Benches Apps and software

6

iMovie 9 quality problem, investigation

apple Verified

Imported from the Apple Support Forums via the Wayback Machine 🔗

I'm really confused where the iMovie image problem is coming from. As with most of Apple's data files you can right click on any iMovie project to check out whats inside and strange enough it stores movies and images in full quality.

I have tried to render the same photo in iMovie 5 HD, iMovie 9, FinalCut Pro 7 and PulpMotion and only iMovie 9 displays the weird posterization in dark gradient areas. It also seems to have a problem with the colours.

So now what? iMovie 9 has fun themes, is very easy to use, great features but I can't get decent results with still photos. Other applications and versions do great export but miss features or are cumbersome to use. Anyone got any suggestions?

User uploaded file

6 replies

Sign in or join Beachball Help to reply.

  1. 0

    Ziatron

    Imported from the Apple Support Forums via the Wayback Machine 🔗

    I have tried to render the same photo in iMovie 5 HD, iMovie 9, FinalCut Pro 7 and PulpMotion and only iMovie 9 displays the weird posterization in dark gradient areas.

    I have spent many hours trying (and re-trying) all the iMovie 09 quality "work arounds" but my DVDs never look as good as when I use iMovie 06 with iDVD 09. With iMovie 06 you don't have to "work around" anything, you alway get a lossless result, with very little effort.

    iMovie 06 and iDVD 09 is a "lossless" combination and my home DVD's look like they came from Hollywood!

    Mac Pro and MacBook, White of course 🙂

  2. 0

    Gerard Van Schip

    Imported from the Apple Support Forums via the Wayback Machine 🔗

    Thing is, I like the themes in iMovie 9. Cant remember if 6 had any but 5 is very very minimal on the feature set. Also, where am I going to get my hands on iMovie 6?

  3. 0

    Steve Mullen

    Imported from the Apple Support Forums via the Wayback Machine 🔗

    "As with most of Apple's data files you can right click on any iMovie project to check out whats inside and strange enough it stores movies and images in full quality."

    One look at your iM09 pix and it was obvious the problem was the compression used. My guess it is looked like MPEG-4 used for "previews." Sure enough it was.

    You are thinking iM09 works like iM06. But, you don't understand how iM09 works. Nothing that will be exported is ever stored inside iM09. It's fully real-time from the source file to the export file.

    Which means your comment "... it stores movies and images in full quality" is wrong."

    There are NO quality problems with photos in iM09. This has been proved over and over.

  4. 0

    Ziatron

    Imported from the Apple Support Forums via the Wayback Machine 🔗

    Also, where am I going to get my hands on iMovie 6?

    Easy,

    You can get iMovie 06 in a number of ways. You cannot download it FROM APPLE any longer. You can also find iMovie 06 on the iLife 06 install disc. You can buy iLife 06 on Amazon or eBay.

    But be prepared to pay about double the cost of iLife 09 (but well worth every penny). Seller's are becoming aware of its value.

  5. 0

    Gerard Van Schip

    Imported from the Apple Support Forums via the Wayback Machine 🔗

    I never said iMovie stores what it exports in the file. I'm trying to troubleshoot so was trying to eliminate causes for the bad image quality. Seeing the imported images are still of good quality inside the iMovie project file there is no problem with the importer.

    I have just done my test again, created a 1280 x 720 file from a high res photo, imported that straight into iMovie 9 and Final Cut Express. Then exported from both the projects, both with highest setting and both 1280 x 720 and no video effects. I should get the same image. I do in Final Cut Express but not in iMovie 9, there is a world of difference.

    You tell me how I can avoid this?

    User uploaded file

  6. 0

    Steve Mullen

    Imported from the Apple Support Forums via the Wayback Machine 🔗

    You said, "I have tried to render the same photo."

    Now you say "... created a 1280 x 720 file from a high res photo."

    Seems like two very different situations. Especially if you created a video file.

    In any case, there is only a slight brightness and color difference, but nothing major. No color banding or compression artifacts. The brightness/color difference is because iM honors the luminance limit of 100IRE while FCE does not. Simply color correct the photos -- if you REALLY care to get an exact match.