Benches Apps and software

4

iMovie and interlaced footage

apple Verified

Imported from the Apple Support Forums via the Wayback Machine 🔗

Hi

I import 1920*1080/50i AVCHD (sony TX7) with import Archive, I get a .mov with Apple intermediate codec (in iMovie events) that is 1920*1080/25 according to Quicktime inspector, it is however obvious in looking the clip that it is still interlaced, quality is still great.

Then I Export Using QuickTime, choose Apple intermediate codec, ensure that desinterlace is not checked, and I get (quickly) a new .mov of the same characteristics (1920*1080/25) BUT this one is NOT interlaced and of course the quality is far worse that the .mov original (less definition, and 25 images/second move characteristics instead of smoother 50i appearance)

Does somebody knows How to export INTERLACED clips from iMovie.

-------------------------------------------------------

Best regards

4 replies

Sign in or join Beachball Help to reply.

  1. 0

    shaynewhite

    Imported from the Apple Support Forums via the Wayback Machine 🔗

    This has been discussed many times. iMovie '08 and '09 don't "pass-thru" interlaced footage. Even if you select interlace on export, iMovie will still use single-field processing.

    The only way to properly get 60i/50i footage through iMovie is to deinterlace the footage using JES Deinterlacer post-capture, pre-editing. iMovie can then import the 50p footage and export without quality loss. If you like, you can re-interlace afterward before putting onto DVD.

    If you have already edited your movie, you're out of luck.

  2. 0

    shaynewhite

    Imported from the Apple Support Forums via the Wayback Machine 🔗

    This has been discussed many times. iMovie '08 and '09 don't "pass-thru" interlaced footage. Even if you select interlace on export, iMovie will still use single-field processing.

    The only way to properly get 60i/50i footage through iMovie is to deinterlace the footage using JES Deinterlacer post-capture, pre-editing. iMovie can then import the 50p footage and export without quality loss. If you like, you can re-interlace afterward before putting onto DVD.

    If you have already edited your movie, you're out of luck.

  3. 0

    Domi27

    Imported from the Apple Support Forums via the Wayback Machine 🔗

    Hi,

    Thank you for this response, I will raise a non conformity of the Apple documentation to Apple Support as it state very clearly that iMovie is compatible with AVCHD 1920*1080/50i and /60i for import with no warning about "some" automatic desinterlacing !!!

    I bought mac because everybody says that its the must for editing, I am desperate, on PC, programs like pinnacle 12 or Sony Vegas can edit AVCHD natively ! I will try with bootcamp...

    Just for fun, Does somebody know what is the desinterlacing type is used automatically by iMovie for 50i import (Discard, Blend, average, bob ...)?

    -------------------------------------------------------------------------------- -

    Last chance for Apple: Is it the same for FCE or is there a possibility to passthrough the interlacing with it.

    For other readers have a look at loss of quality when desinterlace at
    http://www.100fps.com/

    Best Regards

  4. 0

    Domi27

    Imported from the Apple Support Forums via the Wayback Machine 🔗

    Hi again,

    after having checked again, apple intermediate codec seems to support interlaced 50i footage, if you scale 100% in simplemovie or others and open imported .mov iMovie clip, you can see very clearly the interlacing lines when camera moves, it seems that export is the problem, even if you check the interlaced box, it desinterlace when exporting, even if you export to the same Apple intermediate codec. So it seems that it is probably a bug in export.

    Best regards