Benches Apps and software

3

Confused by PAL aspect ratio

apple Verified

Imported from the Apple Support Forums via the Wayback Machine 🔗

Hi,

I'm creating an animation from a series of CGI stills to be eventually outputted as a DV-PAL quicktime movie for use on a DVD to be played on a PAL system.

I'm struggling to understand what aspect ratio I should be saving my stills as - the table and instructions on pages 796-798 of the FCE manual suggest I should start with a still at 4:3 ratio (768 x 576 pixels), and then squash it to 720 x 576 pixels to compensate for PAL stretching it in the other direction during export.

However, when I bring the clips into my sequence, they don't match the aspect ratio of the sequence on the canvas (which seems to be 4:3). The end result seems to be a pillarbox effect of the final animation, rather than seeing the stills stretched back to 4:3 ratio.

Do I also need to set up the aspect ratio of the sequence to match my converted files? Or is there a way of applying PAL's aspect ratio to the clip once it's in Final Cut Express?

Any help gratefully received!!

Derek

3 replies

Sign in or join Beachball Help to reply.

  1. 0

    Tom Wolsky

    Imported from the Apple Support Forums via the Wayback Machine 🔗

    I'm assuming you're working in standard 4:3 format sequence.

    What application are you using to create the stills and what pixel aspect ratio is it using? If you're working square pixels and pre-squeeze the images it should work correctly.

  2. 0

    ilucena

    Imported from the Apple Support Forums via the Wayback Machine 🔗

    i never tried so it's not 100% sure, but this would be the way i would do and i am pretty sure it will work.

    if your final goal format is PAL what you should import the animation with a 4:3 ratio (768x576).

    then export from the FC export as quicktime movie and then load it on idvd or dvd studio pro. this programs will automatically encode your video to PAL or NTSC (you can choose between this two) with the 720x576 you want.

    or you can export to quicktime conversion and choose DV stream -> PAL and then import to idvd or DvdSP, thus you will loose resolution because you are converting and compressing several times, so for better results export to quicktime movie.

    tell us if it worked 😉

    cheers!

    Message was edited by: ilucena

  3. 0

    Derek Jackson1

    Imported from the Apple Support Forums via the Wayback Machine 🔗

    I think I've sorted it - I told FCE that the stills have PAL aspect ratio, whereas it was importing them with square aspect ratio as standard. They now fill the canvas and it looks fine when playing.

    Thanks for the help!

    Derek