Benches Apps and software

15

itunes vs. 10.6.2 finder sound (quicktime…

apple Verified

Imported from the Apple Support Forums via the Wayback Machine 🔗

not sure where to post this.

i was wondering if anyone can confirm to how mac os x renders/plays audio in the finder?

in os x 10.6.x, you can play audio files by clicking on the icon in the finder.

what i'm noticing is that my music files sound way better, louder, crisper and punchier than they do after i import them into itunes. i'm converting 320 kbps, playing with equalization, sound enhancer, etc...

i'm assuming it's just quicktime that is playing, but i thought QT was the engine for audio and video in all programs (final ***, etc.)...

i'm wondering why music sounds "worse" in itunes. the "raw" (unfilered) files played thru quicktime/finder sound so much brighter.

any ideas anyone?

15 replies

Sign in or join Beachball Help to reply.

  1. 0

    AntonioDo

    Imported from the Apple Support Forums via the Wayback Machine 🔗

    I just played a song in iTunes and it sounded very muffled. (Sorry I don't have better musical terms, I wish I did!)

    So, remembering something that I read a LONG time ago about the processing power of OLD Macs with respect to playing music, I went to Finder and played the song directly from Finder.

    Indeed, I found the same results as the OP for this thread. I am also curious about why this would be happening. For what it's worth, it's shouldn't matter what the CD was ripped at, because I am playing in the same FILE from both iTunes and Finder.

    I just want want my music to sound its best, regardless of what application plays it on my Mac. I shouldn't have to work around the operating system and / or the music apps to have my music files always played the best.

    Thanks for your kindest consideration of my post. Any good ideas are welcome!

    :-)

    ~Antonio

  2. 0

    dknightd

    Imported from the Apple Support Forums via the Wayback Machine 🔗

    Try turning off equilizer, sound enhancer, sound check. Then make sure itunes volume is set to max. Then itunes should sound the same as the finder playback

  3. 0

    666dorado

    Imported from the Apple Support Forums via the Wayback Machine 🔗

    i've done all those combinations, turning everything off sounds several decibels lower, nothing like the QT/Finder version....

  4. 0

    dknightd

    Imported from the Apple Support Forums via the Wayback Machine 🔗

    Do you have the volume turned up all the way in itunes (some people miss that slider adjustment near the top left of the iTunes). It might be a 10.6 issue, in which case I can't help you I'm still at 10.4 for now.

  5. 0

    ta

    Imported from the Apple Support Forums via the Wayback Machine 🔗

    What is the "raw" file you are playing before you import it into iTunes? And how are you importing it into iTunes?

  6. 0

    666dorado

    Imported from the Apple Support Forums via the Wayback Machine 🔗

    most of the files i'm ripping directly from CD or from FLAC files, VBR/CBR anything from 192-320 kbps.

    yes, i'm adjusting volume as well. seems that the closest i can get iTunes to sound to the original file as played from Finder is to turn off EQ, soundcheck and then jack the volume (iTunes volume) all the way up.

    i find that kind of strange that the default setting for files played from the Finder is the same or near iTunes with the volume all the way up.

  7. 0

    666dorado

    Imported from the Apple Support Forums via the Wayback Machine 🔗

    it's not a big deal, it's not that iTunes sounds "bad", it's just that i noticed the files were louder when played from the Finder.

    i don't always want to jack up my iTunes volume all the way up, sometimes in need my computer volume up relatively high when i'm listening to music so that my alerts and other program sounds can be heard over the music.

    it just seemed that iTunes was processing the sound and it seemed inferior to the default playback from Finder.

  8. 0

    ta

    Imported from the Apple Support Forums via the Wayback Machine 🔗

    666dorado wrote:

    most of the files i'm ripping directly from CD or from FLAC files, VBR/CBR anything from 192-320 kbps.

    I'm not sure I'm getting it yet, but it sounds like you are saying the cd or FLAC sounds better than the compressed version, which is what we would expect.

  9. 0

    dknightd

    Imported from the Apple Support Forums via the Wayback Machine 🔗

    The finder should be just sending the bits to the soundcard as is. iTunes (with EQ, sound enhancer, sound check off, and volume set to max) should do the same thing. It could be a result of you changing the files from lossless to mp3. To find out, you can try playing the mp3 in the finder (i.e. play the same sound file in both finder and iTunes)

    To get "best" sound quality out of iTunes you want all effects off, and volume set to max.

    You can adjust the volume of alert sounds using the "Sound" system preference panel.

  10. 0

    VyseLegend

    Imported from the Apple Support Forums via the Wayback Machine 🔗

    You're not crazy. I've compared audio in various formats in all media players, and nothing sounds right except for Quicktime, and a other 'pro' audio editing type applications. iTunes, Vox, and others are doing something to the music that is distorting it to a lower quality. I'm not sure if its a hardware issue or something else, I also have an MBP –2007 C2D. It would be cool not to have open each file individually to get proper playback 🙂.

    Message was edited by: VyseLegend

  11. 0

    VyseLegend

    Imported from the Apple Support Forums via the Wayback Machine 🔗

    Hmm so it turns out I was wrong. Solution was simple – go into Audio MIDI Setup application and make sure your output method is set to 2 channels, 16 bit, and which ever format you prefer. This solved my problem – for some reason Quicktime and other 'professional' apps seemed to be bypassing this separating the audio correctly on their own, while 'consumer' listening apps do not. Hope this helps.

  12. 0

    AffyJab

    Imported from the Apple Support Forums via the Wayback Machine 🔗

    I have been having the same issue and have found the 'finder sound' to be very "fat" with a deep richness and more "separated" stereo imaging. Listening to the same track at the same level (itunes turned all the way up, no sound check or any of the extra stuff on, no EQ), itunes sounds a little more mono or flat than the 'finder sound' almost like listening at a lower bitrate. My only guesses, are that 1. Itunes using using different codecs- or something similar- than the finder, or 2. Itunes has an internal limiter that is smushing the transients in the recording a little but makes up the gain or 3. Itunes plays back the stream in lower/different sampling rate or causes internal clocking errors when playing back.

    A user has also mentioned adjusting Audio MIDI settings, but I think those settings are only for Input, not Output, but it could be because I'm on 10.5.8.

    I will also echo that it also sounds better(the same as the finder) in Pro Tools and Logic as well.

  13. 0

    666dorado

    Imported from the Apple Support Forums via the Wayback Machine 🔗

    intersting.

    never messed with audio MIDI setup.

    the default output is 2 channel 24 bit.

    i thought more was better? why 16 bit to make it sound louder/better?

  14. 0

    enzee

    Imported from the Apple Support Forums via the Wayback Machine 🔗

    This problem is really driving me crazy. The difference between the Finder sound and iTunes is beyond dramatic. It's not only the level, but an overall richness, clarity and stereo imaging. Wow!

    What is happening and why is iTunes degrading the source like this. It is on every piece of music I throw at it. A CD would be the best reference as there is no conversion and it even happens on this.

    I have reference mixes for release and I always have to use the Finder to hear what something really sounds like.

    Anyone?

  15. 0

    0le0lson

    Imported from the Apple Support Forums via the Wayback Machine 🔗

    If you find anything out please let me know. The richness is quite different. I took an AIF file I saved through GarageBand. The AIF file sounded the same as GarageBand with Finder but the richness was gone in iTunes. (Drop and drag into iTunes or double click and launch iTunes to play). I also converted the file to a mp3. Again fine through Finder and richness gone with iTunes.

    This doesn't seem like a file format issue, more a player one since the same MP3 or AIF sounds good through Finder and GarageBand and not as "rich" in iTunes.

    Kind of crazy to me.