Imported from the Apple Support Forums via the Wayback Machine 🔗
I just used the new "Movie to iPod 320 x 240" export setting with a 720 x 480 NTSC DV clip and I noticed that the finished video was 320 x 213 rather than the correct aspect of 320 x 240. Could have just been a fluke or something with my particular sample of video but it's interesting that the difference between 240 and 213 is the same as the ratio between 720 and 640. Thus, it almost looks like they are ignoring the standard aspect ratio correction that should be applied when converting from DV's rectangular pixels to a computer's square pixels.
This may have something to do with file extensions since I read recently that QuickTime 7 treats the scaling of DV differently depending on whether the extension is .dv or .mov or something else. That would be odd and somewhat unfortunate since they should be able to determine the correct scaling by looking at the codec type of the movie which in my case is clearly DV/DVCPRO NTSC as reported by the Finder's get info panel.
In any case, this may be something that needs to be checked if you are converting your own DV movies for the iPod. Can anyone else confirm this behavior?
Imported from the Apple Support Forums via the Wayback Machine 🔗
Okay, I've run some more tests and the 320 x 213 resize is consistent in both the QuickTime Pro Player and iMovie HD. If confirmed by other users I'd call this a pretty serious problem.
The workaround on my system is to resize the DV to 640 x 480 before you export (that works in the QuickTime Pro Player). However, I don't know if the latter would work with iMovie HD since they already do the 4:3 aspect ratio correction when they display the movie. But, as I mentioned earlier it appears that the "Movie to iPod 320 x 240" export ignores that correction since the share from iMovie also had an incorrect aspect ratio (i.e. the exported .m4v movie size was 320 x 213 rather than the correct 320 x 240).
I'm running on Tiger with the QuickTime 7.0.3 update.
0
Apple Support Community member·
Imported from the Apple Support Forums via the Wayback Machine 🔗
when using this export feature in quicktime does anyone notice how long it takes to export the movie it seemes like for a very short movie it is taking a very long time.
0
Apple Support Community member·
Imported from the Apple Support Forums via the Wayback Machine 🔗
Man..I should have checked these posts BEFORE i started cranking a 9 minute thing I did thats a full quality DV fiile into an IPod file for a test..Its taking a long time--2 plus hrs and only half done and i hope its the correct ratio!
0
Apple Support Community member·
Imported from the Apple Support Forums via the Wayback Machine 🔗
Mine was also 320x213..but i suspect that is the HD aspect ratio so it will try converting first to 640x480
0
Apple Support Community member·
Imported from the Apple Support Forums via the Wayback Machine 🔗
Mine was also 320x213...
Seems to be confirmed then, that's unfortunate. I suspect that this is going to fowl up a lot of novice users who just want to convert their DV to iPod movies. They should have made it easy for those people, now everyone is going to wonder why they look ten to twenty pounds heavier (wider) in their iPod movies.
One further issue, how will these display on the iPod's TV output? Will they letterbox the video or just expand the image to fit the 4:3 aspect ratio of the TV. If the latter, then the aspect ratio will be corrected but you'll lose a little quality since they'll be scaling the image even more than they would for a 320 x 240 video.
0
Apple Support Community member·
Imported from the Apple Support Forums via the Wayback Machine 🔗
I have crunched lots of movies for web..I looked at the ones I've produced in 320x240 already for web wbworks.com/tornadochase.mov for an example already compressed and in 32x240 size.. i swiped that into iTunes and it plays.
The question is why cant the iPod play existing mov files --which are smaller in size anyway-- or can it???..since i don;t have the new one..and not many do.. I would like to know the answer cause it will save me alot of headaches
0
Apple Support Community member·
Imported from the Apple Support Forums via the Wayback Machine 🔗
I think the new iPods won't be out for another week to ten days. So, you'll have to wait until then to find out if they can play existing H.264 and/or MPEG4 at lower bit rates.
0
Apple Support Community member·
Imported from the Apple Support Forums via the Wayback Machine 🔗
The iPod and its TV output may correct for this problem by forcing the output to 4:3 but I expect that that could have a mild effect on quality and performance since the iPod would have to scale the video up to 320 x 240 during playback.
In any case, it would be better to have the native size 320 x 240 so that the correct 4:3 aspect ratio is maintained. Apple should probably think about changing this.
0
Apple Support Community member·
Imported from the Apple Support Forums via the Wayback Machine 🔗
I was real excited about the announcement yesterday..but have tempered my expectations till I see what this new gizmo can really do. Because Ive been doing this for years...I am slightly skeptical..nice to have the export to iPod choice..not sure whether i am sold yet/jd
0
Apple Support Community member·
Imported from the Apple Support Forums via the Wayback Machine 🔗
Has anyone found out anything new about this? i've already encoded around 10 hours of content and just realized it's all 320x213! as long as the iPod will correct this and strech it to fill the screen, i'm OK with that. I can't imagine it wouldn't since they know this is something many people would be doing. The other intersting thing is, even the few videos i downloaded from iTunes, are all different sizes. the U2 video Beautiful Day is 320x224?
0
Apple Support Community member·
Imported from the Apple Support Forums via the Wayback Machine 🔗
I no longer think that the iPod will resize the 320 x 213 movies to the correct 4:3 aspect ratio. I've downloaded a few movies from iTMS and I see that they also offer 16:9 aspect ratios and thus the iPod will probably just letterbox anything that isn't 320 x 240. That probably means that the DV you've converted will be shown in a letterbox and thus will be slightly distorted. It's only about 10% in error so you may not even notice it. The workaround is to resize the DV to 640 x 480 before you do the iPod export.
0
Apple Support Community member·
Imported from the Apple Support Forums via the Wayback Machine 🔗
actually, i've thought about it too and i agree. another workaround i found other than resizing the DV to 640x480 is to just take the 320x213 movies and resize them to 320x240 and resave as a self-contained movie. i know i'll be losing a little bit of quality, but i have encoded 148 files already and it's taken me all weekend, and i can't even think right now of having to do that all over! thanks for the input.
0
Apple Support Community member·
Imported from the Apple Support Forums via the Wayback Machine 🔗
While it's true that the iPod will display with a letterbox, the problem of DV-iPod is that the pixel aspect ratio is affected. This means that the image will appear distorted. The workaround I did was to convert the DV file to a MOV with Apple Motion JPEG at 320x240 & then use the export to ipod option.
0
Apple Support Community member·
Imported from the Apple Support Forums via the Wayback Machine 🔗
The workaround I did was to convert the DV file to a MOV with Apple Motion JPEG at 320x240 & then use the export to ipod option.
But that's a lot more work than simply setting the display size of the DV to 640 x 480 before you export to iPhoto 320 x 240. Note that you don't have to save or export the DV file to 640 x 480, you just set the display size to 640 x 480 under the movie properties dialog (it's non-destructive, temporary, and can be done in only a few seconds).