Benches Apple TV

7

HDMI output stays on when Apple TV on standby

apple Verified

Imported from the Apple Support Forums via the Wayback Machine 🔗

Since I got my Apple TV, I have an annoying situation (well actually it annoys my wife more than me) regarding the HDMI output from the Apple TV.

When I switch on the TV (Panasonic 42" plasma) it flicks to the Apple TV HDMI input, then my Satellite SCART input and then back to the Apple TV HDMI input. Unless I actually wanted the Apple TV I then have to manually switch the TV to the satellite AV input or flick the satellite off/on to get the TV to auto-switch to the sat AV input.

It does this even though the Apple TV is in standby mode. I cannot find any setting in the Apple TV menus to switch off the HDMI output when the Apple TV is in standby.

If I power the Apple TV off then switch the TV on, it comes straight up on the Sat AV input.

7 replies

Sign in or join Beachball Help to reply.

  1. 0

    Alley_Cat

    Imported from the Apple Support Forums via the Wayback Machine 🔗

    I have exactly the same issue with one of my plasmas - again a Panasonic 42".

    It didn't always do this, I think one of the later updates altered HDMI negotiation.

    The AppleTV standby mode is a bit of a red herring in the conventional sense - it outputs a black screen rather than being a sleep mode, and background syncing tasks can still occur if needed, so it doesn't save much energy.

    I bought my father a refurbished AppleTV and it does exactly the same on his Panasonic 37" plasma - it annoys him and confuses my mother so much they've unplugged the unit for good - you probably experience the same issue of a bit of a game with the remote to change to what you want and stop it repeatedly changing back to AppleTV.

    I have another Panasonic plasma with another AppleTV running 2.2 that I refuse to update as it's working well (the other has random audio dropouts/glitches) - this channel hogging behaviour does not occur with that model of TV.

    It's either AppleTV's HDMI implementation, the TV's or both.

    I don't know of any solution other than to connect by component and a pair of stereo RCA leads for audio.

    AC

  2. 0

    idfitter

    Imported from the Apple Support Forums via the Wayback Machine 🔗

    Actually I've since found a workaround by plugging the Apple TV into HDMI2 which does not auto-switch. I can use HDMI1 when I get a Blu Ray which presumably will understand that the output should turn off when the unit does.

  3. 0

    Alley_Cat

    Imported from the Apple Support Forums via the Wayback Machine 🔗

    I'll try that thanks - I've often suggested that for other HDMI quirks but haven't tried on this setup myself!

  4. 0

    flintonmac

    Imported from the Apple Support Forums via the Wayback Machine 🔗

    Same problem here on a Sony 42" Yet another oversight from the apple design team. As 3 members of the family watch the same TV I have no option but to use the a/v connection instead of the HDMI welcome to the future apple...

  5. 0

    idfitter

    Imported from the Apple Support Forums via the Wayback Machine 🔗

    Not 'answered' but since the workaround works...

  6. 0

    Goshawk29

    Imported from the Apple Support Forums via the Wayback Machine 🔗

    Had the same issue. Good comments about ATV sending 'black' screen. ATV does not power off. Yes states it has sleep or hibernation mode but this is not true. Because of this, there still is a signal going through HDMI cable. With newer model TV's, and HDMI ports and logic, many TV's have "auto" switching or sensing of input and switch automatically. You can simply find this feature on your TV and disable it.

    I have a Panasonic Plasma and auto switching feature was default on.

  7. 0

    Easybourne

    Imported from the Apple Support Forums via the Wayback Machine 🔗

    My TV is a Samsung, and I had all sorts of HDMI issues when I first got my Apple TV (as did a great many other Samsung TV owners).

    I had to go into the service menu to turn off an option called 'HotPlug', which I presume is much the same as the user-accessible 'auto-switching' option on the Panasonics - though this seems to affect all inputs not just 'HDMI 1' as per the HDMI specification.

    Ever since I switched off 'hotplug' I've had no HDMI issues. In fact, a while back I had my TV repaired for an unrelated fault which required the entire mother board to be replaced, and I mentioned the hotplug thing to the engineer and he told me that he routinely switches off hotplug for people that have issues with consoles, Apple TVs etc.

    Basically, the HDMI spec is a bit of a mess, with more attention being paid to how to cripple the signal (because naturally everyone is a pirate) than is being paid to achieve even the same level of connectivity and auto-pullup functions that SCART provided 15-20 years ago.