Benches Apps and software

2

iLife '09 image quality test

apple Verified

Imported from the Apple Support Forums via the Wayback Machine 🔗

I just spent the day doing an evaluation of image quality issues in making movies and DVDs with iMovie 8.0.5 and iDVD 7.0.4.

I made over 16 HD movie variations in iMovie that I used to make DVDs with iDVD 7.0.4

I chose three variations that were better than (or as good as) any of the other variations.

The 1920x1080 movies I made had lower quality in the DVD test than the 1280x720 movies.

For the 1280x720 movies I found the H.264. movie had the best quality followed closely by the AIC 720p movie and the Share>iDVD movie.

As expected, there was a very significant quality difference between the MPG-2 encoded files and the original movie files.

You can see the test at: http://homepage.mac.com/profpixel/text_testiLife09.html

I hope this helps answer some of the HD quality questions.

(Note: I have also posted this message in the iDVD (iLife '09) forum.)

2 replies

Sign in or join Beachball Help to reply.

  1. 0

    Apple Support Community member

    Imported from the Apple Support Forums via the Wayback Machine 🔗

    This test would be of value if you supplied missing information: camera, frame-size, frame-rate, recording codec, interlace/progressive, import parameters, export parameters, and time to export.

    If, which I kind of doubt, h.264 looked better than AIC, how many days did it take to export. Without a hardware encoder h.264 is a beast to encode -- especially if you use a 2-pass option. And, the more powerful the encoder -- the slower it will be.

    The reason I doubt h.264 looks better is that you are exporting to a a very low-bit rate mpeg-4 codec (and Apple's is not the best which makes things worse for h.264) which must be decoded in iDVD and then in iDVD recoded as long GOP mpeg-2. When you export to AIC, the video is being encoded a to high bit-rate I-frame mpeg-2 codec which is decoded and recorded to a long GOP mpeg-2 codec. In general, staying with the same codec is the best option.

    However, if your camera shoots h.264 then exporting h.264 keeps the same codec. So, doing this would meet the rule. So, knowing your camera has real importance.

    PS1: if you really want this workflow, buy a Turbo64 hardware encoder!

    PS2: I'm not surprised 720p30 looked best as iMovie is optimal for 720p and 540p. And, with MOST consumer camcorders, there is no more fine detail in 1080i than in 720p!

  2. 0

    Apple Support Community member

    Imported from the Apple Support Forums via the Wayback Machine 🔗

    Steve,

    I guess you didn't read the referenced web page; it would have made things clear. There was NO camera involved in the test. The short clips were all made in iMovie 8.0.5 using still images with text produced in Photoshop.

    The intent was primarily to show what the best possible way to produce title text on DVDs using the iLife '09 applications.

    The text in the AIC movie looked slightly sharper than the text in the H.264 movie. However, when MPG-2 encoded at Best Performance by iDVD 7.0.4 the H.264 text looked slightly better than the AIC text. Look at the web page and see for yourself.