwhile, I'd like to spend as little as possible to get the G4 machine running again, and $780 is way too much, period.

    As far as buying a complete unit goes, it all comes down to location 'cause of the shipping cost.

    At this point, a used Apple CPU or a new Sonnet may be the thrifty options.

    T

  7. 0

    Nadav

    Imported from the Apple Support Forums via the Wayback Machine 🔗

    Personally, I'd go with the dual 1.25 - I am sure there are plenty on ebay. As far as the 1.42DP? If it were me I wouldn't because(then again my system works like a charm) the yield in performance and speed jump is less than 13% which is not so high if you ask me.

    Try ebay, if not I am sure you could do a core return for your processor. Meaning, send the old processor to an Apple authorized repair center, and they will send you a refurb or used processor for less than the cost of a new one. For instance..

    Say the dual 1.25 is 699.00 and a refurb or used is 300.00 - I'd go with the 300.00 replacement since it works fine and will be tested before techs will ship it out.

    Try hard core mac, also Mac Medics around my way. or DH Computers.

  8. 0

    Nadav

    Imported from the Apple Support Forums via the Wayback Machine 🔗

    You forgot to mention that they lack L3 cache which is needed on a G4 to compensate for the "slow" bus, though I don't suffer from any bottlenecks. But then again, i don't use my Mac like it should be.

  9. 0

    toastyt

    Imported from the Apple Support Forums via the Wayback Machine 🔗

    What you say is true.

    I ended up dropping in a Sonnet dual 1.6 gHz card. Problem certainly solved.

    Performance is more than adequate for the demands put to it.

    Thanks for all your input.

    T